Listen

Description

Show Notes:

* College of St. Joseph the Worker

* Crabtree Group

* Jacob on the Bottom Up Revolution

Build the Next Right Thing is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Edited Transcript

Seth Zeren: Hello and welcome to The New School for City Builders. I’m your host, Seth Zeren, a recovering city planner turned neighborhood developer in Providence, Rhode Island. This is a podcast about how we transform the education of city builders. If we want to change how our cities and towns work, we need to change the people who run them. We need a new generation of city builders — architects, engineers, planners, developers, city managers, and civic leaders. We need a new school for city builders.

Joining me today is civil engineer Jacob Hyman, PE. I met Jacob at the Congress for the New Urbanism in 2024 in Cincinnati — one of those great, fortuitous lobby connections that conferences are best for. Jacob trained as a civil engineer before going to work for Paul Crabtree, one of the best civil engineers building places people love in the entire country. In our conversation today, Jacob and I explore his background, his path through civil engineering education, his connection to New Urbanism and Strong Towns, and his insights about the importance of human formation in education.

Jacob, welcome to The New School for City Builders.

Jacob Hyman: Thank you, Seth. Very glad to be here.

Seth Zeren: It was great meeting you in that hotel lobby — that’s the best part of going to conferences, those fortuitous connections. You never quite know what you’re going to find, and it’s a lot of fun.

Jacob Hyman: That’s great. I remember our hallway conversation well, and I remember you talking about education back in ‘24. I thought, I want to chat with this guy — this is critical, being able to talk about the education question. So I’m really glad you reached out a couple of weeks ago about doing this podcast. You’ve kept the spark alive and kept fanning the flame of this important discussion.

Seth Zeren: Thanks, Jacob. We’re going to keep this fire growing and get some good stuff going. So — how did you become a civil engineer? What led you down this path?

Jacob Hyman: Sure. I’ll keep my answer focused on the civil engineering side for now, though as I’ve reflected on my own education, I’ve realized how incidentally I found my way into urban planning and urbanism.

I went to college from 2014 to 2019, at Florida State University — go Seminoles — and studied engineering at the joint FAMU–FSU College of Engineering. I went into civil engineering, and into engineering generally, because I was good at math, or so my dad told me. As a 17-year-old with a STEM inclination, I didn’t know exactly what I wanted to do, but my father encouraged me toward engineering.

I started at Florida State in 2014 in the general engineering track, taking math and physics, and didn’t declare civil engineering until my sophomore year. By the end of my first semester I already knew I wanted to do civil — which, as it happens, gets you closer to the urban planning side of things. From there I did a fairly typical civil engineering curriculum: concrete and steel, hydraulics and hydrology, soils, construction management, engineering ethics.

I graduated in 2019 with my ABET-accredited degree, which requires at least four years of professional experience before you can sit for your PE license. I got that experience through a master’s degree in engineering management while I was in the Air Force, through a year and a half working for a conventional engineering firm here in the Pittsburgh area, and then through the rest of my time working with Paul Crabtree. I got my license this past December — about six months ago now. That’s the big-picture journey.

Seth Zeren: Congratulations — passing the PE exams is a big accomplishment, a lot of work. What was the best part of your civil engineering education?

Jacob Hyman: Honestly, the engineering itself is fascinating, and I think I got a very good education in the fundamentals. There’s no “urbanist civil engineering” concentration — that doesn’t exist, unless you pursue some kind of independent, self-directed study. So I’m grateful for a rock-solid grounding in the fundamentals: understanding the concepts and equations behind the engineering, doing the math by hand rather than just running software.

It wasn’t heavy on the software side — all the CAD work I now do daily was learned on the job. But the fundamentals — the stuff running quietly in the background of every Excel spreadsheet, every Civil 3D design, every automated grading calculation — that’s what I got, and that’s what I’m most grateful for.

Seth Zeren: That’s great — not just “here’s how to use the application” without understanding what’s underneath.

Jacob Hyman: Right. I actually felt pretty inadequate going into my first engineering job, because I had very little CAD experience — I didn’t have many internships in college since my summers were taken up by Air Force ROTC. So my first job was largely learning the software for the first time. But I’d think back — oh, I learned the TR-55 method, I learned the Rational Method in school — and it was rewarding to see that knowledge translate into real-world work.

Seth Zeren: Looking back, what would you change about the program, knowing what you know now?

Jacob Hyman: That’s why we’re here on this podcast, isn’t it? My civil engineering program didn’t have tracks — no architectural engineering focus, no structural focus. It was one catch-all civil engineering degree. Some of my fellow alumni now do site engineering like me, others do dam engineering, bridge and structural engineering, and so on.

Seth Zeren: That’s a really interesting point. If you’re not in civil engineering, you don’t fully appreciate the breadth of what people with a civil engineering degree end up doing — from the steel in a skyscraper, to a dam or a runway, to site grading, to transportation and traffic engineering. In a lot of other contexts these would be entirely separate degrees, but here they’re all mashed into one.

Jacob Hyman: You’re right. When I was an undergrad — seven years ago now — I was drawn to structural engineering. I liked building with Legos and Minecraft, which is actually where my urban-planning interest began, and I’d also heard that structural engineers tend to be near the top of the pay scale in civil engineering. So I took every optional structural class I could. But seven years later, I’m doing site work exclusively.

Your PE license technically allows you to practice anything you’re competent in, but I’m not going to stamp a set of structural drawings — I don’t do that kind of work regularly, and I’m not going to take on that liability. So even though there was a point where I thought I’d go into structures, that’s just not how things turned out. And I’m glad — I’m doing the New Urbanist work now, which for civil engineers is mostly site-related. Even in developments where we admire the structural or masonry work — say, missing-middle housing — when people think about the engineering behind a New Urbanist development, they’re usually thinking about the streets, the roads, and the stormwater. That’s the site work we principally think about.

Seth Zeren: Let’s dig into that. What is it that you and Paul Crabtree’s firm do differently from typical civil engineering practice?

Jacob Hyman: I joined the Crabtree team in September of ‘23 — so this September will be three years. When I first joined, I told my engineering friends doing more conventional site work, “How is this New Urbanist work different from what you’re doing?” I thought that was a great question, and I’m still figuring out the answer, though almost three years in I have a better sense of it now.

Water flows at the same rate through a 48-inch concrete pipe at a 2% slope with a Manning’s n of 0.015, whether that pipe sits under a suburban McMansion subdivision …



Get full access to Build the Next Right Thing at buildthenextrightthing.substack.com/subscribe