For many Christians today, the “Five Solas” of the Reformation are treated like sacred slogans, often repeated but rarely examined. For others, they’ve become targets of suspicion or dismissal, as if they were mere relics of a theological battle long past. But before we can critique or defend them, we need to understand what they meant in their original context.
That’s the goal of this series: not to tear down but to build a fair and accurate foundation. Before we analyze where each Sola might fall short, we want to begin by presenting each one at its strongest. That means going back to the sources. What did Luther mean by faith alone? What did Calvin mean when he said we are saved by grace alone? Did the Reformers really reject tradition entirely with Scripture alone? And what role did the Church, the sacraments, and obedience play in their thinking?
This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
It’s tempting to argue against a caricature or to blindly defend a slogan without knowing its depth. But neither approach honors the truth. These five statements—Sola Scriptura, Sola Fide, Sola Gratia, Solus Christus, and Soli Deo Gloria—did not emerge from thin air. They were forged in the fires of conflict, expressed in the writings and confessions of the Reformers, and refined by centuries of theological reflection with a conviction to understand God’s revelation to man and follow Him fully.
In the posts ahead, we’ll examine each of these Solas in depth. We’ll ask where they’re biblical, where they may depend on how we define certain terms, and where they’ve been misunderstood or misapplied. But first, we need to let them speak for themselves. That’s where we begin: not with critique but with clarity.
The Origins of the 5 Solas
The Reformers didn’t gather around a table and draft a tidy list of five “Solas” to summarize their theology at some “Council of the Five Solas.” The phrase is a later theological construct coined to capture the central emphases that emerged from the Reformation movement as a whole. The Solas weren’t formalized together in a single document; they developed over time into a framework that helped define what Protestants believed and what they rejected.
Each Sola arose as a theological response to a specific tension with Catholic doctrine and practice:
* Sola Scriptura resisted the idea that Scripture and Church tradition were equal in authority. It asserted that while traditions and councils may have value, they must always be judged by Scripture, not alongside it.
* Sola Fide rejected the system of justification through faith plus merit or sacramental works. It emphasized that faith, rightly understood, is the only means by which one is declared righteous before God.
* Sola Gratia countered the notion that human cooperation or merit contributed to salvation. It affirmed that salvation begins and ends with God’s gracious initiative.
* Solus Christus denied the necessity of priestly mediation or the invocation of saints. Christ alone is the mediator between God and humanity (1 Timothy 2:5).
* Soli Deo Gloria protested against ecclesiastical pride and indulgence-driven religion, returning the spotlight to God’s glory as the ultimate goal of all things.
This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Historically, these themes emerged over decades, not all at once:
* Sola Scriptura took center stage early in Martin Luther’s 1519 Leipzig Disputation and again at the Diet of Worms in 1521, when he famously stood his ground, saying, “My conscience is captive to the Word of God.”
* Sola Fide was emphasized in Luther’s commentary and preface to Romans (1522) and enshrined in the Augsburg Confession (1530), the foundational Lutheran statement of faith.
* Sola Gratia was given theological depth by Philip Melanchthon in Loci Communes (1521), one of the first systematic Protestant theologies, and reinforced by Calvin in the Institutes of the Christian Religion.
* Solus Christus and Soli Deo Gloria were often implicit in early Protestant thought but became more prominent in the Reformed tradition, especially in the Heidelberg Catechism (1563) and later Puritan and Calvinist theology.
By the 17th century, Protestant theologians used these phrases as shorthand to defend the heart of the Reformation faith. The five Solas became theological banners because they collectively captured the Reformers’ vision of returning to the authority of Scripture, the sufficiency of Christ, and the saving initiative of God.
Why This Matters
For those of us in the Restoration Movement and Churches of Christ, revisiting the five Solas is not just an academic exercise or a historical reflection; it’s an opportunity to sharpen our convictions and engage with the theological assumptions that shape much of the Protestant world today.
In many ways, the instinct behind the Solas mirrors our own plea to return to the authority of Scripture, to remove the baggage of human additions, and to exalt Christ as the center of all things. Yet, there are distinct differences between the Reformers’ theology and the faith we see modeled in the New Testament, especially in understanding faith, grace, baptism, authority, and discipleship. Ironically enough, there are also significant differences between the original meaning of the Solas and how they are used by many modern Protestants and Evangelicals today.
That’s one of the key reasons this series matters: if we want to teach, engage, and evangelize those from other traditions—especially Protestants who revere the Solas—we need to understand both what the Reformers meant and how their slogans have evolved. A clear grasp of these concepts equips us to speak their language while grounding our convictions in Scripture rather than slogans.
Too often, Restorationists either embrace some of the Solas uncritically or reject them entirely without knowing what they originally meant. Both responses can be problematic, but neither approach honors our calling to test everything by the Word of God.
Thanks for reading! This post is public so feel free to share it.
This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
