Editor’s note: Eating in America officially launches today, so we’re celebrating something most of us love – coffee! Or tea, of course, if you prefer. The voices of 11 Eating in America readers are heard in the audio/podcast version of today’s Eating in America, making it a very good day to try the audio version, if that is not your usual choice. Thank you for being a part of Eating in America as we officially launch!
I propose that the Nobel Prize for Science should be given posthumously to the goatherd Kaldi, who, 1,300 years ago in Ethiopia, observed his goats were getting very happy after eating the berries off what turned out to be a coffee bush. Kaldi’s discovery of coffee was a great leap for humankind and probably directly responsible for much of the scientific discovery to follow. To paraphrase the G.O.A.T. (that is, Greatest Of All Time) physicist Albert Einstein and the mathematician Alfréd Rényi, who was the first to say it, people are just machines to turn coffee into intelligible thought.
In even the briefest history of coffee, it is important to identify the heinous role of enslavement. It is horrible that, as with two other addictive substances, sugar and tobacco, the explosion of coffee consumption in the Western world was enabled by the kidnapping and enslavement of people from Africa. Outright slavery was used in large producing countries like Haiti and Brazil, and the coercive semi-enslavement of indigenous people made Central American coffee planters rich.
On the positive side, according to many studies, brightening our minds and our days with coffee or caffeinated tea does not seem to bring a health penalty, on balance, for most moderate users. Some studies show coffee linked to a possible reduced risk of some cancers, although one study shows an association with an increased risk of lung cancer. A study reported this past summer but not yet peer reviewed and published found a modest association between coffee drinking and healthy aging, although the study only involved women who were white. A good review of caffeinated beverage consumption published this summer covers not only biological effects but the societal framework of caffeine beverages, globally. That study examined the potential negative effects of caffeine consumption but still concluded the physical and cognitive performance benefits, as well as modest associations with the reduction of chronic disease risk, favored caffeine consumption for many people.
That all said, what we really need to know about coffee and tea is within the stories we keep in our memories and tell our friends. I received 19 coffee and tea stories to share from 12 people, all of whom are represented here. Together they reaffirm who we are and help reveal what we make of coffee and what coffee makes of us. And these stories open windows so we can see what we share with others. Here are the stories told to Eating in America.
If you’re a coffee drinker, the first two stories will likely strike a note of familiarity.
Joan Higbee in Maryland wrote:
“We went to visit my husband’s family who were all big drinkers. I didn’t drink much that evening and went to bed early. The next morning, I developed a huge headache like a hangover, and I couldn’t figure out why – I barely drank. The next morning the same thing. It was only after breakfast I found out that my sister-in-law had been serving us decaf coffee. I was mad. The rest of them deserved hangovers. I didn’t.”
Mary Waters was in California in grad school, working long hours, trying to produce a book. Having developed a terrible headache and worried she might have a brain tumor, she was referred to a specialist.
[Mary’s voice]
“So I got to go to the neurologist, and he did this whole workup on me. At one point he asked me, after he had done a lot of tests, do you drink coffee? And I was like, yes. Like how many cups? I said, well, I don’t know how many cups, but I make three pots. And he’s like, and when do the headaches start? And I was like, you know, after I drink three pots of coffee.”
Needless to say, the doctor told Mary she didn’t have a brain tumor but she really had to cut down on the coffee.
Chris Williams grew up mostly in Oklahoma and Columbia, South America, the daughter of an Air Force pilot, and reports her story from Texas. Chris found out, as she went off to sophisticated San Francisco to study to be a sociologist – someone whose job it is to understand cultural differences, that the coffee you drink, and how you drink it, can be a signal of differences between people:
[Chris’s voice]
“My coffee stories are both about culture. My first coffee story is about when I started graduate school, and I was very poor. But I also was very unsophisticated in my taste. So I got a job working at the Berkeley Journal of Sociology, and I brought my little hot pot and my Nescafé with me. My little jar of Nescafé, and I just thought that was normal. All of my fellow graduate students just thought I was the most exotic human being ever. Very unsophisticated. Like I just rolled in off the turnip truck or something like that. Meanwhile, they are all drinking these giant cups of Peet’s coffee that seemed to be half, half and half.”
“And you know, I did the calculation, and I figured that was a dollar a day. And that was huge. But you know, the culture, the cultural message was that I was doing something very taboo. So I quickly learned to invest the dollar on the giant cups of Peet’s coffee. And indeed it was more delicious.”
Chris’s San Francisco had the heritage of being the western U.S. coffee center from the start of the mid-1800s coffee boom, with Folgers Coffee there making leaps in the quality of beans bought from Central and South America. Folgers also led the way in the packaging of pre-roasted coffee, coffee previously having been roasted in the consumer’s kitchen just prior to brewing. Founder James Folger basically invented the consistently good cup of coffee. Ironically, the attitude about Nescafé that Chris found in San Francisco, the epicenter of the coffee explosion in America, was the opposite of what she had encountered growing up in Columbia, the source of fine quality coffee beans:
[Chris’s voice]
“Well, I lived in Columbia when I was a high school student and a lot of people there drank Nescafé, which was kind of surprising. So there I think the class meaning of Nescafé was different than it was in the States, more like a class marker that you were kind of at a higher level.”
Chris’s time in Columbia was in the mid-1970s when Nestlé’s, the manufacturer of Nescafé, was using grossly unethical and deceptive marketing practices to convince women in low- and middle-income countries, including Columbia, to feed their babies powdered Nestlé’s formula mixed with water instead of breast milk. By 1981, in places around the world where the drinking water was unclean, over 200,000 more babies died per year than in places with clean water. Nestlé’s, with full knowledge of the danger, was selling formula in places where few homes had a washing facility to clean a bottle and no clean water source. I’ve been to some of these places, and seen many of these homes, and it is still an issue. But a mother spending money on formula was seen as a sign she was doing the best for her baby, despite the cost.
It is no surprise that, with the giant marketing effort Nestlé’s was making in places like Chris’s Columbia, drinking Nescafé, instead of delicious Columbian coffee, was also seen as a marker of prosperity.
A 2023 series of papers on breastfeeding in the respected medical journal, The Lancet, reports that sales of formula to low- and middle-income nations continues, at a pace of $55 billion, annually. Today, less than half of infants and children around the world are breastfed as recommended by the World Health Organization.
Nestlé’s flipped the script in Columbia, turning Nescafé, a product made in a factory fr…