PODCAST TRANSCRIPT:
Hello. This is Sarah Towle, author of Crossing the Line. Thanks for joining me for another episode of From the Borderlands.
~ ~ ~
Five years ago this week, my journey of discovery of the many-headed hydra, that is the U.S. immigration system, began in Brownsville, Texas, with the act of bearing witness to the inhumanity of the Remain in Mexico program, otherwise known as the Migrant “Protection” Protocols, which didn't protect anyone at all.
Family separation was the inciting incident that drove me to the border to see for myself the humanitarian crisis I then believed had been wrought by Trump & Co.
I would quickly learn that though they had cranked the cruelty to 11, the cruelty of the immigration system was not theirs alone.
My first day on the ground was spent in a refugee camp on the threshold of the world's richest nation. A camp of 3,000 mothers, fathers, sisters, brothers, grandparents, and tiny babies that represented 70,000 people thrust into homelessness and danger by an unwelcoming U.S. president and nation.
That first day of my journey of discovery was Epiphany Sunday, and it was an Epiphany of epiphanies, let me tell you. And though it was my intention to start this podcast there, at the start of my journey to bear witness, that eventually led me to write and publish a book, I find that I cannot.
My best-laid plans have been taken over by global events.
It is with a heavy and already weary heart and best wishes for all my friends and family in Los Angeles, for all the lives that have been impacted, and for all that has been lost to climate change — including truth — that I kick off this week with a question:
Have U.S. Customs and Border Protection gone rogue?
Trust me, there is a logic here. Let's start with the facts from this week, which are these:
* With Joe Biden still in the White House
* and more than 900 incarcerated individuals joining firefighters from Mexico and Canada to help their US counterparts battle an inferno,
* Border Patrol agents chose to move on a different so-called “foe”: farmworkers.
As fire ripped through the Pacific Palisades on the wings of hurricane-speed Santa Ana winds, devouring homes and histories in its wake, Border Patrol agents descended upon hard-working folks on their way to work in the vast agricultural holdings of Kern Country, just north of LA.
A least 30 people were detained on Tuesday, January 7, one day after Congress certified the 2024 election — the same ceremonial transfer of power disrupted by the loser and his insurrectionist army four years before — and with two weeks still two weeks to go until the actual transfer of power.
[NOTE: On January 13, reporter Melissa Montalvo of The Fresno Bee updated the number of arrests to 78.]
No one was prepared — neither those who were targeted nor the local businesses that serve their needs and rely on their labor. It was panic and confusion, according to journalist Sergio Olmos, writing for Cal Matters.
Agents driving unmarked SUVs raided a Bakersfield gas station popular with field workers who stop in for a warm breakfast on their way to the fields. The agents preyed upon day laborers waiting for rides outside the Home Depot. They stopped cars along Highway 99, profiling people, pulling them out of their cars, and demanding to see their papers.
As the operation continued into Wednesday, multiple wildfires burned just two hour’s drive away. While flames engulfed Altadena, Border Patrol sowed a firestorm of fear amongst the population of essential workers who pick the produce that fills our grocery stores and graces our tables, foreshadowing what awaits communities all across the US — what we thought last week still awaited us — when Trump & Co 2.0 actually assume office and make good on their promise to deport folks living and working in the US en masse — which will come in a larger, more terrifying package that includes raids, mass detention, and family separation.
The Bakersfield raids were unannounced, throwing doubt on the likelihood that the mission was green-lighted by President Biden and his outgoing Homeland Security Secretary Mayorkas.
On social media, Gregory K. Bovino, the Border Patrol chief in El Centro, identified the sweeps by name: “Operation Return to Sender.” He stated similar operations are being planned for Fresno and Sacramento.
Which is why I ask the question: Have Customs and Border Protection gone rogue?
Both ICE and Customs and Border Protection have only ever endorsed a single candidate for president, and they did so three times: in 2016, 2020, and 2024. Each time, they chose Trump.
Their members-only websites are chock-full of anti-immigrant propaganda churned out by so-called “think tanks,” such as the Heritage Foundation; the Federation for American Immigration Reform, whose acronym, FAIR, suggests the opposite of what it really is: a hate group; and the Center for Immigration Studies, whose animating principle has always been that “immigrants are criminals and perverts coming for your wives and your jobs and a burden on the U.S. economy,” and whose statisticians will torture any data set to make sure that belief appears true, particularly on Fox News.
These groups have long been ground zero for stirring up moral panics through disinformation and fake news. They have been working for decades to make America white again. And according to my sources in El Paso, this is not the first time Homeland Security agencies have appeared to act under their own steam — not under the orders or even the knowledge, quite possibly, of the US president.
Indeed, my friends saw Family Separation being trailed right before their eyes, though El Paso Sector top brass would gaslight their claims and deny what was clear and plain as the noses on their faces. My collaborators in El Paso saw family separation happening all the way back in 2016, while Obama was still sitting behind the Resolute Desk.
That is the story we tell in Crossing the Line, Chapter 20: Barbarians at the Gate, which — like the story of Border Patrol’s reprehensible behavior in January 2025, while LA burned — also illustrates just how blind the United States has become to global and national priorities.
These stories are a bellwether, a harbinger of what's to come. They should make us all demand answers now as to who really controls the agencies associated with the Department of Homeland Security; and to interrogate whether or not these agencies are really making us secure.
And now, from Crossing the Line, Finding America in the Borderlands, Chapter 20, Barbarians at the Gate.
“Toward the end of the Obama administration, we saw an increasingly harsh application of US immigration laws here in the El Paso borderlands, particularly by ICE, and particularly with respect to asylum seekers,” recalls Dylan Corbett, founding executive director of the El Paso–based Hope Border Institute (HOPE). Working across borders of geography, ethnicity, and race in an area of roughly one million people spanning three Catholic dioceses and two countries, HOPE builds bridges of solidarity between communities of faith, social justice, and politics. HOPE does “good theology in a practical way,” states Bishop Mark Seitz, leader of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, head of the El Paso Catholic Diocese, and an outspoken voice for US immigration reform.
For Bishop Seitz, Dylan, and their allies, “practical” involved no small dose of “political” when a shift in ICE tactics rolled into town with a new agency boss in December 2015. His name was Corey Price. And as ICE field office director of the El Paso Sector, he brought with him a culture of legal and human rights abuses that spread like a cancer through ICE “detention centers” from West Texas through New Mexico—and one hundred miles northward.
It wasn’t until late March 2016, however, when the El Paso community really felt the sting of change. That’s when the National Border Patrol Council, the 18,000-member labor union representing agents and support staff o…