Build the Next Right Thing is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
About this episode
What if the people running our cities never actually learned how government works, because no school ever taught them?
In this episode Seth Zeren talks with Daniel Golliher, founder of Maximum New York, a for-profit civics school that teaches New Yorkers how their city and state government actually works. Daniel made the case in his essay “Political Science Degrees Must End”: undergraduate government programs are à la carte baskets of unrelated classes that start with what government ought to be, while skipping the “governmental mechanics” of what it is and how its pieces fit together.
They talk about why Daniel holds his students to a 95% midterm and a 90% final, why every student memorizes “The New Colossus,” draws the five boroughs from memory, and sits in on night court and an NYPD ride-along, and why he tested his material at comedy open mics. Daniel also lays out his three-part definition of the liberal arts, explains social technology, makes the case for building a school on the market rather than inside a university or a nonprofit, and previews Maximum New York’s next phase: training better partisans in both parties, starting with his own switch to the Republican Party.
Links
Daniel’s writing
* Maximum New York, Daniel’s Substack on New York government and politics
* The Algernon Project, Daniel’s Substack on the humanities and education
* Political Science Degrees Must End, Daniel Golliher (and his follow-up on responses and feedback)
* The Decline and Fall of the Humanities?, Daniel Golliher, The Algernon Project
* What is a Sanctuary City?, Daniel Golliher
* What Are Mayoral Executive Orders?, Daniel Golliher
* Citizens Who Build, Daniel Golliher, on civic culture and social technology
* Applications are Open for Foundations of New York, Cohort 16, the class Daniel describes
* Considerations on Party Affiliation, Daniel Golliher
* Introducing: Maximum Republicans, Daniel Golliher
Books and poems
* The New Colossus, Emma Lazarus
* Gone with the Wind, Margaret Mitchell
* Preamble to the United States Constitution
People, organizations and programs
* Harvard Department of Government, where Daniel studied
* Harvard Kennedy School and Harvard Law School
* City University of New York (CUNY)
* Leslie Groves, military director of the Manhattan Project
* AARP, the model for Daniel’s proposed American Association of Young People
Build the Next Right Thing is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Transcript
Seth: Hello and welcome to the New School for City Builders. I’m your host, Seth Zeren, a recovering city planner turned neighborhood developer in Providence, Rhode Island. This is a podcast about how we can transform the education of city builders. If we want to change how our cities and towns work, we need to change the people who run them. We need a new generation of city builders: architects, engineers, planners, developers, city managers, and civic leaders. We need a new school for city builders.
Today I’m joined by Daniel Golliher. Daniel is the founder of Maximum New York, a new kind of civic school in New York City. Daniel writes on Substack at Maximum New York, where he writes spicy takes like “Political Science Degrees Must End,” deep inquiries on the decline and fall of the humanities, and nuts-and-bolts explainers on how government systems work, like what a sanctuary city is and what mayoral executive orders are. I’ve wanted to have Daniel on for a while because I love what he’s created at Maximum New York.
It’s a new kind of civic school outside of traditional academia. But I also think it highlights the very important role of knowing how government works if you want to be a city builder. It’s not enough to build good buildings and good cities and good towns. You have to be able to run them, which means administration, management, stewardship, writing laws, running agencies. You have to do all of that. Daniel, welcome to the New School for City Builders.
Daniel: Thank you for having me on. Happy to be here.
Seth: It’s very exciting. What’s the matter with poli sci degrees?
Daniel: I think the first thing you can ask is: what can students do, and what can’t they do, at the end of one? If you plucked any political science graduate from any university (they might call it something different, like a degree in government) and asked what they can do or what they know, it won’t be much in either case. If you gave them, say, a 500-question test, not multiple choice, just write the answer, on the basics of government at every level (their local government, their state government, their federal government, very basic political history, what their government is, how its foundational procedures work), I think you would have well under a one percent pass rate. And almost no one would get a mark of mastery, ninety percent or above, which shows they really know how it works. So in the first instance, you can know them by their fruits: their graduates do not know much about the government. This is pretty easy to verify if you talk to any of them.
So why is that true? Some of the reasons are bound up in the decades-long evolution of the modern university itself, which I think we’ll talk about later. But the more proximate cause is that the degrees are not built to help people understand the government. They have an à la carte structure. Practically speaking, what most students experience is a basic set of degree requirements, often not much, and very broad: take one class in international relations, one in American government, one in comparative government. The classes don’t necessarily relate to each other. They’re often at wildly different levels of complexity, and they don’t incorporate the spiral theory of knowledge, which just means encountering the same idea in an increasingly complex context, over and over, in a wider purview, so you understand it more and more. Students are really just taking a random basket of classes that don’t relate to each other, so they can’t build mastery.
Seth: You were at Harvard as an undergraduate. I’ve heard of it. It’s an okay school.
Daniel: It’s a small liberal arts college in New England.
Seth: And what do they call it there?
Daniel: It’s called a government degree.
Seth: And your experience was that you came in expecting someone to show you how the Massachusetts state government works, how the state agencies work, how the federal government works...
Daniel: How these things knit together.
Seth: How they knit together. How a bill moves through, how the politics works, how the different agencies interact, who the different officials are, what they’re in charge of, and how they’re selected. All of what you call governmental mechanics: the actual nuts and bolts of how the thing works. If you were an engineer learning how cars work, you’d have to learn what all the parts are and how they interact, maybe the history of how we got those parts and the regulations they operate under. You have to build up a body of basic knowledge about how the system works. Then you might also do some comparative work: how is Massachusetts different from Connecticut, from Texas, from California, from France? That gives you a comparative framework for understanding different ways of running governments. But your experience was that you didn’t get any of that, so you had to make it for yourself. How did you navigate that?
Daniel: Of course Harvard has a lot of courses to take. You could cross-register at the graduate schools, the law school, the Kennedy School of Government. People will often say you could have just done that. I generally have two responses. First, why don’t you just put those classes in the undergraduate degree? The undergraduate degrees are still missing this completely, so the point has been conceded. Second, those other schools still don’t have th…