Listen

Description

With today’s video podcast, you have your full choice: watch, listen, or, as most do, read Eating in America. Anyway you do it, we are glad to have you here.

This post and podcast are about what’s in our food and who’s in charge of making it healthy. While RFK, Jr. and his Department of Health and Human Services are getting a lot of attention when it comes to federal action or inaction on making our food healthy, in many ways it’s the USDA, the Department of Agriculture, that’s more in charge of the healthiness of our food.

For example, the USDA is responsible for the safety and inspection of our food. The Department is a full partner with Health and Human Services in writing the Dietary Guidelines that this year famously featured the upside-down food pyramid.

But, more importantly, the 2026 USDA budget is $458 billion – nearly half of a trillion dollars. Most of that money flows to agriculture through consumers who receive food assistance like SNAP in order to put food on their tables. Folks being able to afford to eat and not go hungry is certainly a big factor in health. But also, how SNAP and the other programs allow that money to be spent in the store influences the healthiness of the food that is produced. As Jerold Mande in our interview today points out, a lot of states are now beginning to put restrictions on SNAP dollars being used to buy unhealthy products like Coca-Cola.

However, a lot of money flows through the USDA to directly support agriculture in this country, and whether that money goes to the production of fruits and vegetables that are in short supply in American diets, which it mostly doesn’t, or whether that money goes to help produce corn for ethanol, feed for cattle and pigs, or ingredients for ultraprocessed food, which are the places most of the money goes, makes a tremendous amount of difference to what our American food environment looks like.

Perhaps no one knows more about these issues and how the USDA handles them then our guest on Eating in America today, Jerold Mande.

Interview - Introduction

Jerold R. Mande is a nationally recognized expert in public health, nutrition, policy. He’s an adjunct professor of nutrition at the Harvard Chan School of Public Health and CEO of Nourish Science, an NGO dedicated to greatly increasing nutrition research, putting bite and muscle (my words) into the FDA’s regulation of food ingredients and additives, including the regulation of ultra-processed food and modernizing SNAP food assistance.

This is all towards the overarching Nourish Science mission to change the federal nutrition goal to “ensuring every child reaches age 18 at a healthy weight and in good metabolic health.”

Mande has served three presidents in senior policymaking positions at USDA, FDA, and OSHA. He has shaped nutrition, food safety, and tobacco control programs. He led the Nutrition Fact Label Design Team at FDA for George H.W. Bush.

And first but not least, Mande started his career with Al Gore in Congress, helping Gore write America’s organ donation laws.

Transcript (lightly edited for clarity)

RB: “Jerry Mande, it is such a pleasure and honor to have you on Eating in America.”

JM: “Ric, thanks for having me.”

RB: “So I get sent frequent press releases from the USDA, as I’m sure you do. And I want to save a few minutes in this discussion to get your interpretation about what’s going on with all the program and policy initiatives and media events from the USDA these days.

“But first, one of the press releases that I passed over very quickly said the USDA is closing a couple of buildings in Washington DC and Alexandria, Virginia. But that closure had a lot of meaning for you. Will you explain please Jerry, what has happened with those buildings?”

JM: “So these closures are core facilities of USDA and represent a demolishing of the culture that makes USDA such a remarkable agency, fulfilling the goal of President Lincoln, who created the agency’s mission to make it “the people’s department.”

“First, the Braddock Building in Alexandria is the home of the Food and Nutrition Service. That’s the agency within the USDA that manages 80% of the USDA budget, feeds one in four Americans each year, and houses programs such as SNAP, the Food Stamp Program, the School Meals Program, and the Women Infants and Children, or WIC, program.

“The South Building in D.C. proper is attached to the USDA main headquarters building, the Witten Building. It’s the only federal department that is actually on the mall. It’s a short walk from the White House and right next to the Washington Monument. Actually the South Building should be the headquarters building because it’s many times larger. But the headquarters is the Witten Building. It’s a beautiful building.

“The South Building when it was built in 1936 was the largest office building in America. It held that distinction until the Pentagon was built. And still today, it’s the second largest.

“So the announcement you mentioned, it doesn’t scream out that there’s a problem in getting rid of those buildings. And what they’re doing in getting rid of those buildings is moving those programs somewhere else.”

RB: “Well, it occurs to me that USDA Deputy Secretary Vaden, when he announced the closures, said Trump’s idea is to control this sprawling federal bureaucracy. But to control it, they’re actually sending it away to many far, far away places. And that seems the opposite of actually controlling sprawl!”

JM: “Just a little bit of background to help explain the impact of these closures. Earlier in my career, I worked at the Department of Health and Human Services, particularly the FDA. These were great agencies, I thought.

“And indeed, I thought that the Department of Agriculture was sort of the bad guys because of the industry influence on the issues I worked on, like food labeling, where we had to fight the USDA at every step to get the Nutrition Facts Label that we have in place today. But when I worked at HHS, something just didn’t stand out to me at all.

“The HHS, because it was cobbled together over many administrations and literally decades and decades, was scattered all across the country in different buildings and agencies. There is a big building a block off the mall. The secretary works there, but none of our agency heads work there because their agencies are scattered all across the country. I thought it was always a bit dysfunctional, and there were a lot of challenges. But I figured, this is just life in the federal government and that’s as good as it gets, I guess.

“But then in the Obama administration, I was invited to join the Department of Agriculture. And it was just this remarkable eye-opening experience that, wow, this agency operates so much better than anything I’ve ever experienced before. And it was because of the culture created by the proximity of all of the staff.”

“Secretary Vilsack, the secretary then, and all of his undersecretaries, which are the equivalent of these HHS agency heads, were literally on the same hallway in the Witten building, and all of their staff were right behind them in the big South building. As a result, we met all together, face-to-face, in-person every week. This, what I’ll call the subcabinet, and the physical proximity of all the agencies and the secretary, created just a much more effective culture.

“So the [Trump] administration is going to the HHS model: wanting to destroy the culture of the USDA and move its agencies all over.

“They began that in their first term. They ran an experiment. They took two of the smaller but important agencies at USDA, the Economic Research Service and the National Institute of Food and Agriculture, both research agencies, and decided they were going to move them to Kansas City. They did and it had the desired effect.

“People quit. People didn’t pick up and move to Kansas City. So the elite quality of those agencies was destroyed. The Biden administration tried to build them …



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.eatinginamerica.co/subscribe