In previous posts in this series (Part 1, Part 2, Part 3), I have looked at the history of numbering the psalms. The jumping off point has been Acts 13:33, where Psalm 2:7 (as we call it) was cited as coming from “the second psalm.” I have also looked at the few manuscripts that say in Acts 13:33 “the first psalm.” In this post, I expand that latter point, not looking at manuscripts of Acts but early Christian statements about Acts or about the psalms.
So let’s return to the reading of Acts 13:33, “first psalm” or “second psalm.” We have seen that almost all extant manuscripts of Acts have “second psalm,” but one of the standard editions of the Greek New Testament indicates some doubt that “second psalm” is the correct text. (It prints “second psalm” in the text, but it assigns this a “B” rating, indicating some doubt as to the correct reading. An “A” rating would indicate full confidence.) Actually, this is true of previous editions of this Greek New Testament, up through the fifth edition (2014); I’m not sure what the about-to-be-released sixth edition will show. But I do note that there is no discussion of this textual difficulty in Houghton’s textual commentary (2025), though its predecessor by Metzger (1994) had an extensive and helpful discussion (pp. 363–65). Moreover, Ropes (1926: 263–65) argues that “first psalm” is original in Acts 13:33.
Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
(Since Houghton’s commentary “covers all of the 1,008 variation units selected for UBS6,” I take it that UBS6 will not contain any reference to the ancient evidence for the reading “first psalm” at Acts 13:33.)
If almost all manuscripts of Acts—and early ones!—have “second psalm,” why would there be any doubt that “second psalm” is the correct reading? As Metzger says, the patristic evidence for “first psalm” is “very impressive.” What he means is that some early Christian writers in the second through fourth centuries talk about Psalm 2:7 as coming from the first psalm, and they say that Paul in Acts says that the verse comes from the first psalm. In other words, these early Christian writers must have had manuscripts of Acts with the reading “first psalm,” though these manuscripts—most of them, at least—have been lost to time.
What is this patristic evidence?
Patristic evidence for “first psalm” at Acts 13:33
This evidence is surveyed in several places: the works by Metzger and Ropes already cited, and Willgren (2016: 163–67), whose main concern is whether Psalms 1–2 function as a preface to the Psalter (on which see also Gillingham 2018: 11–43) and, an old article by John Willis (pp. 387–91) on whether Psalms 1–2 should be considered a single psalm or two separate psalms. Willis himself regarded Psalm 1 as a composition separate from Psalm 2, and he also provided patristic testimony to the same effect. So, the early Christians who report traditions about the two psalms being combined in Hebrew manuscripts, or who otherwise indicate that Acts 13:33 says “first psalm,” do not represent the totality of the patristic evidence bearing on this question. For the patristic evidence for “second psalm” in Acts 13:33, see Willis, and take a look at Gillingham (2013). Since “second psalm” is the expected reading (at least, for us) in Acts 13:33, I will not cover it here.
Now I survey the patristic evidence for “first psalm” in Acts 13:33, or patristic evidence that could be cited in support of this reading.
Justin Martyr, First Apology 40 quotes the first two psalms without any break. Did he consider them a single psalm? In that case, what we think of as the second psalm would count for Justin as part of the first psalm.
Tertullian, Against Marcion 4.22.8, introduces the words of Psalm 2:7 as “in the first psalm.” The manuscripts of Tertullian seem to be consistent on this point, though the printed editions differ. Evans (OUP, 1972) prints “first psalm,” while Kroymann’s older edition (p. 494, line 4) prints “second psalm.” (But on Kroymann’s edition, see this note from Kilpatrick.)
Origen has an interesting comment in his Selecta in Psalmos 2:1
“Why do the heathen rage, the people imagine a vain thing? The kings of the earth set themselves, and the rulers take counsel together, against the Lord and against his anointed,” etc. Reading two Hebrew manuscripts, in one we found these [words] as the beginning of Psalm 2, in the other they were combined with Psalm 1. And in the Acts of the Apostles, the saying “You are my son, today I have begotten you” is said to belong to the first psalm. “For as it is written,” it says, “in the first psalm: you are my son, today I have begotten you.” Now, Greek manuscripts indicate that it is the second psalm. But this should be understood, that in the Hebrew, a number is placed beside none of the psalms, whether first, or second, or third. (PG 12.1100c–d; on Origen, see also this work, pp. 9–10)
Cyprian, Ad Quirinum 1.13; 2.8; 2.29; 3.20; 3.56; 3.112; 3.119—at these passages (according to Willis, p. 388) some Latin manuscripts of this work have the reading “first psalm” for citations of our Psalm 2, whereas other manuscripts read “second psalm.” Willis cites an article by C. H. Turner inJTS 6 (pp. 264–65).
Eusebius of Caesarea (Comm. Psal., PG 23.73b) and Athanasius (Argumentum in Psal., PG 27.56) both say that the first and second psalm are combined in Hebrew (κατὰ τὸ Ἑβραϊκόν).
Jerome, Commentarioli in Psalmos, comments on Psalm 1 as follows.
(1a) Blessed is the man who did not depart in the counsel of the ungodly. Some say this psalm is a kind of preface of the Holy Spirit and therefore has no superscription; others that, because it is the first of its order, it has the first place and that it is an error of superfluity to say it is the first before which there is nothing. Otherwise: among the Hebrews both the first and the second are one psalm, which is proved in the Acts of the Apostles. In fact, because it began with a blessing, it closes with a blessing, saying, “Blessed are all who put their trust in him” [Psa 2:12]. (translated from Risse 2005; Latin also at PL 26.823)
What is clear from the patristic testimony is the widespread nature of the reading “first psalm” in Acts 13:33, or at least the idea that our Psalm 2 may be regarded as, in some way, the first psalm. Indeed, some of these church fathers who mention the reading “first psalm” in Acts 13:33 seem unaware of any textual problem with the passage, under the assumption that the reading “in the first psalm” is undisputed. This is true of Tertullian, Origen, and Jerome, and also Hilary, as we observe next.
Hilary of Poitiers
Because his discussion is long, I allot to Hilary of Poitiers (Latin writer, fourth century) a section of his own.
In his Commentary on the Psalms Hilary goes to great lengths to explain the meaning of Paul’s comment in Acts 13:33, specifically, how the apostle could have attributed to “the first psalm” the statement “You are my son, today I have begotten you.” The problem, for Hilary, is that in the Greek and Latin manuscripts of the Psalter that he has seen, this statement is in the second psalm. Why would Paul say it was in the first? He develops an elaborate theory to explain this problem, but it never occurs to Hilary to question the accuracy of his copy of Acts. He never thinks that maybe Paul actually did say “second psalm”; apparently he has never seen a copy of Acts with any other reading than “first psalm.” He thinks it more likely that the book of Psalms is mis-ordered than that his copy of Acts has suffered textual corruption. Hilary also is familiar with evidence among the Jews that the second psalm was considered the first—and, Hilary reasons, the apostle Paul was a Jew.
Hilary of Poitiers discusses the issue in his Commentary on the Psalms 2.1 (pp. 37–38):
Apostolic authority makes many of us unsure whether they should consider this psalm to belong to the first as if the last part of the first, or wh…