Sometimes, the material conditions of podcasting intervene. Due to a classic “Benji time zone” miscalculation, co-hosts Benji and Alkmi found themselves live on the RIF Podcast a full hour before our special guest, Gabriel Rockhill, was scheduled to join us.
But as any good historical materialist knows, you don’t just waste time in the belly of the beast—you use it to organize, agitate, and break down the contradictions of the present moment. What started as a waiting room quickly evolved into a vital discussion on the limits of individual “adventurism,” the necessity of collective networks of care, and the uncomfortable truths about operating a left inside a successful genocidal settler colony.
Here is a summary of the pre-game dialectics before Gabriel Rockhill took the mic.
The Limits of “Yapping” and the Trap of Individual Adventurism
Benji opened the stream by confronting a recurring critique from the chat: You guys are just yapping; what are you actually doing to disable the genocidal machine? Reflecting on his own material limitations, Benji contrasted the “Luigi” approach—referring to the individual, spontaneous assassination of a healthcare CEO—with the necessity of collective, organized resistance. While individual acts of or resistance desperation might garner sympathy, they do not build the power required to dismantle empire.
Alkmi quickly stepped in to provide the correct dialectical counter-example: the collective, organized networks of care and defense mobilized by Latinx, Black, and Indigenous communities in California against ICE raids. True material impact doesn’t come from isolated, white, individualist adventurism; it comes from deep-seated, relational networks of life affirmation that have been built over years of collective struggle.
Material Solidarity: Moving Beyond Performative Politics
If you want to know if your “yapping” has material impact, look at how the empire responds. They don’t give you tenure; they try to shut down your fundraisers. Benji and Alkmi used this segment to issue an urgent call for material solidarity with Gaza. Marking the anniversary of Operation Al-Aqsa Flood, they highlighted the incredible work of Lifeline for Gaza and the Samir Project, a comprehensive mutual aid network on the ground delivering water, education, and entertainment to children. They also issued a special birthday fundraiser for Ibrahim, a tireless organizer whose own father was martyred in the resistance.
Western Marxism, Defeatism, and the “Settler Left”
Addressing some spicy chat debates regarding Gabriel Rockhill’s critiques of Western Marxism and electoralism, Benji and Alkmi dissected why the Western academic left so often sides with empire. From Adorno to Foucault, the Western Marxist tradition has a long history of fetishizing defeated revolutions while actively opposing actually-existing socialist projects and Global South liberation movements.
Furthermore, Benji dropped a hard truth: You cannot build a revolutionary left in a successful genocidal settler colony if it remains a settler left. If your politics do not center Land Back, decolonization, and the internal colonization of Indigenous and Black peoples, you are merely managing the genocide, not ending it. The extreme left of Zionism is still a genocidal project, and the same applies to the settler left that refuses to confront the primary contradiction of stolen land.
Pretendianism: The Highest Stage of Settler Erasure
Alkmi closed out the pre-show with a blistering critique of “pretendianism”—the phenomenon of white settlers falsely claiming Indigenous ancestry (epitomized by figures like Ward Churchill). Drawing on Fanon and Afro-pessimism, Alkmi identified pretendianism as the ultimate, most insidious stage of settler colonialism: when the settlers have marginalized or killed off the actual Native population, they attempt to replace them by donning their cultural skins. This isn’t just a harmless quirk of the left; it is an active extension of genocide that diverts resources and erases actual Indigenous sovereignty. Non-Indigenous settlers have a duty to actively call this out.
🕒 Episode Timeline
00:00 - The “Benji Time Zone” & Welcome to the Sandbox01:35 - Yapping vs. Material Action in the Belly of the Beast04:30 - Individual Adventurism vs. Collective Networks of Care07:00 - Material Solidarity: Fundraising for Gaza & the Samir Project17:00 - Critiquing Western Marxism’s Imperial Defeatism24:00 - Electoralism, Settler Colonialism, and the Myth of the “Settler Left”30:30 - Tactics, Strategy, and the Dialectics of Sovereignty34:00 - Disaggregating the Left: The White Left vs. The Black & Indigenous Left39:00 - Pretendianism as the Highest Stage of Settler Erasure43:00 - Enter Gabriel: Welcome to the Dialectical Sandbox
Free Palestine, swift victory to the free people of the world, and Land Back!
📢 Call to Action on the anniversary of Tufan Al-Aqsa
The empire targets fundraisers because they work. This week, on the anniversary of the Flood, we must turn our dirty blood-money into a ripple of life.
* 🔗 Donate to Gaza, for example through this week’s highlighted fundraiser for Ibrahim’s 28th birthday:https://chuffed.org/project/134655-help-ibrahim-his-baby-and-his-pregnant-wife-survive-the-genocide
* 🔗 Pledge a monthly donation to Sameer Project: https://chuffed.org/project/149178-sameer-project-x-mass-displacement-campaign
* 🔗 Support material resistance as existence: Lifeline for Gaza
To celebrate three years of the Tufan, badger your friends, your family, and your frenemies. Send your little drop of monetary water to cleanse it by directing it toward the resistance.
Free Palestine. Swift and ever-swifter victories to the free peoples of the world and the resistance.
NB: Summary and timeline drafted with help from Qwen AI
Follow Resistance is Fertile on Substack for unfiltered analysis and updates
Share this episode – narrative warfare is everyone’s fight
https://lifeline4gaza.com/
Palestinian-Run Mutual Aid (independent of the imperial NGO-military complex)
Help Gazans provide essential services to Gazans with the Sameer Project.
Contribute to the Abu Hureirah Network, launched by our friend Hamza to support mutual aid groups in Gaza and Sudan.
Or contribute to Benji’s Gaza fundraisers
For Omar and his family of seven: https://bit.ly/omargaza
For Ibrahim, his wife, newborn baby and extended family! https://bit.ly/IbrahimGaza
For a pregnant lady and her family: https://bit.ly/PregnantMotherGaza
For Mustafa in North Gaza: https://bit.ly/MustafaGaza
For Khaled and his six children: https://bit.ly/khaledinGaza
You can also support
RIF Linktree https://linktr.ee/resistanceisfertile
Share with siblings and comrades who believe another world is not only necessary, but already in motion.
Thank you Dr.Who, Michael McKinley, mabby, Christine Stanfield, Anne-Marie P, and many others for tuning into our live video!