Listen

Description

This video summary highlights the critical issue of water security in Southern Alberta, highlighting the impact of drought and various land use activities on water sources. Colin emphasizes the importance of protecting the Eastern Slopes and Southern Alberta’s water sources, noting that without water, essential industries like agriculture, oil, and beer production would suffer. The conversation also touches on the ecological services provided by watersheds and the need for restoration and sustainable management practices. Various speakers express concerns about the effects of gravel pits on water quality and the environment, with specific examples of contamination and inadequate regulatory responses. The discussion underscores the need for community involvement, better regulatory practices, and learning from successful models in other regions to address these environmental challenges effectively.

Highlights from the conversations on “Who’s Who in the Zoo?” with Colin Smith (11), Gerry Bietz (9), Muriel Wynnobel, Lyse Carignan, Neil Konner, Joyce Kyncl, Christina McCharles, Jody Young, Adele McKechnie, Dale Christian, Mark Dorin (12) and Shantel Sherwood (13).

Colin Smith – Cooperative Solar Developer | Land Lover | Bioregional Organizer

Yes, something that was said, I went to the Dried Up documentary, a 30-minute short film about the state of the drought in Southern Alberta made by Kevin Van Tighem and a few others. The best long-term investment we can make is in the water security of the Eastern Slopes and Southern Alberta. I’ve been reflecting on these terms. If you have no water, we have no beer, we have no beef, we have no oil, we have no economy and no life if we damage our water sources. And yeah, Jenny, you asked me to talk about the is this 10-kilometer strip that is essentially the source of 95% of all of the water in Southern Alberta and areas like Banff and Kananaskis, there’s no extraction and those forests are intact, almost too intact, and the other regions are over- forested.

There’s oil and gas, there are roads, there’s cattle, and all these things drastically affect the ecological services that watersheds to store and filter water for our major cities, for agriculture, for oil and gas extraction, for making beer with climate change, with land use decisions, we are on a trajectory to have a lot less water. I don’t think your average Albertan is feeling it, but farmers, ranchers, municipal decision-makers, the oil and gas industry, and all these people who require water to make their jobs and their responsibilities work are worried. We were originally calling for a moratorium and policy, but we are now advocating for the restoration of headwaters and ecosystem services and the headwaters. All this stuff I’ve said is a lot of doom and gloom, but I think the key part to shifting the tide is inspiring people with a vision of a brighter future and how they can get involved. There’s a lot of work to be done like actual hands-on work, but also organizing and changing our mindsets and speaking with our friends and family about the situation, but also giving them, providing opportunities. So something

Gerry Bietz – Big Hills Springs Preservation Society | Rocky View County Aggregate Resource Committee Member

People cannot appreciate, the open spaces and the natural environment unless they have the opportunity to experience it and go to our website, and visit the park. There’s a road allowance that extends from Cochrane up to the park. It’s a public road allowance and if people are inclined to walk up there, it’s available for walking. It’s bordered on both sides by private lands and so if people are inclined to walk up there, we’d encourage them to make sure that they respect that private land. It’s only 70 acres. It sees a quarter of a million people a year or more. It needs to be recognized that it needs to be protected, it needs to be expanded because it’s being loved to death. It needs further respect. We’ve put up on our website a map that illustrates the potential gravel production that we’ll see out of this area over the next 40 years because gravel production is an extended process from the gravel industry’s perspective. It’s a short-term enterprise, but it’s terminal. We won’t see the end of these gravel operations in our lifetime and I don’t suspect my children will see the end of them when these gravel operations are complete. There could be up to a thousand acres of depressions up to 25 meters deep and many of them I believe will have pit lakes, which means their depressions collect water. Then whatever contaminants reside on that landscape floor in the groundwater.

Muriel Wynnobel – Big Hills Springs Resident | Preservation Advocate

We live right adjoining practically the prospective gravel pits next to Big Hills Springs Provincial Park six that are immediately next to the headwaters of the Big Hill Springs Provincial Park. The one that has been approved and is under appeal right now, both by the Preservation Society and myself and some others. It’s 800 meters away from the headwaters of the spring. These springs feed the big Hill Creek, which then empties into the Bow River, so we’re talking pristine water number four or something spring in Canada, so it’s very important Spring, the rocky view just said go ahead and now it went to Alberta Environmental Protection and they approved it and there have been appeals and the Preservation society went for a stay so as they wouldn’t, but they allowed them to start anyway. There are 13 wetlands on that one piece of property, the one mountain ash property and that’s being allowed to just be wiped out to make a berm to protect from dust and that to our properties, not the park, but everything that goes before the board or before the county and then EPA says, “It’s okay, they’ll monitor and if it contaminates the water, well, then they’ll be asked to stop at that point”, but water doesn’t be decontaminated that easily and the board has said that stopping Mount Nash would be too sort of expensive or difficult for or something like they shouldn’t have started in the first place.

Lyse Carignan – Big Hills Springs Preservation Society Member | Resident

They dug a berm and they said they couldn’t allow a stay because they had already done the work. There was an ARP meeting and then the county, the group was supposed to reach a consensus and they only reached, agreed on three points between the industry and them, but the industry does not believe in setbacks. We talked about being 800 meters from the headwater one meter down. They don’t believe in this. The group thought they should provide some money, increase the levy from 40 cents per ton of gravel, but give it to the group so they don’t want to support these groups at all. Also, there was no agreement at all on cumulative impacts. Interesting. As Rocky View County had done a biophysical attribute rating, rating, the biodiversity, the water and so on. In 2003, this wasn’t provided to the group or the council.

Jody Young – Red Deer County Resident

We have some private pits by us as well as a musical gravel pit. We are in Red Deer County and in our situation we’ve ended up having multiple public hearings. In 2020, they passed it and added the land beside us into the gravel overlay district. We were told the same as Dale and Adele that we had no appeal option. What ended up happening was about two weeks after the bylaw got overturned, they reapplied for the same bylaw and we dealt with that for another two years, came up under three different bylaws and then in July of last year, the council ended up voting because we’re immediately adjacent to the Red Deer River and the land beside us has been designated as an environmentally significant area and there were concerns given its proximity to our water well that we would lose our water. Well in 2022 we discovered our water well was contaminated During this whole process.

It was unknown what the cause was, but …



Get full access to The Gravity Well with Jenny Yeremiy at www.thegravitywell.net/subscribe