Listen

Description

I have to admit, I have been a bit hopeless lately. I find I’ve just gone through the same experience on the Right that I did on the Left. I watched a coalition fracture, tried to warn of it, and then watched it lose an important election. The midterm blowout meant that 24 million 2024 Trump supporters stayed home, handing Texas, Maine, Michigan, South Carolina, and even Mississippi to the Democrats.

I wish I could be happy about Mississippi. As a Democrat, I used to think that our problems would be solved if only Mississippi could have a Democratic senator to lift up the underclass that has been stuck for so long. But now, I know what goes along with every Democrat win: indoctrination.

We know what decades of the Left’s indoctrination have done to the young. I watched it with my own daughter, and our conversations now are about whether there is a biological difference between men and women. But it isn’t just that. It is the oppressor/oppressed mindset. Do we think a Democrat in Mississippi will eradicate that? It won’t be. They need it because it is their entire reason for being. Oppression must continue.

The irony has always been that they are the side with all of the power, and yet they need to define themselves, always, as the oppressed side. The wheel of oppression must keep spinning, and now it has landed on Palestine.

I don’t know what will happen in 2028, but I do know where the Left is going. I know what they will be selling. The Right better have more than just “Israel bad” to sell to the people. A broader vision is needed, and I think Marco Rubio's speech delivers it.

This speech offers a ray of light in a sea of darkness because he tells a necessary truth: he calls out the ruling class, who they are, how long they’ve been in power, and what having that kind of power means. It is, in its own way, both a declaration of war against that ruling class and a definition of where we should be headed once we’re rid of its totalitarian control.

He does not need to blame the war or blame Israel or even mention it at all. He does not need a scapegoat. He can speak the truth, and somewhere in there, lies our only hope for a future outside the clutches of totalitarianism.

The ultimate question of our time is whether Americans have a moral right to exist as a distinct nation and a distinct people, and thus to demand a government that defends and pursues our interests above all else. Those who tell us that we are living on stolen land, as an example, that our nation was founded and built upon slavery and genocide and oppression, are telling us clearly that they do not believe that we do. They would have us think that American – that America – and more broadly, that the West – are uniquely burdened by guilt, guilt that we can only atone for through total surrender – by opening our borders, by renouncing our laws, by retreating from the world, and allowing them to remake our society in their image.

We should understand clearly that these – these – are the stakes of our political struggle. We should remember that this is what many in the universities, on the courts, or in the halls of government – what they really believe. As recently as 2021 we had a president telling us that hatred – hatred – was systemically embedded in our laws and our culture. Today, few, if any, of these people involved on that side of our political debate have renounced those ideas.

Their fundamental beliefs have not changed. And in the coming months, we can expect to hear a lot about their deep concern for the Constitution, the law, the principles and axioms of justice. But that concern seems to only appear when it can be wielded as an obstacle or a weapon to advance their interests.

Here is the transcript:

My kids, I used to bring them on stage and show them off, now they’re introducing – I don’t know where she got this. Has no stage fright, she’s not afraid to speak. I mean, I don’t really like public speaking that much, but she – (laughter) – she, on the other hand – that’s fantastic. That’s great. Thank you, Danielle. You did very good. She’s a third-year law student at the University of Virginia. I heard that’s a good law school. (Laughter.) I hope it is. (Applause.) I hope it is, because it’s expensive law school. It’s – (laughter) – I hope it is. No, she’s great. And of course my wife Janette is here as well.

And I was also a lawyer, but I was a different kind of lawyer. I was a land use and zoning attorney, and I always tell them as a land use and zoning attorney, if you ever wind up in court, something went horribly wrong. (Laughter.) She, on the other hand, is going to be like a real lawyer. So we’re – she’s fantastic, and it’s an honor to be with all of you here today, and thank you. And primarily I am here in this collection of lawyers – how many – are there any lawyers here? (Laughter.) Good. Thank you, because on election night there was a congressman that said we all needed to lawyer up, so here we are. (Laughter and applause.)

Anyway, anyway, so – and on a serious topic, less than two years into Ronald Reagan’s first term in office, you know that everything sort of seemed headed in the wrong direction. It’s hard for us to remember that right now, but that’s what it was like. After his first two years in office, things seemed headed in the wrong direction. He had won a stunning landslide victory. He had been hailed as a conservative – which was hailed as a conservative revolution and upended the political establishment. He’d been swept into office with this ambitious political mandate, he survived an assassination attempt, and he promptly delivered on a signature campaign promise, which was a historic tax cut, and he did all of this in the first eight months of his presidency.

But by early 1982 – which, by the way, I think I was in sixth grade – but by early 1982, celebrations had given way to a growing sense of gloom. The Reagan administration was facing its first major political crisis. In less than a year, the approval ratings of the Reagan administration had plummeted from – by 25 points, from 68 percent down to 43 percent. By March of 1982 – think about this, what I’m about to tell you, for a moment – by March of 1982, President Reagan was four points less popular than Jimmy Carter at the same point at his term. The economy had taken a nosedive. In fact, it faced a full-fledged recession. Unemployment was approaching double digits, the worst it had been in 40 years, with many, fairly or unfairly, blaming the president for all of this. Even his foreign policy ambitions were beginning to lose ground, with rising fears of nuclear war with Russia spilling out into a popular revolt against his efforts to take on the Soviet communism around the world.

On all fronts, the Reagan administration and the conservative movement at that time was on the defensive. But it was against that backdrop that I just described to you in 1982 – which, by the way, also culminated in devastating losses for the president’s parties in Congress – it was against that backdrop, amid plummeting morale, the anxiety, the despair, that something new began to stir. And it was – at that time it was little more than just an idea. It was germinating in just a few law schools – common – in the common rooms of several law schools and lecture halls. But soon what was stirring would remake the whole landscape of American politics and law, forever changing the course of the nation.

In April of 1982, in the middle of everything I just described to you, there were four law school students that organized a symposium on federalism in New Haven, Connecticut. About 200 people came. One of the speakers that came was this 46-year-old professor from Chicago. His name was Antonin Scalia, and he diagnosed a basic problem to the room. He said conservatives have simply been outgunned at the federal level for half a century. And, of course, nowhere was that more obvious at the time than in the courts. Republicans had won thre…



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.sashastone.com/subscribe