I recently read the book called Disciples and the Bible (1997) by Eugene Boring, owing to my interest in biblical interpretation within the Stone-Campbell Movement. Boring, who died a couple years ago, was a part of the Disciples of Christ all his life. I myself am a lifelong member of the Churches of Christ. It is obvious from reading this book that Boring was glad he was not within the Churches of Christ, and I myself am glad I’m not in the Disciples of Christ. We’re both content with our own location. Still, we’re both heirs of the Stone-Campbell Movement, and so in the comments below I sometimes use the first-person plural pronoun “we” to signal the heritage that Boring and I share. The “official” date when the two groups parted ways (i.e., the split in the Stone-Campbell Movement) is 1906.
Review of Eugene Boring, Disciples and the Bible (1997)
First things first: I love this book. I love Eugene Boring’s approach to the role of Scripture in the church. I love his respect for historical criticism, and his point that historical criticism is ecumenical. I want to think about that point, and I want to think about it in light of the criticisms leveled against historical criticism from the church, from those who are concerned historical criticism is insufficiently theological to be a Christian reading strategy (for examples from within Churches of Christ, see Brad East and Keith Stanglin). I think I agree that it is insufficiently theological, but the location from which I agree with that point is from Team Boring. I love other things about the book, not least his historical approach—that is, the conviction that to figure out where we are and where we need to go, we need to understand how we got here—and as a part of that historical approach I love his account of the development of the Five-Finger Exercise. I love the view of the biblical canon that he explicates in the final chapter (pp. 423–26).
Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
My favorite part of the book may be his fourth prescription in the final chapter, on the meaning of our pre-baptismal confession, and my least favorite part of the book may be his fifth prescription, his suggestion for a new five-finger exercise. But before continuing in this vein, let me tell you about the book.
Author and Book Basics
First, the author: M. Eugene Boring died as an old man on June 27, 2024. He retired as a New Testament professor from Brite Divinity School at Texas Christian University. He earned his PhD from Vanderbilt.
The book, published by Chalice Press—a denominational publishing house connected to the Disciples of Christ—covers biblical interpretation in the Stone-Campbell Movement, from the days of Stone and Campbell, until Boring’s own day (so, about 200 years), with some hopes and direction for the future.
I’ve owned Boring’s book for 15 years, and it has languished on my shelf. Finally I can say that I’ve read it, and I’m glad I did. I learned a lot.
The Main Point of the Book
This is a different book than what I expected, but I should have expected what it is. I thought Boring’s book would be something like the more recent book by John Mark Hicks on biblical interpretation. I guess they are somewhat alike, but the two scholars certainly care about different aspects of the history of interpretation. Hicks is a historical theologian with expertise in the post-Reformation period, and he is great at tracing the intellectual currents influencing Alexander Campbell and others and especially their hermeneutical approaches. More to the point, Hicks is a lifelong member of the Churches of Christ and—not to put words in his mouth, but I imagine he might say—a recovering legalist. He is interested in how a movement aimed at church unity and renewal based on a fresh reading of Scripture became bogged down in legalism.
Boring is a biblical scholar, and more to the point, a lifelong member of the Disciples of Christ, which is self-consciously a mainstream Christian denomination. and thus a much more liberal group than the Churches of Christ. As you know if you’re at all familiar with the Disciples of Christ, and as Boring documents, for a century now the Disciples have essentially been fully integrated into the Academy and have played the game as well as anyone. The game is critical biblical scholarship, and the only rule is that you should not allow your faith to influence your reasoning. Boring didn’t grow up in a legalistic church; he grew up in a church—I imagine—that barely believed in Scripture, that openly expressed disagreement with the Bible, that harbored, and vocally expressed, serious misgivings about the resurrection of Jesus. Boring set himself the task of trying to figure out how a movement aimed at church unity and renewal based on a fresh reading of Scripture gave birth to a denomination whose leaders sometimes seem more committed to a historical reading of the Bible than to a theological appropriation of life-giving Scripture.
That this framing accurately describes Boring’s project becomes clear late in the book, starting especially in chapters 9 and 10, when he describes the Fourth Generation of Disciples in the middle of the twentieth century, the time when critical biblical scholarship fully dominated biblical interpretation in the denomination. In chapter 9, Boring describes—among others—the New Testament scholar S. Vernon McCasland as someone who had a genuine faith that could not be detected from his writings on the Bible. His faith and his biblical scholarship are in separate categories, and never the twain did meet. In the same chapter, he briefly describes Jack Finegan, another New Testament scholar. Boring says about Finegan:
He fits the McCasland type that threatened to become the dominant paradigm in the Fourth Generation. Whether it will continue to prevail remains to be seen. (347)
In chapter 10, Boring describes a mid-century committee of denominational scholars called The Panel of Scholars, that published a significant trilogy of books in 1963, charting a course for the Disciples of Christ. Again, this was 1963. Boring was ordained as a Disciples pastor in 1957, and he began teaching New Testament at Phillips University in Tulsa in 1967, so this Panel of Scholars was happening right at the time that Boring was launching his career. According to Boring, the Panel of Scholars affirmed the authority of the Bible, “not in terms of propositional revelation or verbal inspiration, but in terms of personal encounter with the God who speaks through the Bible” (357). Most of these scholars adopted a neo-orthodox view of Scripture, whereas, says Boring, “most of the denomination remained locked in the false alternatives of the older liberalism (many of the denomination’s leaders) and the older conservatism (many laypeople and pastors)” (358). He continues:
The authority of the Bible is genuinely affirmed [by The Panel of Scholars] but no longer functions in the same central manner as it had in previous generations. Though the Bible is quoted relatively often, there is remarkably little exegesis, and no exegetical essays as such. Symptomatic of the Disciples mind is the phenomenon that there is a fairly complete index to the three volumes of names and topics, but there is no scripture index. (358)
This is the situation Boring sought to explain. And it is the situation he sought to correct. Boring is not a fan of doing historical criticism of the Bible without reference to faith. He parenthetically and snarkily comments that the believing church is positioned to do historical criticism better than Christian “insiders who pretend to be ‘objective’ outsiders” (358). In the final chapter of the book, the following sentences appear all in italics, to emphasize “the centrality of the Bible.”
This is the central issue. Disciples have always assumed or affirmed that the content of the faith is identical with or inseparable from the messag…