Listen

Description

Here is part 1.

Several Christian groups in America before the Civil War separated the races into different congregations, white congregations and black congregations. But the Stone-Campbell Movement aimed at Christian unity, and this emphasis for the most part ensured that they refused to separate based on race, but rather they encouraged masters and slaves to be members of the same congregation. The Cane Ridge congregation, in 1838, seems amazingly integrated: 222 total members, 72 of whom were Black. But these Black members sat in the balcony. Sometimes congregations would serve the Lord’s Supper to the black members only after the white members had been served. Perhaps ironically, the Civil War and the abolition of slavery contributed to institutionalized segregation based on race in churches of Christ.

Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

[A]fter the Civil War, white and black Churches of Christ went their separate ways, forming two distinct fellowships. Racism evidently overpowered and overshadowed the bonds of full Christian unity even as doctrinal unity remained firm. Although some black Christians in Mississippi chose to stay with white believers after the demise of chattel enslavement, African Americans in Texas and Alabama voluntarily and cordially severed ties with their former owners and charted their own paths—even though often relying on white monetary support for a variety of projects. (Robinson)

David Lipscomb stood opposed to this trend, condemning in no uncertain terms the idea that whites and Blacks should not worship together. Already in 1878, he wrote in the Gospel Advocate, “We believe it sinful to have two congregations in the same community for persons of separate and distinct races now.” In 1907, in response to the situation in which the church in Bellwood, Tennessee wanted a Black girl to attend a Black congregation (mentioned at the beginning of the previous post), Lipscomb basically asserted that such a congregation cannot be a true church of Christ: “I would expect the Master to refuse to meet with or accept the service of such a church.”

Nevertheless, Black churches of Christ did form when Black Christians were not welcome in white churches. One of the earliest Black churches of Christ was established by George Ricks, who had been an enslaved African and learned to read due to his master’s wife, Charlotte Ricks, “who violated the slaveowner’s code,” according to Edward Robinson. George Ricks became the first Black property owner in Alabama, and he became a preacher at the Christian Home Church of Christ, near Muscle Shoals.

Members of white churches of Christ were sometimes members of the KKK (though H. Leo Boles basically said that a KKK member couldn’t be a Christian; Gospel Advocate [March 10, 1927]: 232). Both white and Black church members) often favored segregation. The Black leader S. R. Cassius (1853–1931) tried to illuminate the racism in churches of Christ to which white leaders seemed blind.

Cassius understood something that most white Stone-Campbell leaders failed to comprehend: namely, that centuries of chattel enslavement had tainted their view of black people, causing them to underestimate “our intelligence” and overestimate ‘their ability to give us what we needed then and still—a pure gospel.” White decision makers, explained Cassius, “forgot that four hundred years of slavery had bred a prejudice that even zeal for the cause of Christ could not overcome, and that in the mind of every white man lurked the thought the Negro was, in some way, inferior and that the Negro himself had been taught to suspect and fear the white man.” (Robinson)

But the ideology of churches of Christ—specifically that this movement represented the one true church and was distinct from every other religious body in the world—contributed to a distinctive approach to issues of race, fostering relationships among whites and Blacks while also compelling preachers to focus more on eternal matters than on civil rights.

These sources illustrate the divergent experiences and perspectives among white Churches of Christ in the years preceding the 1960s. Admonitions against racial prejudice could serve as the basis for a Sunday school lesson, but jokes that depended on crude racial stereotypes might appear in church bulletins or sermon outlines. Black preachers could preach to predominantly white audiences, and white preachers could speak in black churches. But most communities, in the South and elsewhere, maintained separate facilities for blacks and whites. Even in these paradoxical contexts, personal and interracial relationships were sometimes established. And all along, most white members of Churches of Christ would affirm without equivocation that all people were equal in Christ and that God was “no respecter of persons.” The primary objective, however, for both black and white Churches of Christ was practicing their conception of New Testament Christianity. Maintaining their identity as restorers of the primitive church took precedence above all temporal concerns, including race relations. (Key)

There were certainly moments of head-shaking racial prejudice, which prompted varying reactions among Black Christian leaders. Marshall Keeble is well-known for his practice of putting up with much racist nonsense in order to not distract from spreading the gospel, while other Black leaders were often more vocal in pushing back. (For these two approaches among Black preachers outside churches of Christ, see David G. Holmes in Allen.)

In 1920, A. M. Burton and white Christians in Nashville organized the Southern Practical Institute for African American students. C. E. W. Dorris, a white minister and superintendent of the new school, demanded that students, all of them black, enter the building through the back door. [G. P.] Bowser, principal of the fledgling institution, vehemently denounced the practice since the school was only for African Americans. [Marshall] Keeble exhorted Bowser to accept the back-door policy, as long as students obtained the “Christian education they so much desired.” Unrepentant, Bowser abruptly resigned his post as principal, left the school, and urged other black parents to withdraw their children, resulting in the school’s hasty demise. Keeble passively accepted racism as long as he achieved his evangelistic or educational goals; Bowser adamantly repudiated racism even when it eliminated opportunities for himself or other African Americans. (Robinson)

As it was for everyone, the Civil Rights movement was difficult for churches of Christ. Black leaders continued to call out racism as they saw it. Norman Anderson’s 1965 essay in the journal Christian Echo described racism as a “stench in the nostrils of God, and therefore subjects them [= racists, specifically “white Christians”] to eternal damnation.” In 1963, R. N. Hogan railed against segregated Christian colleges “headed by so-called gospel preachers and they are living in rebellion against God.” Andrew J. Hairston, preacher for the Simpson Street Church of Christ in Atlanta, suggested that white churches of Christ stop calling themselves Church of Christ and instead use the name “Church of the White Man.”

Most of the colleges affiliated with churches of Christ continued to prohibit Black students through the early 1960s, and the students at these all-white colleges sometimes engaged in what is today considered clearly racist activities. “Students at all of the aforementioned colleges enjoyed minstrel shows that caricatured blacks, but they seemed to be most popular at Freed-Hardeman, where they received prominent coverage in the Skyrocket [the student newspaper] and remained annual events through the spring of 1964, just before the first black students arrived on camps” (Key). For example, this advertisement appeared in the February 1963 issue of the S…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit edmongallagher.substack.com