Listen

Description

When I was young, Christmas happened the night before. We were a Christmas Eve family. Christmas Day—after the rush of discovering what Santa Claus had left us—was pretty boring, until the year that my dad realized, probably when I was an adolescent, that the local movie theater was open on the day. A new Gallagher tradition was born! We did not go to church on Christmas Day. That would be silly; Christmas had nothing to do with church. Christmas was a time for overeating and overspending—or, to put a more positive spin on it, Christmas was for families and for generosity.

Back to Christmas Eve. When my parents got off work on December 24, we would load up the car with presents and head over to my Granny’s house, bustling with family and food. Granny had cooked her chili with spaghetti noodles—no, not like Cincinnati chili, not that many noodles. It was still soup, to be eaten in a bowl. And it was wonderful. There were various other treats, the usual suspects, I’m sure, but the only thing I remember is Granny’s chili. After supper, we would open presents. Participants included my parents with me and my sister, and my aunt Lea with her three kids, and my aunt Anna Lou, and Granny. Sometimes perhaps a cousin’s boyfriend or girlfriend would come around. Afterwards, we went home and prepared for Santa’s visit, who would deliver the final presents of the season. This traditional Christmas at Granny’s house continued, I think, until she moved into an apartment that couldn’t fit everyone.

Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

I married into a Christmas Day family, and Jodi and I have done a pretty good job of combining our respective traditions, of making Christmas Eve and Christmas Day special. Having a lot of kids helps. But Jodi refuses to go to the movies on a holiday.

One of the big things that’s different from my youth is that we are much more explicit about celebrating the birth of Jesus. That’s not really the right way of saying it, but it’ll do for now. We even go to church on Christmas Eve. Indeed, we attend a Christmas Eve service at the Sherrod Ave. Church of Christ in Florence, Alabama. Just let that sink in for a moment. There’s a Church of Christ in Alabama—a very traditional Church of Christ, an acapella Church of Christ with all-male leadership—that hosts a Christmas Eve service. Times have changed.

I grew up in a Church of Christ in western Kentucky that did not say much about Christmas. This was a congregation that was not hardcore traditional; this congregation did not get a steady diet of preaching against the sins of the denominations, and we didn’t hear about the evils of Christmas. But, as far as I recall, we didn’t hear about the birth of Jesus either, not in December, anyway. Maybe in April or October. There was an understanding that Christmas was a good holiday for families; there was no need to tell people that Christmas should not be celebrated religiously because no one in the congregation had any thought of making Christmas a religious holiday.

Coming around to Christmas

In this way, the church where I grew up shared a tradition common to many people in Churches of Christ, though things were beginning to change even then. In the year I was born, there was an article printed in the Gospel Advocate called “What about Christmas?” (December 20, 1979, p. 780) by a fellow named Ross W. Dye, who at the time lived in Anaheim, California. Dye said he was grateful that people around the world honored Jesus at Christmas time, and he thought churches ought to teach about the birth of Jesus, even in December. But a few weeks later, the Gospel Advocate printed a response to Dye’s article by a Collinsville, Virginia preacher named A. Lowell Altizer (“What About ‘What About Christmas’?” January 21, 1980, p. 109), who expressed concern that talking about the birth of Jesus in December would confuse people about the intentions of the Churches of Christ, with the result that outsiders would lump Churches of Christ in with the denominations. “Why not teach and sing about the birth of Christ in mid-summer instead of December?” Altizer asked. “I am persuaded,” said Altizer, “that any action that makes us look like a denomination or a partaker of their error ought to be avoided.” But it seems that Altizer was fighting a losing battle.

The next Christmas, the Firm Foundation ran an editorial by Reuel Lemmons (“Christmas,” December 23, 1980, p. 818), largely positive toward Christmas, even as a religious holiday. “Personally, we are glad that the world, bent on carnage and drunk on hedonism takes time out to acknowledge that God has sent his Son into the world.”

This viewpoint was becoming common in the Firm Foundation. In 1977, Cecil Hook wrote “In Defense of Christmas,” (January 25, p. 56) a remarkable article, arguing that imperfect Christianity is much better than secularism, and that Christmas (and Bible teaching in public schools) does a great service in preparing people to receive undenominational Christianity.

In protesting the religious over-emphasis centering around the alleged birth date of Jesus, many disciples have been crusading to “keep Christ out of Christmas.” And the crusade is becoming effective. Christmas is becoming increasingly secular. Religious sentiment in the songs of Christmas is being heard less. “Santa Claus is coming to town” is replacing “Joy to the world, the Lord is come!”

I regret this change even though I recognize no religious observance of Christmas. I regret it because we are losing something. Something is better than nothing. Secularism is nothing.

The year prior to Hook’s article, the Firm Foundation ran an article by John Waddey (“Christians and Christmas,” December 14, 1976, p. 792) that was less positive about the religious observance of Christmas—which is, Waddey says, unbiblical—but recognized quite a bit of the Christmas celebration that was perfectly acceptable for Christians.

But no New Testament writing instructs us to observe a holy day for Christ’s birth. To so observe the day is to go beyond what is written. According to Christ such religious practices are vain worship for they are the precepts of men (Matt. 15:9). God gave his church only one special day, the first day of the week.

…

What shall we do? We live in a world that makes December 25 a national holiday. We obviously cannot participate in the religious observances connected with this day. But neither can we “go out of the world” (1 Cor. 5:9, 10). It is the author’s view that we can observe the legal, civil, social holiday as such, just as we would any other; for example, Labor Day, Independence Day or Thanksgiving Day. It appears to him that Christians could:

* Take the day off with pay;

* Accept a Christmas bonus;

* Receive a Christmas gift;

* Eat a Christmas feast of turkey and cranberries;

* Give presents to his family and friends;

* And enjoy the holiday festivities without sin or compromise so long as he did not make it a special religious observance.

Waddey ends his article by stressing that if participation in the celebration of Christmas makes you feel guilty, then you should not do it. But then he warns: “Do not, however, try to force your scruples on other brethren.” He then points to Romans 14.

Also in 1976, the same year as Waddey’s article, Guy N. Woods published a collection of Questions and Answers (Henderson: Freed-Hardeman College) that he had addressed over the years at the Freed-Hardeman lectureship. (A decade later, he would publish a second volume.) One of the questions concerns Christmas.

What does the word ‘Christmas’ mean? When did the observance of the birthday of Christ on December 25, begin? Is it wrong for Christians to engage in any of the usual activities associated with Christmas such as putting up Christmas trees, decorating lights, and exchanging gifts? (p. 203)

The answer Woods provides is the same as what Waddey had said. Christians shou…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit edmongallagher.substack.com