Welcome to the land of QE4EVER. Where the rich get richer, and the poor get poorer. The wealth transfer, the inequality has only increased over these last few months. Let’s take a look at where we are, where we’ve been, and how this rickety money driven machine is falling apart before our eyes. The State of the Momentum is swinging ever further.
The year is 2020. The year has been full of volatility and change. The Corona Virus swept its way around the world, and broke further the already failing monetary system within its wake. Countries around the globe frantically reacted to COVID-19. China being ground zero for the virus, they swiftly began lockdowns of major cities and travel. Most countries soon adopted the same strategy. With stay-at-home orders issued for non-essential workers across the globe, the productivity of the global economy all but came to a halt. What answer did politicians and chairpersons of central banks have to combat this virus? They printed a ton of money to throw at the economic stagnation and a crashing stock market.
Do you remember when we were worried about the Federal Reserve lending money to banks overnight through the Repo markets? Do you remember how flabbergasted we were to learn they were throwing billions on the balance sheet to continue bailing these bankers out? Well, billions turned to trillions, and it all fell under the same umbrella of Quantitative Easing. Call it TARP, call it Repo, call it Quantitative Easing, its all the same. The Federal Reserve is printing money faster ever faster, and their corporate buddies reap the rewards from the value they are stealing from you.
The Federal Reserve within the United States alone printed $3 trillion. Yes, trillions. This quickly sent the stock market into a rally like we had never seen. But is money all that’s needed to make an economy go around? Of course not. As soon as the Federal Reserve stimulus topped out and its balance sheet began retracting, the stock market, too, began retracting its massive gains. With the stimulus being injected by the FED going directly into the hands of corporations, this “stimulus” had a rhyme to it all too similar to the bailouts of the last financial crisis of 2008. Except this time, everybody gets a bailout.
With the price of stocks only rising because of the money thrown at them by bonus hungry CEO’s, are the values of these assets actually going up, or is it merely that the dollar is being devalued so quickly that the amount of dollars to buy that same asset increases? When one looks past the FED money printer BRRRRing away before our eyes, one can see that no matter the liquidity, if the cash doesn’t flow out of the US economy then the momentum of the QE is lack luster, and the economy returns to its stagnant complacent self. So what did the FED do? They began directly purchasing assets to add to their balance sheets, and thus the market further detached itself from reality.
A free market determines the price or value of an asset, but if you have an institution buying the assets regardless of their product or performance eventually you have a degrading of the product because the company offering the product seeks to cut costs to make profit. They also become reliant on the institution continually buying their product, rather than focusing on the satisfaction the product brings their consumer base. When the institution, the FED, stops printing, the company suffers and so does the market. Bailouts for everyone!
At this point, there is only so many assets the FED can buy to prop up markets, but they have began bending the rules. They can buy US treasury bonds, mortgage-backed securities, and now corporate bonds via a special purpose vehicle the FED created. So the FED isn’t buying these corporate bonds directly. This special purpose vehicle is which makes it legal. The FED traditionally doesn’t create fiscal stimulus either, but with the addition of extra unemployment benefits, stimulus checks for all, Paycheck Protection Program loans, and bailouts for corporate entities on a mass scale they are entering new territory. Traditionally they would’ve created treasury bonds which are then bought by pensions or countries outside the US, and that money from these buyers is then distributed throughout the economy. Currently the FED is essentially creating dollars out of nothing and distributing them through these fiscal policies or its special purpose vehicle. In this manner, the FED becomes the financer and the US Treasury becomes the allocator or spender.
With debt levels on balance sheets across the globe at such high levels, the traditional means for putting dollars into the financial system is no longer effective because there is not as much capital to spend on the treasury bonds. Everyone’s balance sheets are weighed down by debt. Its taking most of the buyers capital just to service their debts. This is why the FED is having to resort to these new means.
The US consumes more than it produces which causes trade deficits to rise. Traditionally we would really on foreign buyers to pick up the treasury bonds to place within their reserves and as a safe haven investment, but again, balance sheets across the board are strapped with debt, So we don’t have the foreign buyers to resort to. The FED begins to monetize debt to then buy treasury bonds to then issue more dollars.
Since 2008, the FED has not turned off the money printer. Essentially, because it had to allocate capital to banks to keep them solvent. Banks are required to keep a minimum amount of cash reserves. This is where the 2008 bailouts went, the Repos of late 2019, and now we are already seeing signs that again the banks reserves are beginning to run low. With all this creation of wealth, one would think there would be plenty to go around for everyone, but the wealth/income gap only seems to grow greater. The rich continue to grow richer because of this top-down system. The banks lending the money cheaply to the corporations who then buy back their own stock to boost market prices. Thus padding the CEO’s own pockets with bonuses because of their companies stock gains. Essentially, Universal Basic Income for the wealthiest, as they are able to take advantage of the situation, the current crisis. The rich grow richer. The poor grow poorer, as there is less and less purchasing power within their dollar. The current situation is illustrated well within this quote by Frederic Bastiat, “When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it.”
Within the current environment, as you can see, big business thrives, as they continue getting FED handouts. At this same time, small businesses are forced to close due to the COVID-19 pandemic. In many cases, the PPP loans were not allocated to those that needed them the most, and again, big business gets a leg up on small business. There has been record unemployment and less incentive to find new work, as many are making more with their unemployment benefits than they were at their job. Many small businesses will be forced to close. They don’t have the demand for their services. Their workers aren’t going to want to return to a job they will be making less than if they sat at home. With less demand within these sectors of the economy, there simply won’t be as many jobs to return to, as the small businesses will have to make cuts to staff just to stay open.
With this reverse Robin Hood game the FED is playing, lower income households didn’t have money for an emergency before this current pandemic. The $1200 stimulus money has already ran out. The extra unemployment benefits are scheduled to end at the end of July 2020. So what is the FED to do, but print more money.
We can call this whole process the Japanification of the United States. For years the Bank of Japan has involved it…