Listen

Description

For many Mainers, Dr. Nirav Shah became a familiar and reassuring presence during the COVID-19 pandemic. As director of the Maine CDC, he delivered near-daily press briefings, explaining complicated public health decisions with a sense of calm. He went on to serve as the second-highest-ranking official at the U.S. CDC before returning to Maine to run for governor.

We start our conversation with Dr. Shah, by revisiting his very first COVID press briefing and unpacking what it takes to communicate uncertainty, make difficult decisions, and build trust when everyone seems to disagree with you.

From there, we turn to his experience on the campaign trail, where he discovered that voters were far less interested in ideological labels than in whether government could actually make their lives better. We also have a spirited disagreement about what makes a good politician. And we think about whether we need sweeping rhetoric in politics or leaders who can deliver on the basics. Or can we have both?

Along the way: the surprisingly personal conversations Shah had with voters across Maine, a debate over Zohran Mamdani, and some disagreement about whether the Democratic Party needs better speeches or better results.

Politics Between Us is created by Alison Beyea and Luca DeAngelis. Produced by Carlos Cuellar. Research by Jeff Sanders.

This Substack is a personal project. Alison and Luca are both employees of Colby College, but the views and opinions expressed here are entirely our own and do not represent those of Colby College or any other institutions with which we are affiliated. This publication is not produced, sponsored, or endorsed by the College.

Keywords: Nirav Shah, Maine, COVID-19, public health, crisis, political persuasion, Maine governor, Democratic Party, Janet Mills, Zohran Mamdani, political rhetoric, political leadership, healthcare, Gen Z



Get full access to Politics Between Us at politicsbetweenus.substack.com/subscribe