Some Christians are Bible people, and others are prayer people. This classification is my invention. I am not completely sure that it’s original with me, but I did not read about it in Scripture and I have not encountered anyone else who makes the same distinction. Let me tell you what I mean by it. My impression is that some Christians gravitate more toward Bible study and others gravitate more toward prayer. There might be some Christians who enjoy both disciplines, but it seems to me that the overlap is small. There is probably a much bigger overlap for those Christians who enjoy neither prayer nor Bible study.
So, which are you? If you could choose one or the other, prayer or Bible study, which would you choose? Or if you have time to do only one of these before you’ve got to take the kids to school, which one? Or, which of these comes more naturally to you, or gives you more comfort? Or, which one excites you more, or intimidates you less? They are both essential Christian acts, and we can grow in either one, but chances are one of them is going to appeal to us more. I’m a Bible person. In my experience, most Christians are prayer people. I am jealous of the prayer people.
Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Let me circle back to the absence of this classification in Scripture. It would not be true to say that Jesus was a prayer person more than a Bible person. It is true that we catch him praying several times in the Gospels and hardly ever reading Scripture (cf. Luke 4:16–21), but the Evangelists depict Jesus as having a great deal of Scripture stuck in his head. Maybe he didn’t read Scripture often, but it does seem that he meditated on it routinely. His accusation that the Sadducees knew not the Scriptures (Mark 12:24) could not have been lobbed at him. So also the apostle Paul cannot be categorized as one or the other—a prayer person or a Bible person—but both.
The New Testament does not present this distinction as an inevitability, certainly not as desirable. It seems to me to articulate an obvious characteristic of both myself and many of the Christians I have known most intimately, but I wonder if the distinction would make less sense in an ecclesial context different from mine. At any rate, if we find one of these practices (prayer or study/meditation) more difficult than the other, we are in good company and, as always, practice makes perfect.
I want to be a prayer person because I want to be a person who gives myself wholly over to God. I want to be the kind of person who directs everything in my life to God. It seems like that’s what prayer represents. I want to be the kind of person who prays without ceasing. I want to say the words of Psalm 143:6 with full sincerity: “I stretch forth my hands unto thee: my soul thirsteth after thee, as a thirsty land.”
After all, this is how my Christian life began when I was baptized. Whether I realized it at the time or not, my baptism marked the death of one lifestyle and the beginning of a new one, so that I am not a slave of sin, and certainly not a slave to myself, but, as Paul says in Romans 6:18, a slave to righteousness. I buried in those waters my selfishness, my pride, my anger, my impatience, and every other work of the flesh, and I rose up to walk in newness of life. Just as Paul was crucified with Christ (Gal 2:20), so also he says that I have been (Rom 6:6), so that I am now “alive unto God through Jesus Christ our Lord” (6:11). Which means—if we can skip forward to Romans 8—that I am not led by the flesh but by the Spirit. Since I have received the Spirit of adoption, I cry out Abba, Father (8:15). When I reflect on the significance of my baptism, I want to be a prayer person, someone in constant communication with God, someone who recognizes with Augustine, and even earlier with David, that my soul is restless until it finds rest in God. As Evagrius said in the fourth century, a theologian is one who prays, and I would like to be such a theologian.
But, I’m not a prayer person, I’m a Bible person. Or does that distinction even make any sense? Like I said, I think the distinction does make sense of my experience, and the experience of other Christians I have known, Christians I’ve gone to church with. And, I will say, since I’m a Bible person, I can testify that there are a lot of prayers in the Bible—I mean, a lot. And in some religious contexts, prayer and Bible go together more intimately than I am accustomed to.
I was thinking about these issues at the end of 2024 when I heard about a new podcast that would start at the beginning of the year, The Rosary in a Year. Obviously this is a Catholic podcast. I had heard about the Rosary, but I didn’t know much about it. A string of beads popped into my head. I decided to investigate. The point of the beads is to aid in counting the prayers, because there’s a lot of repetition in the Rosary, and so keeping your fingers on the appropriate bead helps you to remember, “am I on prayer #6 or #7?” I watched a video showing people praying the Rosary, and you can get the basic idea from the Wikipedia article. The whole prayer usually takes about 15 minutes. Here’s how it goes, or at least how it begins: you start by making the sign of the cross, and then you recite the Apostles’ Creed, and then you say the Lord’s Prayer, and then you say three Hail Marys, and then the Glory Be. And then you say a whole bunch more Hail Marys. (Here’s especially where you need the beads.)
Anyway, I’m not going to be praying the Rosary. And I ended up not subscribing to that podcast, the Rosary in a Year. But I’m glad to see that a lot of the prayer is taken directly from Scripture. Maybe I shouldn’t make a distinction between prayer people and Bible people. Maybe a Catholic would say it’s all just one and the same. (For instance, familiarize yourself with lectio divina or the Liturgy of the Hours.) In fact, Catholics basically do say that: according to The Catechism of the Catholic Church, “The catechesis of children, young people, and adults aims at teaching them to meditate on The Word of God in personal prayer, practicing it in liturgical prayer, and internalizing it at all times in order to bear fruit in a new life” (CCC 2688). Did you hear that? “Meditate on the Word of God in personal prayer.” Prayer and Scripture go hand in hand.
Jews might say that, too. I guess the most famous Jewish prayer is called the Shema, which observant Jews have been saying twice every day, morning and evening, for thousands of years by now. Do you know where that prayer comes from? It’s Scripture. Deuteronomy 6:4 (and other passages). The prayer is essentially a recitation of Scripture.
The same sort of thing, Scripture and prayer combined, describes some form of prayers in monasteries. Did you know there are monks who pray through the entire Psalter—all 150 Psalms—every single week. The Rule of Saint Benedict from the sixth century says that any monk that doesn’t recite the entire Psalter every week is slothful. Think about the benefits here. Not only do you fill your mind with Scripture, and specifically with the book of Scripture that is almost entirely addressed to God, but also you fill your time with meditation on God. It doesn’t give you much time for sin. If the idle mind is the devil’s playground, a mind committed to going through the Psalter weekly, in addition to other reading and praying, gives the devil little opportunity to play. Jesus tells a story about an unclean spirit (Matt 12:43–45). A common way of getting an application out of that parable is to say that you should not just clean up your life, but you need to fill it with good things. Don’t just sweep your house and put it in order. If you’re praying through the Psalter weekly, the amount of time that you can dedicate to porn is very limited. Or to go out drinking with your friends.
So if prayer is the …