Listen

Description

The phone buzzes with an unfamiliar notification. Jeffrey Goldberg, Editor-in-Chief of The Atlantic, glances down to see an invitation from someone identifying themselves as Michael Waltz, National Security Advisor to President Trump. For two days, he watched in silence inadvertently witnessing history from inside a confidential Signal messaging group where top administration officials coordinated military strikes against Houthi rebels in Yemen.

This unprecedented breach of operational security—quickly dubbed “Signalgate”—exposes vulnerabilities in how modern governments conduct their most sensitive business. In an era where convenience often trumps security, the incident reveals systemic failures in the safeguarding of national defense information and raises questions about accountability, transparency, and the blurred lines between journalism, government, and global security networks.

The Breach and Its Implications

The Signal chat group titled “Houthi PC small group” included Vice President JD Vance, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, CIA Director John Ratcliffe, and White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles among its 18 participants. Their exchanges revealed both operational details and policy disagreements about the planned military action.

Within the chat, Hegseth shared information that security experts consider inherently classified: precise timing for F-18 launches at 12:15 ET, strike windows beginning at 13:45, and details about Tomahawk missile launches. Real-time battle damage assessments followed as operations commenced: “Building collapsed. Had multiple positive ID,” Waltz messaged, later clarifying that “their top missile guy” had been killed.

Former national security officials express dismay that such discussions occurred on a commercial platform rather than in a Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility (SCIF), the secure spaces designed for such conversations. “Discussing operational details of a pending strike on an unsecured platform represents a fundamental breakdown in operational security protocols,” explains one former intelligence official who requested anonymity due to the sensitivity of the matter.

The White House has confirmed the chat’s authenticity. National Security Council spokesman Brian Hughes characterized it as “a demonstration of the deep and thoughtful policy coordination between senior officials” while stating the administration is “reviewing how an inadvertent number was added to the chain.”

[PHOTO: Aftermath of the F-18 strike on “missile guy” girlfriend’s house.]

[VIDEO: American jets bomb Saada, northern Yemen.]

Strategic Context: Israel at the Center

The conversations captured in the Signal chat provide a rare window into how geopolitical considerations shape U.S. military decision-making. Among the messages, Hegseth explicitly mentioned Israel as a motivating factor for immediate action, writing that one risk of waiting was that “Israel takes an action first — or Gaza cease fire falls apart — and we don’t get to start this on our own terms.”

This reference wasn’t incidental. Many of the Signal chat participants maintain strong pro-Israel or Zionist ties that inform their worldview and policy positions. Hegseth, a staunch supporter of Israel’s policies, has been documented wearing a visible Jerusalem Cross tattoo and has openly endorsed hardline positions, including expressing hope at a 2018 Jerusalem conference for a “miracle” that would lead to rebuilding the Temple on the Temple Mount—a highly contentious position even within Zionist circles.

National Security Advisor Michael Waltz, who inadvertently added Goldberg to the chat, has been described as having “an even stronger pro-Israel tilt” and has been an “outspoken backer of Israel throughout his career.” As a congressman, Waltz received substantial funding from pro-Israel lobbying groups, including AIPAC, totaling over $235,000. Before the Yemen operation, he had publicly recommended that Israel strike Iran’s nuclear facilities at Natanz.

Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, while maintaining a complex political trajectory, has positioned herself as a staunch supporter of Israel in the Israel-Palestine conflict, labeling pro-Palestine protesters as “puppets” of “radical Islamist organization[s].” Her stance has attracted financial support from pro-Israel lobby groups.

The Houthis, an Iran-backed group, had been targeting not only international shipping in the Red Sea but also launching attacks against Israel in solidarity with Palestinians in Gaza. The U.S. strikes, presented publicly as primarily protecting freedom of navigation, were also implicitly supporting Israeli security interests.

When Vance expressed reservations about the operation, noting that only “3 percent of US trade runs through the Suez” compared to “40 percent of European trade,” the discussion became about balancing domestic political messaging with regional security commitments. “I just hate bailing Europe out again,” Vance wrote, to which Hegseth responded that he shared his “loathing of European free-loading” but argued for proceeding anyway.

The collective Zionist orientation of these key officials—combined with their inclusion of Goldberg, who served in the Israel Defense Forces during the First Intifada and has been called “the most influential journalist/blogger on matters related to Israel”—creates a much more complex picture than a simple communication error.

[PHOTO: Pete Hegseth]

Goldberg: Not Just Any Journalist

Of all possible journalists who might have received access to this sensitive conversation, Jeffrey Goldberg’s involvement presents particular complications. His inclusion raises questions about whether this was truly, as the administration claims, a simple error.

Goldberg has built his career on reporting focused on Israel, the Middle East, and national security—but his profile extends far beyond conventional journalism. Before becoming The Atlantic’s editor-in-chief, Goldberg served in the Israel Defense Forces as a prison guard at Ktzi’ot Prison during the First Intifada, where he guarded Palestinian detainees. This was during a period when Ktzi’ot held, according to Human Rights Watch, approximately one out of every 50 West Bank and Gazan males older than 16 . Palestinian human rights group al-Haq described conditions in the camp as “harsh and inhuman,” with reports documenting severe overcrowding.

Ktzi’ot was the largest detention camp run by the Israeli army during the First Intifada, holding three-quarters of all Palestinians detained by the army . Human rights organizations have documented widespread abuses in Israeli detention facilities during this period, including routine use of physical and psychological pressure during interrogations. Goldberg met Rafiq Hijazi, a PLO leader, during his time at the prison, whom he described as “the only Palestinian in the prison who understood Zionism.” This military service for a foreign power remains unusual among American journalists covering Middle East affairs.

After leaving Israel, Goldberg cultivated extraordinary access to power centers in both American and Israeli governments. He conducted five interviews with President Obama, who once spoke at Goldberg’s synagogue and thanked him for describing him as “the first Jewish president.” His access extends to Israeli leaders as well, with multiple interviews of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Shimon Peres, and other senior Israeli officials.

Michael Massing of the Columbia Journalism Review described Goldberg as “the most influential journalist/blogger on matters related to Israel,” reflecting his unique position at the intersection of media, politics, and national security networks. His connections create an extensive web of influence that spans administrations and crosses partisan divides.

The Atlantic, where Goldberg serves as editor-in-chief, is owned by Laurene Powell Jobs, the widow of Apple co-founder Steve Jobs, who acquired a 70% stake in the publication in 2017. …



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit tatsuikeda.substack.com/subscribe