Spring 2016. You’re at Waitress, and you’re hungry, because when you walked in you could literally smell freshly baking pies. You know three things about it: (1) it’s based on a movie Felicity was in 10 years ago, (2) it stars recent Tony-winner Jessie Mueller, and (3) the score is by Sara Barellis. “Ugh,” you think to yourself, why are they having pop stars who’ve never done theater write musicals?“ Well, by intermission you realize that’s humble pie you’ve been smelling, and you have to eat a big slice. It’s one of the freshest, most tuneful scores you’ve heard in years. You expected a number of good ballads, but there’s a lot of musical range with humor and warmth that makes each character vibrant and distinct. Mueller plays the titular waitress, Jenna, who works at a diner in the south. She bakes whimsically named pies to take her mind off her abusive husband, Earl. When she learns she’s pregnant, she realizes she has to leave Earl. To fund her new beginning, she starts concealing portions of her tips around the house and plans on entering a baking competition with a sizable cash prize. Her life gets more complicated when she starts an affair with her (also married) obstetrician (Dr. Pomatter). She hits a low point when Earl finds the hidden cash and storms off. She sings a powerful ballad lamenting what her life has become and resolving to “fight, just a little, to bring back that fire in her eyes.” (“She Used to Be Mine”)
Catch up with all the songs to date!