You’ve probably heard someone say it before. Maybe you’ve even said it yourself: “I don’t need the Church to follow Jesus.” For many people, it sounds like freedom. It sounds authentic. Why deal with the drama of organized religion when you can just read your Bible, pray, and try to live a good life?
Here’s the problem. That kind of Christianity—privatized, disconnected, and self-managed—doesn’t come from Jesus. It comes from modern individualism. It’s a product of the culture we live in, not the gospel we’ve received.
Test Everything is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Yes, the Church has made mistakes. Some people have been deeply hurt by religious leaders or betrayed by those who should have shown grace. Some churches feel cold, unhealthy, or shallow. But none of that changes what Scripture teaches.
From start to finish, the Bible assumes that to belong to Jesus is to belong to His people. Christianity was never meant to be a solo project.
Where Did This Idea Come From?
In the last few centuries, Western society has shifted toward a deeply individualistic mindset. The Enlightenment encouraged people to trust their own reason above outside authority. Faith became less about belonging to a community and more about personal opinion. That was only the beginning.
In the American context, rugged individualism became a cultural virtue. People were taught to carve out their own path, define their own truth, and take responsibility for their own spiritual journey. Add to that the rise of consumerism and religion began to look less like a covenant and more like customization. If something in a church doesn’t suit your preferences, you can simply leave; or stay home and do it on your own.
We now live in an “everything goes” society, where truth is treated as subjective and morality is viewed as personal. In that kind of culture, the Church is often seen as restrictive. Its call to holiness, repentance, obedience, and mutual accountability feels out of step with a world that prefers to be left alone. The demands of authentic Christian discipleship and the natural moral guardrails that come from being part of a church family clash with a mindset that says, “I define my own life, and no one tells me otherwise.”
This trend has only accelerated with the rise of “online church.” What began as a helpful tool, especially during times when gathering wasn’t possible, has become, for many, a substitute for real-life fellowship. But watching a livestream isn’t the same thing as participating in the body of Christ. Online church gives the illusion of connection without the reality of commitment. You can watch a sermon, sing along with a song, and log off without ever being known, challenged, or supported. That’s not church; that’s spiritual entertainment.
Even the language of faith has shifted. The ancient Church confessed together, “We believe.” Modern Christianity often says, “I believe.” And while personal faith is essential, the Bible never treats belief as an isolated experience. It calls us into something larger than ourselves.
This is where the idea of “just me and Jesus” came from. It’s not rooted in Scripture or the early Church. It’s a modern invention built on the values of independence, privacy, and personal autonomy. And while it may sound empowering, it actually cuts us off from the very things we were created for: fellowship, accountability, shared worship, and growth in community.
The Dangers of “Just Me and Jesus”
At first glance, solo Christianity might seem harmless. It feels simple, flexible, and maybe even more “pure.” But in practice, it leads to serious spiritual problems.
Isolation breeds self-deception. Proverbs 18:1 warns that “the one who lives alone is self-indulgent, showing contempt for all sound judgment.” When you’re cut off from other believers, no one challenges your blind spots, no one sharpens your thinking, and no one helps you grow beyond your preferences. Without community, you start shaping Jesus into your own image instead of being shaped into His.
Disconnection leads to doctrinal drift. Ephesians 4:14 says that immature believers are “tossed to and fro and blown about by every wind of doctrine.” The local church, when grounded in Scripture, protects us from error and anchors us in truth. When we remove ourselves from that anchor, we become vulnerable to whatever teachings sound appealing at the moment, regardless of whether they’re biblical.
Going it alone leaves the mission incomplete. Jesus didn’t just save people individually; He formed a people for His name. The Church is meant to be His hands and feet in the world: serving, teaching, comforting, evangelizing. If every Christian isolated themselves and tried to “do church at home,” the witness of the gospel would wither. Christianity isn’t meant to be a solo journey. It’s a body, a family, a community on mission together.
When someone tries to follow Jesus apart from His Church, they end up cutting themselves off from the very context God designed for spiritual health. What may feel like freedom is actually a slow form of starvation.
The Biblical Vision of the Church
If you read the New Testament with unbiased eyes, one thing becomes immediately apparent: there’s no such thing as a Christian who isn’t part of a church. The idea of someone being saved but not belonging to the gathered people of God simply isn’t in the text. In fact, Scripture shows the opposite.
In Acts 2:41, those who received Peter’s message were baptized, and “that day about three thousand persons were added.” Added to what? Verse 47 tells us: “The Lord added to their number those who were being saved.” In other words, salvation and community are inextricably linked. God doesn’t just forgive sins and walk away; He adopts people into a family and places them into a community.
Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 12: “Just as the body is one and has many members, and all the members of the body, though many, are one body, so it is with Christ.” He goes on to say that every believer is a part of this body, with gifts and responsibilities that only make sense in relationship to the rest of the body. A Christian who tries to live disconnected from the Church is like a hand trying to survive apart from the arm. It might be technically alive for a moment, but not for long.
Ephesians 2:19 says, “You are no longer strangers and aliens, but you are citizens with the saints and also members of the household of God.” Families don’t function in isolation. The New Testament doesn’t invite believers to “visit” church like consumers. It calls them to belong; to be rooted, invested, and accountable.
Test Everything is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Hebrews 10:24–25 gives this instruction: “Let us consider how to provoke one another to love and good deeds, not neglecting to meet together, as is the habit of some.” Even in the first century, some were already trying to live their faith alone. The author of Hebrews calls that a mistake.
There are dozens of “one another” commands in the New Testament: love one another, bear with one another, forgive one another, exhort one another. None of these can be obeyed in isolation. Christianity without the Church isn’t just incomplete; it’s disobedient.
The Church isn’t optional. It’s central to the Christian life. Every metaphor Scripture gives for God’s people assumes community: body, temple, flock, household. There’s no category for a solo Christian. To follow Jesus is to follow Him with His people.
Common Objections and Honest Struggles
It’s easy to understand why some people pull away from the Church. For many, it’s not about rebellion; it’s about disappointment, disillusionment, or pain. And while none of these justify walking away from the body of Christ, they do deserve to be addressed with honesty and compassion.
“The Church hurt me.”
This is one of the most common and heartbreaking reasons people leave the Church. Abuse of power, hypocrisy, judgmental attitudes, and broken leadership have driven many away. That grief is real, and it shouldn’t be dismissed. But even when the Church fails, the answer isn’t to abandon it altogether. Jesus never gave up on His people. He calls us to pursue healing, not isolation. Finding a faithful, grace-filled church is hard work, but it’s worth it. You can’t heal from church wounds by avoiding church altogether; you heal by stepping back into a healthy community.
“I can worship God anywhere.”
That’s true in a sense. You can praise God while hiking a mountain or driving your car. But worship in Scripture isn’t just personal expression; it’s corporate and covenantal. The early Church worshiped together. They shared communion, heard the Word read aloud, sang together, confessed their sins together, and prayed together. Those aren’t things you can fully experience in isolation. Worship is both vertical and horizontal.
“The Church is full of hypocrites.”
Yes, it is, and we have a seat for one more. Jesus died for every one of us. He said, “I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners.” The Church isn’t a place for people who have it all together. It’s a place for people who know they need grace. If we left every space where flawed people exist, we’d have nowhere left to go, not even our own homes. Don’t let the failures of people cause you to miss the faithfulness of God through His Church.
“I feel closer to God on my own.”
That might be true for a time. But feelings are not the measure of spiritual health. What often happens in those moments is that you’re not drawing near to the God revealed in Scripture; you’re drawing near to your own idea of God. When no one is there to teach, challenge, or sharpen you, God starts to look a lot like you: same opinions, same priorities, same blind spots. That’s not spiritual intimacy; it’s self-projection.
The Beauty and Necessity of the Church
You weren’t meant to do this alone. The Christian life was never designed to be an isolated, personal project. From the very beginning, God has been forming a people. He is not just saving individuals; He is building a community. That community is the Church.
Yes, the Church can be messy. It’s made up of sinners. But it is also the place where God’s grace becomes visible. It’s where faith gets rooted, where love is tested, where truth is taught, and where hope is practiced. It’s not perfect, but it’s still part of God’s plan.
Ephesians 3:10 says that God’s wisdom is made known through the Church. That means the Church is not a spiritual add-on. It’s central to God’s work in the world. When you remove yourself from it, you’re not just avoiding community; you’re stepping away from the very thing God is using to shape His people and carry out His mission.
Christianity is not a solo journey. It is a life of shared worship, mutual growth, honest accountability, and loving service. It is walking with others as you follow Christ together. That kind of life cannot be lived in a vacuum. It only happens in local churches, among real people, in real places, through ordinary rhythms of grace.
If you have been hurt by the Church, don’t give up. If you’ve drifted into isolation, come back. If you’ve never belonged to a church at all, now is the time to find one. Not just to sit in a pew but to participate: to be known, loved, challenged, and sent.
Jesus didn’t die to create a scattered collection of spiritual loners. He died to redeem a people for Himself, and you belong with them.
Thanks for reading Test Everything! This post is public so feel free to share it.
Test Everything is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
