Listen

Description

Welcome back to the Dialectical Sandbox, the impromptu theoretical deep-dive of the Resistance is Fertile podcast! In this episode, Comrade Alkmi and Comrade Benji (libérationpsy) return to the chalkboard to continue unpacking the materialist dialectic. If last week was about introducing the concept of sublation, this week is about sublating the sublation—digging into the mechanics of how the old gives birth to the new, and what that means for revolutionary practice, clinical psychology, and the natural sciences.

🌍 The Clinical and the Cosmic: Identity as Sublation

Benji kicks off the practical applications by bridging Marxist-Leninist dialectics with his clinical psychology practice. How do we help individuals dismantle the “seeming necessity” of their own histories? Benji explains that therapeutic growth is essentially a dialectical negation: we don’t delete our past (that’s metaphysical deletion), we sublate it. We overcome our blind puppetry to historical trauma, retain the lessons and the history itself, and forge a new self-determined identity on a higher level, based on the equal fundamental worth of all humans.

🦅 Freedom, Necessity, and the Geometry of Change

Alkmi takes the mic to dismantle Western, Eurocentric hang-ups around “absolute freedom” and “determinism.” Drawing on global majority philosophical traditions and materialist dialectics, Alkmi breaks down the dialectic of spontaneity and determination. Freedom isn’t the ability to ignore the laws of physics or society; freedom is the recognition of external necessity. By reflecting the objective laws of the material world through practice, we gain the agency to work within—and eventually overcome—our constraints.

Thanks for reading Resistance is Fertile! This post is public so feel free to share it.

🐺 The Wolf, The Rabbit, and the Coffee Cup

What does sublation actually look like in the material world? Alkmi provides vivid, grounded examples:

* The Seed and the Flower: The flower negates the seed, but retains the plant’s life-form.

* The Wolf and the Rabbit: Contrasting the Western/metaphysical view of “deletion” (the wolf destroys the rabbit) with the dialectical, relational view of indigenous metabolisms (the wolf and rabbit mutually impact each other; the rabbit’s energy is inherited and carried forward into the “full wolf”).

* The Coffee Cup: The transition from a full cup to an empty cup is a quality shift that overcomes the cup’s previous state of potentiality.

🔬 Dialectical Materialism: The Ultimate Philosophy of Science

A major portion of this episode is dedicated to defending dialectical materialism against the charge that it is “unscientific.” Alkmi and Benji trace the roots of Engels’ and Marx’s dialectics directly to the great scientific leaps of the 19th century: cell theory, the conservation of mass and energy, and evolution. Dialectical materialism was born as the necessary philosophical framework to unify the empirical data of the natural sciences. It is not opposed to science; it is the general science of motion, proving that the objective universe and human thought are governed by the exact same dialectical laws.

Resistance is Fertile is 100% free. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber (all money paid sent to Gaza families with a boost of between 50% and 75%, receipts published on here).

🌀 The Spiral and the Methodology of Organizing

Finally, we arrive at the Law of Negation of Negation and its ultimate geometric abstraction: The Spiral. Change is not a straight line, nor is it a closed circle. It is an ascending spiral where things tend to return to their starting point, but on a fundamentally higher level. Alkmi uses the lifecycle of aluminum (Raw Rock ➡️ Soda Can ➡️ Recycled Aluminum) to illustrate this.

The Methodological Takeaway: Negations are objective (they happen whether we want them to or not) and they possess inheritance. As revolutionaries and organizers, our job is not to be against change, nor is it to magically erase the past. Our job is to consciously analyze the material conditions, filter out the reactionary elements of the old, and consciously guide the inheritance of the new to build a socialist, decolonized future.

📢 Housekeeping & Solidarity:

* Gaza Fundraiser: This week’s fundraiser is for Khaled in Gaza. We are just a few dollars short of our $1,000 goal. Please donate at the link below!

https://chuffed.org/project/171433-save-khaled-and-his-six-children-in-gaza

* Next Week: Join us for a special geek-out session with Gabriel Rochhill to discuss his use of the dialectical method!

* Reading Material: Pick up the Vietnamese Marxist-Leninist curriculum, translated by Comrade Luna Oi, available for free (ebook) or $20 (paperback) at Banyan House Publishing.

https://www.banyanhouse.org/product/ebook-the-worldview-and-philosophical-methodology-of-marxism-leninism/

🕒 Episode Timeline

00:00:00 - Welcome, Housekeeping, and the Gaza Fundraiser00:03:37 - Alkmi’s Introduction and the Vietnamese Marxist-Leninist Framework00:09:20 - The Definition of Dialectical Negation vs. Formal Logic00:14:40 - Clinical Psychology Parallels: Identity, History, and Sublation00:19:20 - The Dialectic of Freedom, Necessity, and Determination00:24:00 - Spontaneity and the Recognition of External Laws00:26:40 - Internal Contradictions Drive Change; External Conditions Condition It00:31:00 - Concrete Examples of Sublation: Seeds, Adults, and Coffee Cups00:34:10 - The Wolf and the Rabbit: Relational Metabolism vs. Western Deletion00:40:50 - Dialectical Materialism as the Unifying Philosophy of Science00:51:40 - The Three Laws of Change: Contradiction, Quantity/Quality, Negation00:56:10 - Metaphysical vs. Dialectical Categories and the Critique of Postmodernism01:06:10 - Engels, Cell Theory, and the Unity of Epistemology, Logic, and Dialectics01:23:00 - The Law of Negation of Negation: Affirming vs. Negating Tendencies01:28:30 - The Spiral of Development and Methodological Takeaways for Organizing

Free Palestine. Swift and ever-swifter victories to the free peoples of the world and the resistance.

NB: Summary and timeline drafted with help from Qwen AI

Call to Action

This week’s highlighted Gaza fundraiser is for Khaled:https://chuffed.org/project/171433-save-khaled-and-his-six-children-in-gaza

🔗 Pledge a monthly donation to Sameer Project: https://chuffed.org/project/149178-sameer-project-x-mass-displacement-campaign

🔗 Support material resistance: Lifeline for Gaza

Follow Resistance is Fertile on Substack for unfiltered analysis and updates

Share this episode – narrative warfare is everyone’s fight

https://lifeline4gaza.com/

Palestinian-Run Mutual Aid (independent of the imperial NGO-military complex)

Help Gazans provide essential services to Gazans with the Sameer Project.

Contribute to the Abu Hureirah Network, launched by our friend Hamza to support mutual aid groups in Gaza and Sudan.

Or contribute to Benji’s Gaza fundraisers

For Omar and his family of seven: ⁠https://bit.ly/omargaza⁠

For Ibrahim, his wife, newborn baby and extended family! ⁠https://bit.ly/IbrahimGaza⁠

For a pregnant lady and her family: ⁠https://bit.ly/PregnantMotherGaza⁠

For Mustafa in North Gaza: ⁠https://bit.ly/MustafaGaza⁠

For Khaled and his six children: https://bit.ly/khaledinGaza

You can also support

Doctors against Genocide

Palestine Trauma Centre

RIF Linktree https://linktr.ee/resistanceisfertile

Share with siblings and comrades who believe another world is not only necessary, but already in motion.

Thank you Thank you Aswa, Ellen, and many others for tuning into our live video!



Get full access to Resistance is Fertile at resistanceisfertilepodcast.substack.com/subscribe