Listen

Description

Is Artificial Intelligence going to kill us all in just a few years? That is a question making the news now, because some bigwigs in the AI world have claimed that the apocalypse is coming and it’s almost here. These are people working at the companies making AI, not the mom-and-pop AI companies, but companies like Anthropic and OpenAI. And these are bigwigs at these companies, like, the biggest of wigs, like the CEOs of the company, saying that what they are doing is going to end humanity, kill us all. Of course, we shouldn’t worry about this because our politicians are going to do something about it.

What should a Christian think about such news? The end of humanity by the end of the decade? Let’s talk about it.

Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

First, we need to understand something about AI. Let me explain the technology to you. It has something to do with computers, I think. I believe the internet might come into play somehow. There are microchips, maybe in the computers, or in the internet, or something. You mix them all together and you get robot armies. I think that’s how it works.

What if these companies make some sort of superintelligence that we cannot control, which is, I think, their explicit aim? There are a few ways that might play out. I’ve heard some people say that if AI takes over the world, humans will be free, liberated from the tyranny of work, and able to pursue our passions and hobbies. In that scenario, I think that some people will probably be on a space ship, and they’ll have a mission to explore strange new worlds, and to seek out new life and new civilizations, and to boldly split infinitives. Of course, another possibility, less positive, is that the AI will try to turn us into robots or some sort of cyborgs, that is, they’ll try to assimilate us, and it may be that resistance is futile. Maybe the AI will try to harvest our bodies’ energy while we live in a dreamlike state in some sort of pod, or maybe humans and machines will fight an apocalyptic war. I think that covers the main possibilities.

Let’s assume it’s the Terminator scenario: robots versus humans, and robots win. I figure that it’s not actually going to be a shooting war, but that the robots will get us in some other way: affecting the food supply, or tampering with medicine, but whatever—death comes; maybe very painful death, maybe quick death, but definitely death.

My first thought is: what’s the problem? Robots or not, death is coming; we can’t stop that. Of course, I wouldn’t want to be someone who is designing technology that would result in massive death or perhaps human extinction, but I’m not that person. I am someone who is potentially facing death as a part of human extinction, and it just doesn’t strike me as all that big of a deal. I guess I find it implausible that it’s going to happen, but not that troublesome if it does happen. I would find it much more problematic if the technology were being designed to annihilate a selection of humans, like poor people, or disabled people, or Asians, or something. In that case, we should definitely work to stop it, and we should probably put some people in prison. But the annihilation of all humans? Ok. There are worse things.

How plausible is this doomsday scenario? I don’t know. I have described to you the technology as I understand it, which should alert you to my complete ignorance in this realm. Some people very much involved in the AI world consider it plausible that machines will destroy humans during our lifetimes.

Is that plausible from a Christian point of view? I don’t see why not. Now I know some Christians would push back on that statement; they would insist that it cannot happen, that machines cannot destroy humanity. I have not heard people say this, but I’m guessing from analogous situations. I recall some years ago hearing Christians talk about global warming and the doomsday scenarios associated with it. As an aside, I note that we have been under a heat advisory all week as temperatures in the third week of September hover close to triple digits. But anyway I would hear Christians declare that global warming cannot result in human extinction because the Bible says so, and they would make this comment: “I’ve read the end and that’s not how it goes.” This is silliness.

We do not know how the world will come to an end. There is a description in 2 Peter 3 of a coming conflagration that will dissolve heaven and earth, but I’m not sure why that would invalidate global warming—it would seem to confirm it, in fact, since Peter says that the globe will warm—or the destruction of humanity through a robot army. There’s also a description of the return of Jesus in 1 Thessalonians 4, where we read about a trumpet and a shout and such like—but, again, I myself have enough imagination to conceive of how Paul’s description could be fulfilled literally, word for word, after humans make the planet uninhabitable, at least for human life, whether through carbon emissions or designing deadly AI. There are other biblical passages that could be considered, such as at the end of the book of Revelation, but it is difficult to know how far to press the details of passages that might well be symbolic.

And there’s the problem for any biblical interpretation addressing events or ideas about which we have no knowledge outside Scripture: how literally do we take the descriptions? Because the Bible likes to speak in symbolic language. That should be clear enough from the Gospels, where Jesus enjoyed teaching in parables, and we should remember that these parables gave his listeners fits, including his disciples, and that was entirely the point. Jesus adopted Isaiah’s mission as his own, when he explained to his disciples: “The reason I speak to them in parables is that seeing they do not perceive, and hearing they do not listen, nor do they understand” (Matt 13:13). We should also remember how common it was for very religious Jews who encountered Jesus to insist that he, Jesus, could not be the fulfillment of the prophecies because they interpreted those prophecies in a way that excluded someone like Jesus. Obviously the Messiah would not die on a Roman cross because the Messiah was a warrior. How do we know the Messiah is a warrior? Because the prophecies say it. Psalm 2: “You shall break [the nations] with a rod of iron, and dash them in pieces like a potter’s vessel.” Isaiah 11: “he shall strike the earth with the rod of his mouth, and with the breath of his lips he shall kill the wicked.” Daniel 2: “And in the days of those kings the God of heaven will set up a kingdom that shall never be destroyed, nor shall the kingdom be left to another people. It shall crush all these kingdoms and bring them to an end.” And then think about all the times in the Jewish Scriptures that the Messiah, the coming king, is said to be the son of David or even the new David, and if we know anything about David it’s that he was a warrior.

Now you’re going to tell me that I’m misinterpreting these passages, but that is exactly the point. Everyone misinterpreted them until they saw their fulfillment. They were unable to interpret them correctly until they saw Jesus. And he completely blew a hole through the way they thought it was going to go. Too often we are like Amelia Bedelia insisting on a literal interpretation of things that we cannot possibly know about—things like heaven and hell. What will these realities be like? Who knows?! But I am pretty sure that God has little interest in making sure we, right now, understand the details of heaven and hell. And so also for the end of the world. If every religious leader completely whiffed on their interpretation of the first advent of the Messiah, what would make us confident in our interpretation of the second advent of the Messiah? Should we not take the lesson and be more open and …



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit edmongallagher.substack.com