When we heard that Kimberly-Clark wants to buy Kenvue, we had the same reaction you probably did: Wait, who’s Kenvue? And then, Seriously, What Could They be Thinking?
The $48.7 Billion Question
At first glance, this looks like a match made in your linen closet: diapers meet Tylenol, tissues meet lotion. But once you dig in, the deal starts to feel like déjà vu from the Family Dollar–Dollar Tree acquisition: two struggling retailers trying to “synergize” their way out of stagnation.
Kimberly-Clark is chasing growth in a low-growth world (fewer babies, less toilet paper). Kenvue is still shaking off its talcum powder lawsuits and PR fallout from a certain politician claiming Tylenol causes autism. (It doesn’t, for the record.)
The result? Kimberly-Clark’s stock promptly dropped nearly 20% the day of the announcement.
What’s Really Behind the Deal
Both companies face pressure from shareholders to “do something.” In this case, something means paying a 40% premium for a company with legal baggage, and claiming $2 billion in cost synergies to make the math work.
As Jaime points out:
“If you’re counting synergies you can’t measure, you’re doing fan fiction with spreadsheets.”
And Cindy adds:
“Building a culture where people feel safe to challenge bad ideas might be the most valuable synergy of all.”
The real question isn’t whether the brands fit. it’s whether the cultures do. Kimberly-Clark runs as a centralized machine. Kenvue thrives on autonomy. We’ve seen how that mismatch plays out before, and it usually ends with layoffs, brand dilution, and dashed expectations.
Leadership Lessons Hiding in Plain Sight
Every merger is a test of leadership nerve and cultural honesty.
* Are executives willing to say, “This doesn’t make sense”?
* Do employees feel safe raising red flags?
* Can leaders resist the urge to justify decisions with made-up math?
As we unpack in this episode, hope is not a strategy — and synergy is not a synonym for success.
Our Takeaway
Two desperate companies don’t make one strong one.If this deal works, it’ll be because the leaders create clarity, protect what’s working, and build a culture brave enough to say “no” before saying “merge.”
Otherwise? This might go down as the most expensive Band-Aid in corporate history.
🎧 Listen now! Here on Substack, on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your shows. And don’t forget to subscribe to Seriously, What Could They Be Thinking?
Never miss the next questionable corporate decision.Keep your spreadsheets handy and your coffee strong. ☕
