I. The Grocery Receipt
The total was $187.43. Daniel Mercer looked at the screen as if it had accused him of something. He had bought chicken thighs, eggs, coffee, detergent, toothpaste, frozen dumplings, spinach, apples, yogurt, two onions, a bag of rice, and a box of cereal whose price suggested the oats had been individually educated. He pressed CALL ATTENDANT. A woman in a blue vest appeared. “I think something scanned twice.” She looked at the receipt. “Nothing scanned twice.” Daniel asked if she was sure. She looked again, mostly because he was standing there with the expression of a man who had discovered accounting fraud. “Nope.” Daniel examined the cart. No wine. No steak. No imported cheese. Nothing that could plausibly explain one hundred eighty-seven dollars. The attendant handed him the receipt. “Everything’s expensive now.” Daniel hated this sentence. People had begun saying it the way medieval Europeans must have said, The plague is back.
On the drive home he called Marcus. “One hundred eighty-seven dollars.” Marcus asked what for. “Groceries.” How many people? “One.” Marcus told him he bought stupid coffee. Daniel said he had bought one bag. “You buy the one with the volcano on it.” Daniel protested that it was from Guatemala. “It’s coffee.” Daniel was forty-three years old, an electrical engineer, and made $146,000 a year. He had spent fifteen years becoming the sort of person who did not need opinions about the price of coffee. This, more than the number itself, offended him. “I should be able to buy coffee.” Marcus pointed out that he could. “Without thinking about it.” Marcus paused. “That is a different economic category.”
At home Daniel put the groceries away, opened his laptop, and created an Excel file called THINGS THAT ARE APPARENTLY LUXURIES NOW.xlsx. He entered: good coffee, olive oil, homeowners insurance, dentist, calling a plumber before watching YouTube. Then he added, Leaving thermostat at 72, and saved the file. For six months, it was a joke. Then the joke acquired tabs.
Daniel was not poor. This was important to him. He owned a house outside Columbus, Ohio, purchased when people said things like three-and-a-half-percent mortgage without realizing they were describing a lost civilization. Three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a maple tree he resented every November, and a garage full of abandoned evidence that he had once believed weekends were renewable. His salary had risen. His 401(k) had risen. Zillow insisted the house was worth much more than he had paid. Everything was going up, and yet Daniel kept cutting things. One evening he pulled a decade of salary history into another spreadsheet and compared it with groceries, insurance, utilities, taxes, healthcare, home maintenance, and what replacing the Subaru would cost. His income had increased impressively. His life had not.
Money had always appealed to him because it resembled measurement. Dollars translated unlike things into a common unit: an hour of labor, a roof repair, a chicken breast, a dental crown. Now the measuring instrument itself seemed to be drifting. He thought of a sensor losing calibration. The display could remain precise while becoming less truthful. Daniel added another row to the spreadsheet: Salary increase. He laughed. The second time he opened the file, he didn’t.
II. The Safest Investment in the World
His father called on a Sunday morning. “Are bonds safe?” Richard Mercer was seventy-four and had reached the age when questions arrived without greeting. Daniel asked what kind. “Treasuries.” Daniel said yes. “Then why am I losing money?” Daniel went quiet. Richard asked if he didn’t know. “I’m an electrical engineer.” Richard said, “You people know everything.” Daniel replied, “Software engineers told everyone that. The rest of us got dragged into it.”
Richard had retired from a utility company with a modest pension, Social Security, and an investment account designed by an adviser whose philosophy seemed to be that retirement should become progressively less interesting. Stocks. Bonds. Cash. Nothing with a mascot. “I thought the government pays these back,” Richard said. Daniel agreed. “So why are they down?” Daniel told him he would call later. Richard said, “You don’t know.” Daniel reminded him that he had already admitted this.
Daniel spent the afternoon reading enough about bonds to resent himself for not having learned it sooner. Rates rise; older bonds paying lower rates become less attractive; their market value falls. Fine. Then he kept reading. Everyone knew the federal debt was enormous. The number appeared periodically on television with enough zeros to become decorative. Thirty trillion. Thirty-five. Forty. At a certain scale, Daniel thought, numbers became weather.
What bothered him was the interest. Bonds matured. New bonds replaced them. Fresh deficits required more borrowing. Debt issued cheaply did not remain cheap forever. If more of it rolled into higher rates, interest expense grew. More interest enlarged deficits. Larger deficits required more borrowing. Daniel drew a loop on a yellow pad: DEBT → INTEREST → DEFICIT → DEBT. His profession had trained him to distrust positive feedback. Positive feedback made systems exciting shortly before it made them unusable.
The next morning Abby Patel, a younger engineer on his team, saw the pad beside his keyboard. “You know that loop isn’t automatic.” Daniel looked up. “I know.” Abby said that if nominal growth stayed above the effective interest burden, debt could stabilize even with a high ratio; primary deficits mattered, maturity mattered. Daniel repeated that he knew. “Then why did you draw it like a reactor meltdown?” Daniel considered this. “A reactor also operates perfectly well until certain conditions stop being true.” Abby shook her head. “Engineers should not be allowed to discover macroeconomics unsupervised.” She was right, which annoyed him. The loop was a risk, not a prophecy. That distinction reassured Daniel for approximately twelve minutes.
Then he called his father. “You’re probably going to get paid.” Richard objected to probably. Daniel told him the government owed him dollars and that the United States borrowed in its own currency. Richard asked what that had to do with anything. Daniel stopped. The federal government did not simply own a machine labeled PRINT. Treasury and the Federal Reserve were separate institutions, and the Fed was supposed to conduct monetary policy independently. But America still occupied a very different position from a household or a country owing debts in somebody else’s currency. Its own institutions governed the monetary system in which its obligations were settled.
“The problem isn’t just whether the country can find dollars,” Daniel said. “It’s whether it can maintain confidence in the institutions that make those dollars valuable.” Richard was silent. Daniel tried again. Suppose Richard was owed a thousand dollars. The government could almost certainly make sure the financial system produced the thousand. What it could not produce with equal ease was the medical care, food, electricity, housing, labor, and physical goods Richard expected those thousand dollars to command. The distinction struck Daniel as both obvious and obscene. The government could manufacture the ruler. It could not manufacture what the ruler measured.
Richard finally said, “That sounds like something politicians say when they’re stealing from you.” Daniel told him it was actually bond math. “That’s worse.” After they hung up, Daniel opened the spreadsheet and typed Being repaid in money that still works. He considered deleting it for melodrama. He left it.
III. Five Percent Is a Very Large Number
Kevin across the street put his house on the market. For three weeks the neighborhood followed the listing through Zillow with an intensity previously reserved for college football. Kevin and his wife had bought for $390,000. They listed at $575,000. Nobody came. Eventually someon…