Listen

Description

Frogwares made this game in a war zone. Members of staff were drafted into the Ukrainian military, lost their homes, and experienced upheaval in their families. Without reliable access to power, development was completed remotely using mobile internet and by exchanging ideas via text or video call. And, after decades of detective-adventure titles, this also marked the developer’s first foray into survival horror as part of a strategy to reach a wider audience and prevent downsizing. I mention all of this only to drive home how deeply impressive I find The Sinking City 2: a genuinely unsettling eldritch adventure that capably deploys time-tested survival-horror conventions whilst carving out its own distinctive identity. It may run into difficulties in the third act and feature some stiff gunplay but never to a degree that diminishes the outstanding level design, exploration, and puzzles.

The Other Gods

You play as Calvin Rafferty, an occult investigator searching for a ritual to reawaken his comatose wife, Faye, amidst a disastrous flood in the fictional city of Arkham. There’s a pleasing variety to the environments throughout the adventure from flooded streets and abandoned cabarets to derelict hospitals and damp fish markets. The clear visual upgrade helps to engender a deliciously atmospheric experience, playing with light and shadow to unnerving effect and plastering walls with a convincing layer of rot and decay. Character models receive similar treatment: bloated and waterlogged corpses (piloted by the parasitic Slither) roam the halls while facial animations, particularly on protagonists Calvin and Faye, have also improved. However, the game never entirely escapes its AA trappings; an ambitious story and prolonged action set-pieces write checks that the faintly stilted performances and limited production value simply cannot cash.

The Sinking City 2 is almost entirely indebted to Resident Evil in design and structure right down to the inclusion of safe rooms and lockpicks. Levels gradually unfold in that same tradition as well, interconnected maps blossoming as more and more pathways become available alongside uniquely eldritch “keys” such as amputated faces and glowing jars. Discovering these paths forward and mastering the environment is as satisfying as its been for the last thirty years. Of course, it’s unsurprising the same philosophy that has sustained one of the most popular game franchises of the modern era works here too, but the team have crafted exploration that truly satisfied whilst seamlessly nudging me towards the more involved side investigations without constant backtracking. It’s all done with such consistency, too; only during the final stage does the game run out of steam and narrow in scope.

Calvin will often be provided a device near the beginning of an area and be required to deduce its power source or mechanical workings which forced me to pay more attention to the environment. One such instance involved figuring out how to activate and operate a lightning conductor and recharge a fuse. It’s more complicated than it sounds. If I wanted to progress, I couldn’t just pass through the world, I had to engage with it, read it, listen to it. Scanning notes and other evidence for clues was just inherently more satisfying than the typical scavenger hunt fare. And that’s without even taking into account the honest-to-goodness brain teasers that those aforementioned keys hide behind. Moving through the world became a puzzle in and of itself. It’s no surprise that prior to the development of this game, the team released a number of detective titles under the Sherlock Holmes license.

Ex Oblivione

They might have made the move towards survival horror but Frogwares’ detective bonafides remain central to The Sinking City 2’s success. Investigations form the backbone of exploration beyond the critical path. You might have to determine a safe code based on different species of fish or perhaps settle a debate between the disembodied brains of three scientists to tune a radio to the correct frequency. The activities themselves reward you with meaningful additions like weapons, attachments, and ammunition but actually engaging with the investigation screen and linking evidence into relevant groups is the most efficient way to gather upgrade resources. It’s an elegant system that motivated me to solve these cases but one that would have worked better if those upgrades, or “talents”, made more of a direct impact on combat or were themselves a reward for exploration.

Combat, though undoubtedly a huge improvement over the first game, remains mostly frustrating and stiff. It’s a valiant effort: everything from dodges and weak points to a robust ammo economy and crafting system have been included. That combat never prevented me from enjoying the rest of the game, and at points supplied some much-needed tension, is enough of a win given Frogwares’ relative inexperience here.

The Rats in the Walls

However, it’s in the final hour or so that The Sinking City 2 begins to come apart at the seams. The final chapter transports Calvin to an arctic wasteland that features none of the intricacy, intelligence, or scope that made earlier levels so appealing. It’s frankly suffocating in its linearity relative to the rest of the game, point blank refusing to test the skills I had spent over ten hours developing. Throw in a clunky pre-boss ammo dump and “Cold Comfort” makes for a poor climax.

I also found the story didn’t land in its entirety: emotionally thoughtful yet mechanically nonsensical. The tale of a long-term couple struggling to piece their lives together, and ultimately choosing to do so anyway, is a worthy one but without a clear understanding of the threat or the stakes that story loses some, not all, of its meaning. There’s a conversation to be had about the balance between the accessibility and authenticity of these dense, lore-based narratives but the fact I would have been completely lost without some post-game research probably means that balance wasn’t struck.

Verdict

It might not stick the landing but The Sinking City 2 delivers classic survival horror in spades. Intelligent level design, thoughtful puzzles, and a creepy atmosphere make Frogwares’ latest a worthwhile venture into Lovecraftian horror.

8.0

Thanks for reading The Five Hundred. Subscribe for more articles like this.



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thefivehundred.substack.com