A few years ago, while writing a series of lessons for Bible classes at the Sherrod Ave. Church of Christ, I drafted an essay on race relations within the Restoration Movement. This is not my area of expertise, and I have relied heavily on some of the recent scholarship on this issue, which continues to expand. I found especially helpful the published dissertation of Barclay Key and the survey history by Edward Robinson. There’s also a chapter on the topic in the wonderful history of churches of Christ by Richard Hughes, and in its updated form by James Gorman.
The essay I wrote has a lot of footnotes, which I don’t want to reproduce here. Maybe someday I’ll publish it in full in some other form. But for now, this is the most public that I have made it. But the typical length of a Substack post requires that I break up the essay into two parts.
Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
By the way, about a year before I wrote this essay, I preached a sermon on race relations. (Here’s the video of that day’s worship service; the sermon starts at about the 21 min. mark). It was early June 2020, and you may remember what was happening at that time. If you click the link to the video, you’ll notice that I’m not preaching to a live audience but in a studio; such were the times. I had not planned on preaching on race relations, but events overtook me, and I thought I needed to say something on the topic. I’m sure that sermon could be improved in all kinds of ways, but the one comment I made that sticks in my mind as completely stupid is when I said—more-or-less off the cuff (and that was the problem)—that the Bible doesn’t really address this issue head on. That statement is wrong, comically wrong, absurdly wrong. Like Whoopi Goldberg, I was thinking about racism based on skin color, and I think it is fair to say that the Bible doesn’t address that particular topic head on. (There might be a hint in that direction; see below.) But the Bible has a great deal to say about racial prejudice (or something close to racial prejudice), and much of the New Testament is taken up with this issue in terms of Jews and Gentiles. This essay is part of my penance.
From one ancestor he made all nations to inhabit the whole earth. (Acts 17:26)
In 1907, a young Black girl attended the (mostly white) church of Christ in Bellwood, Tennessee, near Lebanon. Not all of the members were happy about her presence, particularly since there was a Black congregation that met not far away. Why doesn’t she just meet with her own kind, they wondered? One of the members (S. E. Harris), ostensibly concerned about the division resulting from this situation, wrote to E. A. Elam (biographical sketch), a teacher at the Nashville Bible School and the girl’s guardian, encouraging Elam to send the girl to the Black congregation rather than the white one.
Elam was not having it. Against Harris’ suggestion that the girl’s presence was causing division, Elam retorted: “Those members who have taken up this matter and keep it agitated are doing a very great wrong in that they are dividing the church and sinning against the innocent and helpless. Instead of keeping this matter continually stirred up, all should endeavor to quiet it and to preserve the peace of the church” (Gospel Advocate, July 4, 1907). Harris did not help his case, certainly not from a twenty-first century perspective, when he replied that those objecting to the girl’s presence want her to worship God, but just to do so somewhere else, because “they just do not want their children associating with her in the capacity of worshiping God.”
Churches of Christ have had their share of racial prejudice, their share of people like S.E. Harris wanting to preserve “unity” by instituting division, their share of the “white moderate” that Martin Luther King complained about so bitterly in his iconic Letter from a Birmingham Jail (1963; wikipedia; text of the letter; pdf). Churches of Christ have also had their share of leaders like E. A. Elam, willing to stand against the dominant culture of their time in insisting on the principles of the gospel, in regard to the basic equality of all human beings, regardless of race. If the Restoration Movement has encouraged this insight into the unity in Christ brought about by the gospel (Gal 3:28), it probably is related both to the origins of the movement as a unity movement and to the call for Christians to abandon their human opinions and stand on the Bible alone.
On the other hand, the history of churches of Christ seems to reveal that the twentieth century saw a hardening of racial divisions in the movement, so that by the time that the Civil Rights movement made constant headlines in the 1960s, the dominant strain of churches of Christ typically ignored the issue altogether. The twentieth century also saw Black members of the churches of Christ finding various ways to do the work of God in a society and in a religious context that often provided them limited opportunities. While some of them focused more on eternal matters than civil rights (e.g., Marshall Keeble), others saw the two as indistinguishable and pushed back on what they considered the racism around them (e.g., S. R. Cassius, R. N. Hogan).
When it comes to race issues, our history is not all bad, but it’s not all good, either. Looking back at what we’ve done right and wrong might help us move forward with open minds and hearts on this issue that continues to cause so much turmoil.
The Bible against Racism
The Bible is not a fan of racism. That statement will come as some surprise to overt racists, who often use the Bible to undergird their ideology. Particularly popular in American history as a defense for institutionalized racism and even the enslavement of Africans has been the so-called “Curse of Ham” passage (Gen 9:20–27), a passage that supposedly shows that God curses black Africans (the descendants of Ham) to eternal slavery. According to historian Barclay Key, George Benson (wikipedia), president of Harding College, “taught that blacks were ‘under the curse of Ham’” in classes on the Pentateuch in the 1950s. But, of course, the passage in Genesis says no such thing; in fact, there is no “curse of Ham” passage known to the Bible. The cited passage is, in fact, a “curse of Canaan” passage, and Canaan has nothing to do with black Africans. The passage was intentionally misrepresented by pro-slavery apologists as a justification for their own cruelty.
The Bible’s presentation of the issue of slavery is actually quite complicated. It is true that there is no outright biblical condemnation of slavery, just as there was no abolitionist movement at all until the early eighteenth century in America and Europe. (For a brief introduction to the difficulties of the study of slavery in the Bible, see my chapter here; pdf here.) At any rate, whatever the Bible says about slavery, it certainly does not justify racism—far from it. (Slavery in the ancient world was not based on race, as it became in America.)
While the Bible says very little about anti-Black racism, one of the major themes of the New Testament is the overcoming of racism (or, at least, prejudice) between Jews and others. That must be at least part of the point of the Good Samaritan parable (Luke 10:25–37). It’s a big part of the Cornelius story (Acts 10). And it’s the main thing Paul wants to stress in Ephesians 2.
But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far off have been brought near by the blood of Christ. For he is our peace; in his flesh he has made both groups into one and has broken down the dividing wall, that is, the hostility between us. (Eph 2:13–14)
In fact, a big part of Paul’s ministry is trying to convince people from different races that they are one in Christ, that they are brothers and sisters, a part of God’s family, and any distinctions that used to separate them are at best irrelevant, and at wors…