We've now had more of January's foreign reserves data for Asia, and its generally shown modest falls, as you'd expect when the dollar strengthens and asset prices fall. To recap: China's reserves fell 0.9% mom, Japan's fell 1.4% S Korea's fell 0.3% (thanks to some very active switching out of bonds);and Indonesia fell 2.5% (includes some foreign debt repayment). But Singapore managed a 0.1% rise.
Today we had Hong Kong, which reported reserves down 0.9% mom - ie pretty much in line with what we've seen elsewhere. But there are a couple of problems: first Jan's loss comes after a year of near stasis, with the result that reserves are now falling in yoy terms. This is only marginal, but its very rare for HK, and shows that HK has received negligible reserves inflow from global QE this time - in stark contrast to the reserves bonanza HK enjoyed in 2009/2010. The second problem is this: the HK dollar is run as a currency board: in theory, if foreign reserves fall, then the net HK$ clearing balance of the banking system, or currency in circulation, has to shrink too. In simple terms, the impact of falling foreign reserves is sharper in HK than in most Asian economies. And so, in Nov HK M0 grew only 1.7% yoy, and in Dec HK$M3 only 1.5%.
And there is this third consequence: Hong Kong's continuing liquidity is increasingly being supplied by China. We have the net international breakdown of HK's banks net int'l position only up to October. But what is shows is consistent with the rising pressure: HK banks' total net assets fell by US$51bn yoy to US$327bn; but its position with China fell $41bn to a net liability of $28bn. My bet is that by January it was much deeper. Again, having a net liability position to China is very rare for HK - back in 2014 it had net assets in China of $335bn. The last time it had a net liability position was back in . . . 2008 - 2009.
What this adds up to is HK's increased financial vulnerability to a) a strengthened dollar; b) any tightening in China; plus, of course, any feedback in loss of confidence. That's quite a lot of vulnerability to take into the likely environment of 2022.
