Listen

Description

"In ancient shadows and twilights

Where childhood had strayed,

The world's great sorrows were born

And its heroes were made.

In the lost boyhood of Judas

Christ was betrayed. "

- George Willam Russel

The right to education is paramount. At no point can this fact be ignored.

Our constitution has provided primary education as a fundamental right by article 21A of the constitution. Article 21A states that the education of children of the age group 6 to 14 is the responsibility of the state. Article 45 of the Constitution reiterates the provision for free and compulsory education for children until they reach the age of fourteen years.

Even the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted in 1998 by the United Nations, proclaims in Article 26(1)

“Everyone has a right to education. Education shall be free, at least in the elementary and fundamental stages. Elementary education shall be compulsory. Technical and professional education shall be made generally available and higher education shall be equally accessible to all on the basis of merit."

Now, why am I saying this?

We are going through a difficult time. For the last year, we are concerned about the spread of the Covid19 virus and the falling economy due to the lockdown. Rightly so. We should be concerned about the spread of the virus and the economy's free-fall affecting all of us.

But there is a more vital issue that requires our immediate attention, least it becomes too late. Too late to rectify the wrong.

Isn’t it time that we take the education of our children more seriously? Shouldn’t the schools and educational institutions be opened, albeit cautiously?

As is in individual life, so is in our society. The way we prioritize important issues in our society, especially in difficult times, will tell us how we would like to build our society for our children.

No hiding the fact that Covid19 positive cases are increasing again after a steady decline for 12 weeks. This is the first time, in 12 weeks, the ‘R’ factor is more than 1. Now, what is this ‘R’ factor? ‘R’ factor is a mathematical representation of the growth of the pandemic. When the ‘R’ factor is less than 1, the pandemic is in decline. However, if it becomes more than 1, it means that the pandemic is spreading faster. More people are getting affected than they are being cured.

Now, in a situation like this, when the pandemic is again rearing its head high, is it advisable to open the schools and educational institutions to risk the health of our children?

Prof. Reetika Khera, Department of Humanities and Social Science, IIT Delhi, seems to think so.

Recently in an interview with Karan Thapar, she very nicely and categorically states her points. She clarifies the reasons for opening the schools, especially the primary schools, even now, when the pandemic is rearing its head high. She also highlights how it can be done - what are the steps and precautions we need to take.

And her reasons, to say the least, are compelling.

Just a fortnight back, Executive Director of UNICEF, Henrietta Fore, and UNESCO Director-General, Audrey Azoulay, in a joint statement, emphasized that the schools should be the last to close and the first to open. The statement also highlights the fact that the bars and restaurants are open while the schools are still closed.

As a matter of fact, India is only one of a few countries where the schools are closed for the longest period, 16 to 17 months, since the outbreak of the pandemic.

Two very vital issues require our immediate attention.

First, why do we need to open the schools, especially the primary schools, and second how do we go about doing that?

A pre-school or primary school-going child requires a more physical learning environment than an elder child pursuing secondary or higher secondary studies. Online and distance schooling is meaningless for a child who did not even learn her alphabets or numbers. The study materials supplied online remain ineffective for any good purpose. The damage this generation of small children is facing due to school closure for 16/17 months can perhaps, be never recovered.

If we go back to our learning days, we will remember how not practicing a learned skill can make us forget that skill fast. Try a simple arithmetic problem now that a fourth or fifth-grader does without much effort. You will be surprised that you will not be able to solve it. This is because you have lost the habit of doing similar sums regularly. The same is more true for small children, whether they learn language or sums.

Azim Premji University had done a study, in January 2021, on the possibilities of academic damage due to this prolonged closure of schools. The study states that the children might have lost 92% of their language skills and 82% of their mathematics skills due to the closure of schools. So the primary school-going children are back to where they were before they started going to school, losing precious time and learning abilities.

Also, schools are much more than just a place where only academics are taught. It is a place where the kids pick up psycho-sociological skills by interacting with their peer groups, teachers, and educators. By denying the children, the facility of interacting with their peers is by far the greatest harm we can inflict on them. A child’s education is never complete unless she learns to interact with his social environment. A growing child may not make up for this loss during her formative period.

This is more true for younger children than older children. Child development until the age of 10 has more facets than only learning to read and write. The skills the children pick up during this period of their life, while in school, can never be matched at home.

Considering Indian social conditions, children from poorer households and girl children are more to lose if they are refrained from attending school for a longer period.

This brings us to another important issue for consideration.

Most poor households do not have learning conditions at home. This is a direct contrast from most middle-class and affluent households, where children get a conducive environment for well-rounded development. Most middle-class parents know to read and write and impart some skills to their children. But for children from an underprivileged background, this is mostly absent.

Another harm the children are facing due to this prolonged closure of schools is that they are missing out on their mid-day meals. As per the supreme court order, the mid-day meals for the school-going children must continue, even during the school closure. However, the implementation of this order at the ground level is suspect. Even supplying dry ration instead of hot cooked meals is not implemented.

So, as 70% of the school-going children come from the underprivileged section of the society - both urban and rural - the harm is done to them are enormous. The harm inflicted on them are fourfold,

* Nutritional, due to lack of poor diet due to loss of regular mid-day, meals,

* Educational, due to lack of support at home, and

* Sociological, as, the children are missing out on simple skills they learn in schools, like queueing up, washing hands before taking a meal, sharing their meals with their friends, to say the least, and

* Missing out on simply having fun with their same age group.

All the facts suggest that on-line studying does not work for the poor as they might work for the rich.

Here are some facts,

* Only 4% of rural and 23% of urban households have a computer at home.

* Only 17% of rural and 42% of the urban population have internet facilities.

For most urban city dwellers like us, smartphones are common. In fact, most households have more than a few. Yet 2019 Lokniti Survey found that less than one-third of households have smartphones. Even when they have one, they have to share it with other members of the family. So the fashionable idea that smartphones will solve all the problems is not a reality.

So the idea that onli…



Get full access to Life is Addictive at barun.substack.com/subscribe