Listen

Description

What started as an unannounced, off-the-cuff live session of Dialectical Sandbox of RIF Podcast turned into a philosophically rich conversation as Benji and Alkmi got down and dirty in the dialectical sandbox to untangle one of the most misunderstood and overloaded terms in Western Marxist discourse: sublation.

The spark? A commenter on a previous broadcast asked how we should “sublate” Critical Theory, or to be precise Adorno’s Negative dialectics — and Benji had opinions. Strong ones. But rather than just riff, he chose to invite the better half of dialectical sandbox Alkmi, decolonial student of Marxism-Leninism of Okinawan, Japanese, and Korean diaspora background, whose understanding of dialectical materialism was fundamentally reshaped by the Vietnamese Marixsm-Leninism curriculum.

That’s right. A textbook written by 30 PhDs, used to teach dialectical materialism to Vietnamese students, provided the scaffolding that cleared years of cobwebs around concepts like sublation, dialectical negation, and the negation of the negation. As Alkmi puts it: “It was created by 30 people. So it’s going to be better than any one single person’s definition anyway, right?”

Thanks for reading Resistance is Fertile! This post is public so feel free to share it.

The core of the episode is deceptively simple: sublation and dialectical negation are the same thing. The confusion isn’t definitional — it’s discursive. The word “sublation” carries Hegelian baggage in the West that obscures what is, in materialist dialectics, a straightforward concept: something old gives way to something new, and that new thing carries the birthmarks of what came before. That’s it. That’s sublation. That’s dialectical negation.

But the conversation doesn’t stop at philosophical housekeeping. Alkmi and Benji push into the objective and subjective dimensions of dialectics — the difference between sublations that happen in the material world regardless of our intervention (caterpillars becoming butterflies, atoms bonding, humans dying while their ideas persist) and the sublations we consciously choose to pursue through praxis. And here’s where it gets political in the most grounded sense: which sublations you choose to do is a question of your class position and your political values.

“We’re communists. We want to encourage the sublations that get us to a classless, stateless society. We need to leverage all the other sublations that do not or can be managed until then.”

The episode also tackles common misfires in online Marxist discourse — like asking “can you sublate China?” or “can you sublate capitalism?” — with Alkmi gently but firmly arguing that these questions are misguided because they treat sublation as something you optionally do to a thing, rather than recognizing that everything is already sublated, constantly, because everything is changing. The real question is never whether sublation happens. It’s which sublations you align with and work toward.

Resistance is Fertile is 100% free. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber (all money paid sent to Gaza families with a boost of between 50% and 75%, receipts published on here).

Along the way, there’s a discussion of Adorno’s negative dialectics, Lenin’s distinctions between skepticism, eclecticism, and genuine dialectics, the relationship between formal logic and dialectical logic (one doesn’t negate the other — it’s sublated under it), and a constant focus on fundraising for mutual aid in Gaza. Because what’s the point of understanding dialectics if you’re not using it to materially those materially fighting genocidal imperialism, if only by existing?

The tone throughout is warm, playful, and deeply comradely. Benji and Alkmi interrupt each other constantly — not out of disrespect, but out of the kind of intellectual excitement that only happens when two people are genuinely building something together in real time. As Alkmi says, “I’m not going to disagree with everything he’s saying. And I won’t necessarily agree with everything he’s saying. In the spirit of sublation, I’ll raise this to a higher level by taking the best of what he said and developing it.”

This is an episode for anyone who’s ever felt lost in the jargon of dialectical materialism, anyone who’s rolled their eyes at the word “sublate” in a YouTube comment section, and anyone who wants to understand why these concepts actually matter — not as abstract philosophy, but as tools for understanding how change happens and how we can orient ourselves within it.

“Everything’s a sublation because everything’s changing. It doesn’t matter what the f**k you’re talking about.”

Episode Timeline

00:00 | Welcome to an Impromptu Live Dialectical Sandbox06:15 | Geek Out Central: The Comment That Sparked This Episode09:51 | Meet Alchemy: A Decolonial Student of Marxism-Leninism14:15 | Demystifying Negation: Western Metaphysics vs. Eastern Dialectics22:36 | The Baggage of “Sublation” and the Jargon Problem28:28 | Formal Logic vs. Dialectical Logic35:43 | Sublation as a Material Process, Not Just a Concept37:11 | Two Conversations: Philosophical Definitions vs. Sociopolitical Praxis46:01 | Lenin on Skepticism, Eclecticism, and the Spiral of Development52:01 | The Unity of Opposites: Master/Slave and Either/Or vs. Both/And01:01:30 | Circles vs. Spirals: Indigenous Cosmologies and Historical Materialism01:12:30 | Objective vs. Subjective Dialectics in the Real World01:18:07 | Clarifying the Two Meanings of “Negation” in Dialectics01:24:50 | Sublation and Dialectical Negation Are the Same Thing01:27:30 | Choosing Our Sublations: Class Position, Politics, and Liberation

Free Palestine. Swift and ever-swifter victories to the free peoples of the world and the resistance.

NB: Summary and timeline drafted with help from Qwen AI

Call to Action

This week’s highlighted Gaza fundraiser is for Ibrahim:https://chuffed.org/project/134655-help-ibrahim-his-baby-and-his-pregnant-wife-survive-the-genocide

🔗 Pledge a monthly donation to Sameer Project: https://chuffed.org/project/149178-sameer-project-x-mass-displacement-campaign

🔗 Support material resistance: Lifeline for Gaza

Follow Resistance is Fertile on Substack for unfiltered analysis and updates

Share this episode – narrative warfare is everyone’s fight

https://lifeline4gaza.com/

Palestinian-Run Mutual Aid (independent of the imperial NGO-military complex)

Help Gazans provide essential services to Gazans with the Sameer Project.

Contribute to the Abu Hureirah Network, launched by our friend Hamza to support mutual aid groups in Gaza and Sudan.

Or contribute to Benji’s Gaza fundraisers

For Omar and his family of seven: ⁠https://bit.ly/omargaza⁠

For Ibrahim, his wife, newborn baby and extended family! ⁠https://bit.ly/IbrahimGaza⁠

For a pregnant lady and her family: ⁠https://bit.ly/PregnantMotherGaza⁠

For Mustafa in North Gaza: ⁠https://bit.ly/MustafaGaza⁠

For Khaled and his six children: https://bit.ly/khaledinGaza

You can also support

Doctors against Genocide

Palestine Trauma Centre

RIF Linktree https://linktr.ee/resistanceisfertile

Share with siblings and comrades who believe another world is not only necessary, but already in motion.

Thank you Evil and Scary Black girl 🥷🏿, Will Redd, and many others for tuning into our live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.



Get full access to Resistance is Fertile at resistanceisfertilepodcast.substack.com/subscribe