July 1, 2025
Sorry, but it seems like you either hate or love Zohran Mamdani and either makes you a de-facto racist. No one seems to evaluate on the merits anymore, and no one has updated what the definition of political merit is since FDR and guess what everyone from that time period is dead. We are literally living in a withered away political culture, buried with everyone who lived during World War II. Love him, you are probably a jew hater. Hate him, well you are also a jew hater, but you are deeply islamophobic to boot, and a homophobic for good measure. Love him, you want free everything and government nanny state. Hate him, you are thinking he will bankrupt NYC overnight and 9/11 part two happens. (I will disprove this later, bankrupcy, not 9/11.) What if there was another way to analyze not just Mamdani, but the public, political establishment, and media responses to this admittedly handsome, well spoken, and very NYCāish young millennial? Although I have never written op-ed before, let me entertain you, and possibly get you thinking outside your head.
CAPTION: āLiberal calling Mamdani anti-Semitic" and "Conservative calling Mamdani anti-Semitic"
Mamdami Needs No Introduction, But
Zohran Mamdani is omnipresent these days, on CNN, on Telegram, on X, making him either a genuine phenomenon or some twisted plot of controlled opposition by the Democratic party, maybe ISIS, who knows. Is he a new manufactured political personality, like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who literally got the congress seat out of 10,000 applicants to a Justice Democratic casting call? Or is he going to destroy NYC, like the city government did in the 1970ās under Republican then turned Democrat mayor John Lindsay (1966ā1973). It would be ironic, because conservatives like to forget Lindsay and his Democratic successor maimed the city with overspending, leading to white flight, then banker takeover, then austerity, and then eventually Donald Trump and others made the city a playground for the rich ever since. Despite his relative wealth, and his parentās even greater wealth of $2 to $10 million, Zohran Mamdani rents an apartment in Astoria, but owns undeveloped property in Uganda. This is the black mirror of what polar opposite Michael Bloomberg used to portray, who was unabashed about his wealth, yet made a daily show of riding the subway to work, after being chauffeured from UES to the subway station in a black government issue Chevy Suburban SUV. Mamdani, the 33-year-old assembly member hasnāt really been making new rounds at sweltering community centers preferring to sweat it out with a trans flag at the annual Pride March, having been catapulted daily to national news cycles. He doesnāt need to visit health centers and synagogues anymore, heās making CNN and NYT headlines daily. He is making promises that would have seemed fantastical just a decade ago: free buses, city-owned grocery stores, a $30 minimum wage. Is he living is his own head nearly rent-free as an inexperienced lawmaker sipping White Claw on his couch in Astoria with a Che Guervara tee shirt, or does he truly have the interests covered of constructions workers, home health aides, and recent immigrants? If so, what about police officers and first responders? Note that I say interests covered. Itās one thing to be concerned, another to actually fix big complicated problems. Especially at his age.
What strikes me isnāt just the audacity of Mamdaniās platform, but the ferocity of the national reaction it has provoked. When was the last time a New York City mayoral race commanded headlines from coast to coast? When did local politics become a referendum on the soul of American democracy? The answer reveals something vibing about our political moment: Zohran Mamdani has become an unwitting litmus test for a system that has lost its capacity to imagine genuine alternatives.
The son of Indian Shia and āPost-Colonialā academic Mahmood Mamdani and international filmmaker Mira Nair, this wealthy Democratic Socialist represents something our political establishment cannot easily categorize or dismiss, despite being easy to analyze if you read on. He is neither the familiar progressive archetype, like Bernie or AOC, nor the comfortable ethnic candidate like Eric Adams none of whom poses any threat whatsoever to existing power structures. Instead, Mamdani embodies a dangerous idea: that politics should actually start looking back at even discussing about working people, not Israel, something literally no politicians has represented for decades. Yet, ideas do not solve problems. People do. Supposedly. So basically, Mamdani to me is a theory. He talks. To me that is not threatening. Iāll believe heās a threat when ISIS is running over the Brooklyn Bridge.
Spoiler Alert, Mamdani Will Win It All and It Does Not Matter
Zohran Mamdaniās most ambitious policy proposals face significant legal and political constraints at both the state and federal levels. Many of these initiatives, including new or higher municipal taxes, require approval from the New York State Legislature, where Governor Kathy Hochul and other Albany leaders have already voiced skepticism or outright opposition. Even if Mamdani were to secure citywide support, state lawmakers could block or dilute his agenda, as seen in recent moves to increase oversight and limit mayoral power in response to controversial policies. On top of this, federal funding is a critical lifeline for New York Cityās budget, and President Trump has publicly threatened to withhold federal support if Mamdani pursues policies the administration opposes, warning of āstrict financial measuresā and āsevere financial repercussionsā for noncompliance. These overlapping layers of state and federal authority mean that, while Mamdani can set a bold vision, the practical implementation of his āpipe dreamā policies will be sharply limited by political realities and legal guardrails outside City Hallās direct control. So yes, Mamdami doesnāt really matter. In the end, he might be able to get free buses I predict. It would only add $1 billion of budget debt, not a big deal for NYC.
Liberals and Conservatives Arenāt a Thing Anymore
The hysteria surrounding Mamdaniās candidacy exposes a deeper pathology in American politicsāthe complete failure of both conservative and liberal establishments to offer meaningful solutions to the crises facing ordinary Americans. Conservatives retreat into fantasies about a golden age that never existed, while liberals chase utopian futures that never materialize. Between these poles lies a vast wasteland where pragmatic governance might flourish, if anyone possessed the courage to inhabit it. Where does the eschaton lie?
Consider the conservative response to Mamdaniās rise. Rather than engage with his policy proposals, critics resort to tired rhetoric about ācommunist threatsā, āanti-semitismā, and the specter of white flight, fleeing businesses and unrecoverable economic collapse. This reaction reveals the intellectual moribundity of modern conservatism, which has abandoned any pretense of actual governance in favor of perpetual grievance politics. Where are the conservative alternatives to Mamdaniās housing proposals? Where is the right-wing vision for addressing New Yorkās affordability crisis?
These talking points have become so rote and mundane because conservatism has devolved into a nostalgic exercise in myth-making. Itās not exactly a recent event, conservatism by its nature, is founded on a belief in a glorious past, sometimes the bloodier it was, the better. The āgood old daysā these politicians invoke, when New York was supposedly more prosperous and orderly, conveniently forget the 1970ās austerity measures, 24/7 red light district sex shows in Times Square, rampant squatting, cars abandoned en masse under the BQE, every subway car covered in graffiti, redlining in housing, police brutality such as Haitian man Abner Louima who was raped by officers with a plunger hanā¦