A Pig Walks into a Potato Patch…
On the morning of June 15th, 1859, an American farmer named Lyman Cutlar walked out of his cabin on San Juan Island. He saw a large black pig rooting around in his potato patch. Again.
This pig had been eating his potatoes for weeks. Cutlar had chased it off. He had complained about it. He had asked the pig’s owner to control it. Nothing worked. The pig kept coming back for the potatoes.
So Cutlar grabbed his rifle and shot the pig.
That single shot almost started a war between the United States and the British Empire. Within weeks, 461 American soldiers and 2,140 British troops would face each other across the island. Five British warships would be anchored offshore. Cannons would be aimed. Orders would be shouted.
All because of one hungry pig and some potatoes.
Welcome to the Show
You’re listening to, Wait! That Actually Happened?, the podcast where we prove history is stranger than fiction. I’m your host, author Daniel P. Douglas, and today we’re heading to the Pacific Northwest in 1859 for the weirdest war that almost happened.
This is the story of the Pig War. A 12-year military standoff between two global superpowers over a single dead hog. It has warships. It has angry generals. It has a kaiser from Germany who had to come settle the whole mess. And it all started with some potatoes and a pig.
How Two Countries Ended Up Sharing an Island
First, let’s figure out where the heck we are.
San Juan Island sits in the Pacific Northwest, tucked between the Washington mainland and Canada’s Vancouver Island. It’s part of an archipelago of over 400 islands and rocks known as the San Juan Islands. Only about 128 of them are named. Only 4 are big enough to get regular ferry service. The whole group sits in the Salish Sea, which is the shared name for the waters between Washington and British Columbia.
Here’s where the geology starts making trouble. These islands are actually the tops of a sunken mountain range. About 17,000 years ago, during the last ice age, a massive glacier called the Vashon covered this whole area. The ice was 4,200 feet thick. As the glacier moved south, it scraped, carved, and gouged out the landscape like a giant bulldozer made of ice.
When the glacier finally melted, it left behind deep canyons that filled with seawater. It left behind a scattered mess of mountain tops poking out of the waves. And it left behind not one, not two, but several different channels running through the islands.
This is the geological headache at the heart of the Pig War. When Britain and the United States later tried to draw a border through “the middle of the channel,” they had a problem. The glacier had carved multiple channels. The two big ones were Haro Strait on the west side of the islands and Rosario Strait on the east side. Either one could reasonably be called the middle channel. There was even a third option running right between the islands themselves.
Whichever channel got picked would decide who owned the islands. Pick Haro Strait? The Americans get them. Pick Rosario Strait? The British get them. Pick the middle option? Everybody gets confused and it goes to court.
So when we say the Pig War started because of a pig, that’s only half true. It really started because of a glacier that carved a mess of channels 17,000 years too early and left two empires with an unsolvable geography problem.
To understand why a dead pig almost triggered a war, we need to back up 13 years.
In 1846, the United States and Great Britain signed the Oregon Treaty. This was supposed to settle a big argument about who owned the Pacific Northwest. Both countries had been arguing over the land for decades. The treaty drew a border along the 49th parallel. That’s the line you see today between Washington State and Canada.
Simple enough, right? Well, no.
The treaty said the border would run west along the 49th parallel, then drop south through the middle of the channel between the mainland and Vancouver Island. But as we just covered, the glaciers had left behind more than one channel to choose from. The treaty writers didn’t specify which one. They probably didn’t even realize the problem existed.
Nobody could agree. So both countries just started acting like they owned the islands.
By the 1850s, the British Hudson’s Bay Company had set up a large sheep farm on San Juan Island called Belle Vue Farm. They had thousands of sheep, plus pigs, cattle, and crops. An Irish man named Charles Griffin ran the whole operation. He let his pigs roam free across the island.
Meanwhile, American settlers started showing up too. Most of them were failed gold miners. They were tired, broke, and looking for free land. One of them was a 27-year-old farmer from Kentucky named Lyman Cutlar.
In April of 1859, Cutlar staked a claim to 160 acres on the island. He built a little cabin. He planted a potato patch. He did not build a fence around that patch. This would turn out to be a problem.
The American settlers and British shepherds lived near each other but mostly ignored each other. Tensions were there, but things were quiet. Everyone was just waiting for their governments to figure out who owned the place.
Then came the pig.
The Shot Heard Round the Potato Patch
Charles Griffin owned several Berkshire boars. These are big, black pigs with short snouts and an enthusiasm for eating whatever they can find. One of them had discovered Lyman Cutlar’s potato patch. And Berkshire boars do not forget a good meal.
The pig kept coming back. Cutlar chased it off with sticks. He yelled at Griffin’s employees. He complained. Nothing changed. The pig kept eating his potatoes.
On the morning of June 15th, 1859, Cutlar walked outside and saw the pig again. Standing in his garden. Rooting up his potatoes. And here’s the detail that really set him off. One of Griffin’s shepherds was nearby. Watching. Laughing.
Cutlar snapped. He grabbed his rifle and shot the pig dead.
Now, Cutlar was not trying to start a war. He immediately walked over to Griffin and admitted what he had done. He offered to pay for the pig. He offered 10 dollars. That’s about 360 dollars in today’s money. Fair price for a pig.
Griffin was not interested in fair. He demanded 100 dollars. That’s 3,600 dollars today. For one pig.
The two men argued. According to one popular story, Cutlar said, “It was eating my potatoes.” Griffin shot back, “It is up to you to keep your potatoes out of my pig.”
Historians aren’t sure if that exact exchange happened, but it captures the spirit of the thing. Neither man was backing down.
Griffin reported Cutlar to British authorities on Vancouver Island. The British threatened to arrest Cutlar and drag him to Victoria to stand trial. The American settlers on the island were furious. They weren’t about to let the British arrest one of their own.
They drew up a petition and sent it to Brigadier General William S. Harney, the U.S. Army commander for the whole Oregon region. Now here’s an important detail. Harney really, really hated the British. Like, more than was professionally appropriate. He had been looking for a reason to stick it to them for years.
When he got the petition, Harney did not consult Washington. He did not send a diplomat. He did not ask for instructions. He sent soldiers.
On July 18th, 1859, Harney ordered Captain George Pickett to take 66 men and occupy San Juan Island. Yes, that Pickett. The same George Pickett who would later lead the disastrous Pickett’s Charge at Gettysburg in the Civil War. Before that, though, he was busy almost starting a different war.
Pickett landed on San Juan Island on July 27th. He announced the island was American territory and that British law did not apply there. The British were stunned.
The governor of Vancouver Island, James Douglas, was a tough old Hudson’s Bay Company man. He was not about to let the Americans just take the island. He ordered Royal Navy Captain Geoffrey Hornby to sail to San Juan and get rid of the Americans.
Hornby showed up with three warships.…