In this impromptu episode of the Psymat series, Benji sits down to address a thoughtful, four-page critique from a Substack comrade regarding his previous claims about Noam Chomsky. Read it here! The critic argued that labeling Chomsky’s entire career an “imperial psychological operation” veers into conspiracism and ignores the possibility of genuine, independent anti-imperialist thought.
Benji uses this opportunity to draw a razor-sharp distinction between conspiracism (the idea that history is driven by shadowy cabals in smoke-filled rooms) and historical materialism (the understanding that the ruling class consciously organizes and promotes systems of meaning that serve their material interests, and regularly conspires to that end).
The result is a masterclass in dialectical psychology, exposing how Chomsky’s scientific revolution didn’t just change linguistics—it killed the materialist study of human behavior, resurrected Cartesian dualism, and provided the perfect liberal veneer for the military-industrial complex.
Here is a breakdown of the key takeaways from this episode.
1. Historical Materialism vs. Conspiracism
Benji clarifies that he doesn’t believe the CIA sat Chomsky down in a basement at Langley and handed him a script. Instead, he applies a rigorous historical materialist lens: White empire doesn’t need to manufacture every compatible intellectual from scratch. It simply identifies, funds, and promotes thinkers whose work naturally aligns with its hegemonic designs. Chomsky’s career, funded entirely by the military-industrial complex through MIT, produced a “system of meaning” that perfectly serves imperial interests by foreclosing socialist and anti-imperialist class consciousness.
Thanks for reading Resistance is Fertile! This post is public so feel free to share it.
2. The Real Psyop is the Science
The greatest psychological operation Chomsky ever pulled wasn’t his pseudo-anti-imperialism; it was his 1959 review of B.F. Skinner’s Verbal Behavior. By taking down behaviorism—a contextual, materialist approach to how organisms interact with their environment—Chomsky ushered in the Cognitive Revolution. He posited that language is the result of a random genetic mutation creating an innate “language module” in the brain. Benji exposes this as pure Cartesian dualism and idealism dressed up as biology, deliberately isolating the human mind from social relations, class struggle, and material conditions.
3. The Political Function of Liberal Anarchism
Chomsky’s political philosophy—his “anarcho-syndicalism”—is exposed as a millenarian fantasy. It posits that humans are innately cooperative and that if we just stripped away the State and got the “truth” out of the media, a perfect society would emerge. This ignores the material realities of class struggle and the need for the dictatorship of the proletariat. It serves as a safe, radical veneer for the imperial labor aristocracy, allowing them to feel oppositional without ever having to engage in actual, risky revolutionary strategy or support actually existing socialist states.
4. The Epstein Test: Class Traitors and Imperial Elites
How do you know whose class interests an intellectual truly serves? Look at who invites them to their islands. Actual anti-imperialist leaders—Sinwar, Khamenei, Xi, Nasrallah—were never invited to Jeffrey Epstein’s island. Chomsky, however, corresponded with Epstein, dreamed of visiting his island, and was photographed on his private jet. This isn’t just a “failure of personal judgment”; it is the ultimate litmus test of class alignment. Chomsky belongs to the imperial elite, and his work reflects that class position.
5. Decolonizing Psychology: Freud, Foucault, and Fanon
The episode closes with a blistering critique of Western psychology. Benji dismantles Freud’s Oedipus complex as a projection of white colonial neuroses (the desire to kill the father and rape the mother’s resources) and exposes Foucault’s genealogical method as a paralyzing tool that declares “all power is bad,” effectively disarming the working class. Instead, Benji champions a materialist psychology rooted in Vygotsky, Relational Frame Theory, and Frantz Fanon. Consciousness, language, and identity are not innate modules; they are social products emerging from our material social relations. True liberation requires understanding how systems of meaning teach us to value some lives over others, and organizing collectively to shatter those imperial contingencies.
Here’s an article of mine that broaches upon some attendant issues.
🕒 Episode Timeline
00:00 - Intro & The Purpose of the Response02:00 - Historical Materialism vs. Conspiracism06:50 - Systems of Meaning and Genocidal Imperialist Realism16:40 - The OSS, the Frankfurt School, and Anti-Communism24:40 - Shaping Science: How the Political Economy Dictates Research37:30 - The Core Psyop: Chomsky’s Takedown of B.F. Skinner46:00 - Cartesian Dualism and the Myth of the “Language Module”54:00 - Relational Frame Theory: A Materialist Alternative1:01:00 - The Fiction and Function of Chomsky’s Anarcho-Syndicalism1:07:30 - The Epstein Test: Class Traitors and Imperial Elites1:13:40 - “It’s Complicated”: Unmasking the Zionist Psyop1:29:30 - Reification and the Abstraction of Empire1:45:30 - The Long Road to Communism: Burning Our Idols2:03:00 - Decolonizing the Mind: Freud, Foucault, and Fanon2:14:00 - Material Action: Fundraising for Gaza and Closing Thoughts
🛠️ Walk on Two Legs: Practice and Yapping
The Empire is terrified of material solidarity, which means it works. If they give you a tenure, you aren’t making a difference. If they shut down your fundraisers and censor your videos, you are hitting the nail on the head.
* Donate to Lana’s Mother (Medical bills are piling up; let’s step up again).
* Support Lifeline for Gaza (Direct, life-saving mutual aid).
* Support the Sameer Project (Set up a monthly donation to keep their comprehensive mutual aid networks running).
Free Palestine, and swift victory to the free people of the world!📢 Call to Action on the anniversary of Tufan Al-Aqsa
The empire targets fundraisers because they work. This week, on the anniversary of the Flood, we must turn our dirty blood-money into a ripple of life.
To celebrate three years of the Tufan, badger your friends, your family, and your frenemies. Send your little drop of monetary water to cleanse it by directing it toward the resistance.
Free Palestine. Swift and ever-swifter victories to the free peoples of the world and the resistance.
NB: Summary and timeline drafted with help from Qwen AI
Follow Resistance is Fertile on Substack for unfiltered analysis and updates
Share this episode – narrative warfare is everyone’s fight
https://lifeline4gaza.com/
Palestinian-Run Mutual Aid (independent of the imperial NGO-military complex)
Help Gazans provide essential services to Gazans with the Sameer Project.
Contribute to the Abu Hureirah Network, launched by our friend Hamza to support mutual aid groups in Gaza and Sudan.
Or contribute to Benji’s Gaza fundraisers
For Omar and his family of seven: https://bit.ly/omargaza
For Ibrahim, his wife, newborn baby and extended family! https://bit.ly/IbrahimGaza
For a pregnant lady and her family: https://bit.ly/PregnantMotherGaza
For Mustafa in North Gaza: https://bit.ly/MustafaGaza
For Khaled and his six children: https://bit.ly/khaledinGaza
You can also support
RIF Linktree https://linktr.ee/resistanceisfertile
Share with siblings and comrades who believe another world is not only necessary, but already in motion.
Thank you Ali Hart عَلي هارت • they/them, Dr.Who, Lynda Craig, Ramona E Lawson, Eva Juhl, and many others for tuning into our live video!