Listen

Description

Show notes:

* Incremental Development Alliance

* Range Co.

Build the Next Right Thing is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

The following transcript has been lightly edited for quality:

Seth: Hello and welcome to the New School for City Builders. I’m your host, Seth Zeren, a recovering city planner turned neighborhood developer in Providence, Rhode Island. This is a podcast about transforming the education of city builders. If we want to change how our cities and towns work, we need to change the people who run them. We need a new generation of city builders — architects, engineers, planners, developers, city managers, and civic leaders. We need a new school for city builders.

Joining me today is Allie Quinlan, an architect, landscape architect, and developer in Fayetteville, Arkansas. I met Allie many years ago through the Incremental Development Alliance (IncDev), where she was an early instructor and, for the last three years, has served as executive director. She’s a principal at Range, an architecture, planning, and landscape consulting firm based in Fayetteville, and a small-scale developer in her own right. Allie, welcome to the show.

Allie: Hi Seth, thanks so much for having me.

Seth: I’ve been looking forward to this for a long time. You and I have talked a lot about the importance of getting more people into development — so it’s not just run by the same old cast of characters. We need a lot more people doing this work. But before we get into that, let’s step back: to you, what does it mean to be a city builder?

Allie: We’d really classify this as the people doing the work — the doers. At IncDev, we think a lot about who our audience is, and we usually break it into three categories. First, the people who have a say over projects — the regulators and administrators: city planners, permit staff, fire marshals. Second, the ecosystem members — your banker, your appraiser, your designer, your consulting team. And third — maybe a third of the total — the actual doers, the city builders.

We need people from all three categories, but in a lot of places, people in the first two categories get really frustrated that nothing’s happening, that they’ve written all these good codes and no one’s using them. None of it works without the actual builders — the people willing to put their personal guarantee on the line, commit a couple of years of hard work, and see a project through.

Seth: Right. I see this play out on the developer side, but even in the public sector, you find people taking on that same entrepreneurial role — not waiting for someone else to solve it, but actually driving a project to completion. Navigating the bureaucracy, finding the money — it’s honestly very similar to being a developer. I think the mindsets are alike.

When I talk to people about this, there are a lot who are genuinely excited about actually doing the work — getting out there instead of just writing policy. But a lot of them, often younger people, struggle to figure out how to get in. What’s the entry point into being a city builder? So — first principles — what does a young person actually need to learn?

Allie: The first thing is that you can’t learn everything before you do anything. There’s no way to sit and prepare fully in advance. I’ll admit — Seth and I had a great chat before we remembered to hit record — and one thing we talked about is that even after years in the business, we both still feel a lot of impostor syndrome once we get into parts of real estate development outside our direct experience.

So the thing I want young people to embrace is: you just have to start somewhere. There are a hundred ways in, and a lot of them are bite-sized. You can get a job with a development office, work for a property management company — those are easy internships to land. You could work at a bank for a while on the finance side, which is actually a great way to see a huge variety of projects and learn what’s working and what isn’t.

One reality worth naming: you can get into real estate development without a lot of money. At IncDev we talk about “zero to three stories” as incremental development — and by zero stories we mean it literally. A snow cone stand. Renting a vacant lot and activating it with something low-cost. You’re learning how to get a permit, how to get water connected — all these small steps you have to go through. Pick any entry point. You just have to pick one and actually do it to learn.

Seth: That’s great advice. Going back to your own education — where did you go to school?

Allie: I did my undergraduate degree in architecture at the University of Oklahoma, then a master’s in landscape architecture at Virginia Tech, so I’m dual-licensed in both. After that I got into real estate development doing fix-and-flips — framing, tiling, renovations I learned from my mom. I got into it in a roundabout way, and for a long time I thought of it as just a hobby while I worked toward getting licensed for my “real job.” It turned out that hobby was just as useful as all the schooling.

Seth: I usually tell architecture students that one of the best internships they can do is with a construction company — not in the office, but out with a crew in the field. Because eventually your plans get built by someone who’s sweaty, the plans are upside down, covered in coffee stains — that’s who’s actually building your building. You need an intuitive feel for the people you’re working with, not just a nice air-conditioned office. You need to see what the materials are really like, what a job site is really like.

Allie: Completely agree — and it’s the same analogy we use training young architects: are your details “kind”? Have you been kind to the person who has to put this together, given the materiality you’ve chosen? We describe it as: would a hungover twenty-year-old in ninety-eight-degree heat be willing to build this the way you’ve drawn it? Because in reality, that’s who’s doing it.

Seth: Right. One thing that’s really changed about city building is the growing gap between design and construction. It used to be that if you were building a cathedral, the designer was on site. In vernacular construction generally, the person designing something was often the person building it, or a close relative — a tight connection, adaptive in real time. Now we draw a full set of plans, hand them off, say “build it,” and come back a month later to see what happened.

Allie: We get architects straight out of school who don’t know what a two-by-four is. We ask them to draw wall sections and they don’t know what the materials they’re drawing even are — it’s just lines on paper to them. Getting out on site, doing DIY projects even if the results aren’t great, gives you a real, visceral sense of what it means to carry a four-by-eight sheet of plywood up a ladder. You have to understand how buildings actually go together to build and manage them well.

Seth: [Construction noise outside] Even the jackhammer crew outside my window is proof — city building in action. The planner needs to go spend time with the DPW crew too and see how they do it.

Allie: That’s right — they’re out there getting it done.

Seth: So what advice would you give a current student — seventeen, eighteen, weighing college or grad school options — who wants to be a city builder?

Allie: It’s funny — I ended up at the state school where I could get a full ride. I started school early, stayed close to home, got in-state tuition, and took the best scholarship available. I picked a school based on those factors, not on where I “should” go. I actually got advice to go to Notre Dame — from a fellow Rhode Islander, no less — and ignored it because it was so much more expensive.

Looking back, I do sometimes wish I’d g…



Get full access to Build the Next Right Thing at buildthenextrightthing.substack.com/subscribe