This essay is based on a sermon I preached several weeks ago. The video for the sermon is at the end of this post. I have continued to think about these issues, and I’m sure I’m not done thinking about them. Perhaps this way of approaching the subject of Christian forgiveness will be helpful to people.
To err is human, to forgive divine.
There’s an episode of the TV show Blue Bloods called “Bad Company” (season 5, episode 18—find it on Disney+) that has an amazing scene, one that has stuck in my mind for years now. There’s a young woman named Sarah Grant who is angry at a man named Donald Berry. She has good reason to be angry. Donald Berry is in prison and will never get out because of what he did to Sarah’s family perhaps fifteen years earlier. I’ll let you use your imagination about the crime, or watch the episode. The scene I mentioned takes place in the prison, when Sarah visits this man, who wants to talk to her to explain that he is sorry, that he was diagnosed only in prison as a paranoid schizophrenic, that he has now found God, that he is a different person from what he was. He says that he has tried to end his life a number of times. And Sarah Grant’s response to all this is to say that if he’s really sorry for what he did, he should try suicide again and get it right this time.
Thanks for reading Gallagher! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
That’s the end of the scene and the storyline. We never hear from these people again.
I remember watching that scene for the first time, years ago, and thinking, “Wow! What are we supposed to get out of this? What were the producers of this show wanting to say?” And I’m not sure.
That scene reminds me of Natalie Maines.
Forgive, sounds good.Forget, I’m not sure I could.They say time heals everything,But I’m still waiting
Lloyd Vogel is a bit like Sarah Grant. He is angry at a man who treated his family poorly, and he doesn’t want to get over his anger. He has good reason to be angry, not as good as Sarah Grant has, but still pretty good. Lloyd is angry at his father, Jerry, because perhaps twenty years earlier, when Lloyd’s parents were married and Lloyd’s mom got sick, Jerry left, abandoned the family, couldn’t handle the pressure of family life, especially with a sick wife. Lloyd’s mom died when Lloyd was, I dunno, twelve years old maybe, and Lloyd spent the next twenty years pursuing his career and hating his father. I’m describing to you the backstory of the wonderful movie, A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood (2019), the one where Tom Hanks plays Mr. Rogers—which, by the way, is not a kids movie. After Lloyd Vogel developed a relationship with Mr. Rogers, and learned from him about dealing with anger, he had a dream of his sick mom, and he went up to her bedside, and she said to him, “I know you’re hanging on to this anger, this hatred, for my sake. You think your anger toward your dad is honoring me.” And she says to him, “I don’t need it.”
Look, I haven’t ruined the movie for you; you ought to watch it. And if you haven’t seen it in the past six months, you ought to watch it again. It’s good. You can watch it with your kids in the room; they’ll just be bored. But you won’t be.
Now I’m about to ruin the movie for you. Not really, because you knew it had to happen: Lloyd reconciles with his father. There is forgiveness. He manages to do what Sarah Grant could not do. Earlier Lloyd was angry, bitter, and when he manages to release that anger and forgive his dad, he himself feels liberated, joyful. What’s that that they say? —that holding onto a grudge is like drinking poison and hoping the other person dies. Letting go of the anger is good for you.
I can understand why Sarah Grant is angry, but I can also say that it’s bad for her, that she would be better off releasing her anger and forgiving this murderer. I don’t mean that they should be best friends, or even have any sort of relationship at all. But he asked for her forgiveness, and she should offer it.
That’s the Christian way.
Forgiveness and Reconciliation
But if Sarah Grant is not going to have a relationship with the person who harmed her family, is that really forgiveness? To what extent does forgiveness involve reconciliation?
I’ve got three answers, three buckets of forgiveness, three different categories by which to measure the relationship between forgiveness and reconciliation. Sometimes forgiveness entails a complete restoration of a relationship, and sometimes it doesn’t. The third bucket of forgiveness I’m not actually sure should be called forgiveness as the Bible talks about forgiveness, but we’ll get to that.
These are my buckets, not God’s buckets. I didn’t find these buckets in the Bible; I just devised them from observing life. I think it’s helpful to contemplate forgiveness in these three categories, but you could come up with a few—or even many—more buckets if you think about it enough. People are complicated, and there are all kinds of situations that don’t fit neatly into these three categories, but I think these three categories do cover a lot of the ground.
I’ll name these off and then talk about them:
* Total Reconciliation
* Partial Reconciliation
* No Reconciliation
Buckets 1 & 2: Total Reconciliation and Partial Reconciliation
The common element for both of these categories is that the offender repents and asks for forgiveness. What distinguishes the two is the nature of the offense and whether it would wise for both parties to return to business as usual.
Bucket 1, Total Reconciliation. The person repents and asks for forgiveness, and you not only forgive and welcome the person back into a relationship, but there is a complete restoration of the previous relationship.
Bucket 2, Partial Reconciliation—or you could call this one: Forgiveness without trust. The person repents and asks for forgiveness, and you forgive and welcome the person back into a relationship, but there is not a complete restoration of the previous relationship.
The examples I am thinking of here have to do with the nature of the sin that the person committed. Maybe the person had been the church treasurer and had embezzled funds and gambled away the money. Forgiving the person does not mean restoring them to their role as church treasurer. Maybe the person sexually abused kids in the church. Forgiving the person does not entail asking them to babysit your kids.
Are there biblical examples of Bucket 1? The Parable of the Prodigal Son seems to me the most obvious. This is a picture of divine forgiveness. Literally. The Father who offers forgiveness to his prodigal son represents God. It’s a good message to us, and I think it means this: whenever God forgives, there is always total reconciliation of the relationship.
Are there biblical examples of one person forgiving another person in this way? I can’t really think of any.
Bucket 1 is difficult. Let me tell you why (as I think). We are perfectly fine forgiving people completely when it comes to rather minor sins, perhaps ones of which we were not even aware. Have you had the experience where someone apologizes to you for some offense, and you’re response is something along the lines of, “I don’t know what you’re talking about.” Person X has said something, or done something, and at the time it didn’t even register with you, but Person X soon feels bad about saying or doing that thing, and can’t sleep that night, and finally has to confess the wrongdoing. It bothered the offender but the offendee didn’t even know. And so the offendee is perfectly happy to say, “no problem, all is forgotten,” and the offendee really means it. In this case, there is a complete restoration of the relationship, but there was never really any offense to begin with.
When there’s really an offense, when someone says something really nasty that does register with you, or does something harmful to your career, or to yo…