Listen

Description

“There were two subjects we never heard about in church,” Joy Winn told me one evening. She was referring to her childhood and young adulthood, decades earlier (roughly, the 1960s), in a church of Christ in Alabama. I’m pretty sure this conversation took place on a Wednesday evening because we were at church, which narrows down the possibilities. For my entire life, I have gone to church every Sunday and Wednesday and no other day of the week (except for special events). I think I spoke to Joy on a Wednesday evening because what prompted her comment to me was the talk I had just delivered on the Holy Spirit, and I seem to recall making that presentation in the middle of the week in about the year 2017. I asked her which two subjects the church of her youth failed to cover, and she replied: “The Holy Spirit and grace.”

Readers with a deep association with conservative churches in America (or, maybe, elsewhere) will understand Joy’s comment. I don’t think its application is limited to churches of Christ, but it definitely includes them, as she intended. I myself am a lifelong member of churches of Christ in the (mostly southern) United States—Kentucky, Tennessee, Ohio, and Alabama. My experience in churches confirms the truth of Joy’s comment: many churches have had little to say about the Holy Spirit or grace.

Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Ignoring the Holy Spirit

Why these two topics? I think the Holy Spirit is perceived by some conservative Christians as too mysterious—maybe too nebulous—to provide anything firm or concrete to say, so they mostly avoid the subject. I understand this concern; I feel the same pressure. My experience of churches is among those who emphasize the Christian Bible over Christian tradition—or, rather, who emphasize the Bible against tradition. The idea is that Christian tradition largely went off the rails in the centuries after the New Testament, adding all kinds of extraneous doctrines and practices to the simple message of the gospel as attested in the Scriptures. And it is true, I think, that whereas there are well developed doctrines regarding the Holy Spirit among some Christian groups, these are in many ways add-ons, later developments, not clearly articulated in the New Testament. If we’re going to stick with the Bible rather than later traditions developing from it, that’s going to limit what we can say with confidence about the Holy Spirit.

You may have noticed some problems with this explanation for Christian reticence regarding the Holy Spirit. Surely there are all kinds of ways in which even very conservative, sola-Scriptura-kinds of Christians accept as true things that are not directly said in Scripture—not to mention denying or downplaying things that are directly said in Scripture.

Yes, guilty.

Just think about the doctrine of the Trinity for a moment. Or whatever other doctrine you want to know. There’s what the Bible says, and then there’s your way of explaining those biblical statements, putting them together into a coherent system.

With regard to the Holy Spirit, what I can say is that church leaders I have known have tended to take a rather high view of the status or person of the Holy Spirit, and they will even occasionally address their worship toward the Holy Spirit (“Spirit, we love you, we worship and adore you…”), but they get cagey when you ask them what the Holy Spirit actually does now. They do think he—and they often insist on the “he,” not “it”—dwells in Christians, but they’re not sure how he does this, or what he does in us or for us. And that is because they want their thoughts on divine matters to be based on a biblical prooftext, and while the Bible (especially the New Testament) is very interested in talking about the Holy Spirit, many non-charismatic conservative Christians are dubious that the things the Holy Spirit does in the New Testament (prophecy, speaking in tongues, healings, etc.) are still happening. If he’s not doing those things, what is he doing? The Bible says some things, but not much, so some churches prefer to talk about other things.

I know, the Holy Spirit seems like an awfully important element of Christianity to be ignored by Christians. I’m just trying to explain the thought process.

Ignoring Grace

And grace? That one is a little different. The New Testament (and especially Paul) talks a lot about grace in such a way that it’s obvious that it’s supposed to apply to all believers for all time. Grace is the basis of human salvation from sin. Humans could not achieve that salvation through any of their own activity or brilliance, so God simply gave it to them. That gift is grace. “For by grace are ye saved through faith, and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God; not of works, lest any man should boast” (Ephesians 2:8–9). How could a Christian ignore grace? Grace is everything; it is the entirety of Christianity!

I’ll try to explain. Even in that verse I just quoted from Ephesians, written in the name of the apostle Paul, the gift of salvation comes not to everyone in the world but to certain people based on a condition—the condition of faith. It’s believers who receive grace. What does it mean to believe? Let’s bring in the testimony from another well-known passage in the New Testament, this one attributed to a certain James, who may be (and traditionally has been taken to be) the brother of Jesus mentioned in the Gospels (e.g., Mark 6:3) and by Paul (e.g., 1 Corinthians 15:7). “You believe that God is one; you do well. Even the demons believe—and shudder” (James 2:19). Okay, wait: the demons believe? But they are obviously not recipients of God’s grace. Is mere “belief” enough to enjoy salvation from God? Uh, big issues. For now I offer this suggestion: though the demons know about God and Jesus and they are perfectly confident in the basic facts of the gospel, they refuse to submit to the authority of God. When Paul in Ephesians says that grace comes to believers, he means by “believers” people who accept Jesus as their Lord, who love God and submit to him.

That means that “believing” is not just about something happening in a person’s head, like whether they believe in evolution or whatever, or in UFOs, or Bigfoot. It’s more like whether you believe in spending time with your kids; if you do, then prove it—spend time with your kids. There’s a behavioral element here. If you believe that Jesus is Lord, then do what he says. “If you love me,” Jesus says in the Gospel of John, “then you will keep my commandments” (14:15). If you’ve got to prove your faith or love through your actions, then what does that entail? It turns out that there is a significant tension between faith and works—or between grace and works—in the New Testament, which has led to longstanding debates within Christian history among and within various churches. While all churches would affirm Paul’s statement of the situation in Ephesians 2:8, all would say humans are saved only by grace, not works, most churches would also want to set alongside that verse other New Testament statements affirming the value of works, or, rather, the necessity of ethics.

What Joy meant on that Wednesday evening a decade ago was that the churches of her youth had spent more time talking about human responsibility and less time rejoicing in God’s mercy. I understand that impulse, though I think it has often gone too far and most certainly needs balance.

The Churches of Christ

What are the churches that I’ve been talking about, the churches of Christ? Let’s start with terminology. Some people in these churches self-identify as members of “the churches of Christ,” others of “the Churches of Christ,” and others of “the Church of Christ.” In that sense, there is no official name (“denomination”) for a collection of congregations sharing the peculiar set of beliefs and practices that I’ll describe later…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit edmongallagher.substack.com