Show Notes:
* Aaron’s Substack: On Housing
* Aaron’s architecture & development practice (with Jenn Truman): Rocket Shop
* Shop Class as Soulcraft, by Matt Crawford
* YIMBYtown 2026 in Raleigh NC
Build the Next Right Thing is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
The following transcript has been lightly edited for clarity:
Seth Zeren: Hello and welcome to The New School for City Builders. I’m your host, Seth Zeren, a recovering city planner turned neighborhood developer in Providence, Rhode Island. Joining me today is Aaron Lubeck, my first returning guest. Aaron is an incremental developer and designer in Durham, North Carolina. He’s taught historic rehabilitation and sustainable design, and with the Incremental Development Alliance he’s taught small builders. He also co-founded the National Town Builders Association podcast. Today we’ll be talking about his ideas for building a new school — ideas that are somewhat different from mine, which makes for an interesting opportunity to compare visions. Aaron, welcome to The New School for City Builders.
Aaron Lubeck: It’s good to be here. Feels like I was just here.
Seth: Yeah, absolutely — great to have you back. You and I have both been talking about building new schools and new educational strategies for teaching city and town builders and developers for a long time now. So let’s start with a basic question: what is a city builder?
Aaron: Great question. My design partner actually started a local pro-housing organization here in North Carolina called City Builder, which was founded on that same question. I’ll be hosting YIMBYtown in Raleigh this November.
I think a city builder is a risk-taker. There are people who are city-builder-adjacent — city-builder supporters — but the ones who obviously qualify are what I jokingly call “the bad guys”: the acronym — builder, architect, developer. But it’s also the shopkeepers, the storefront retailers. Those are all risk-takers. It’s the artists too — artists are entrepreneurs. They’re putting out art, making statements, trying to show their interpretation of the world, and people either buy into it or they don’t. That’s all entrepreneurial, small-business-like behavior.
This might be one of the things we disagree on slightly: I think risk-taking is integral to the definition. That’s not to discount the important work public servants do, but they’re not risk-bearing the way small-business people are, and I think that’s a core differentiator.
Seth: Absolutely. So if you were advising a young person who wants to become a city builder, what would you tell them to go learn? What do they need to be learning when they’re starting out?
Aaron: This isn’t a theoretical question for me — I have a 17-year-old and a 20-year-old exactly in this space, so it’s been fun watching them explore what they want to do and where. I share your core frustration: there’s really no great place to send a 17- or 20-year-old who wants to build cities.
Building a city is messy work. It requires Renaissance men and women who can see the whole picture, even though it also demands specialist skills. Schools tend to teach one facet of it while missing three or four others, which contributes to the siloization you’ve written about so well.
In my own practice — we redesign small neighborhoods and do stock plans for small builders — I had to teach myself to draw. I’m not great at it, but I can communicate ideas and solve problems with it, and that seems like a core skill I want both my kids to have. I was well into my thirties before I was comfortable doing it at all, but there’s no reason a 20-year-old can’t draw a basic site plan. It’s teachable — not even that difficult.
There’s a whole set of tactical skills like that. I think our generation was the first or second generation of American men who didn’t have technical skills and didn’t need them to get by. That pendulum is swinging back — for self-worth, for job opportunities, and honestly for happiness. People want to build things, want to do physical work again, whether as a hobby or for work. I hope universities start teaching that. The more elite the university, the less likely you are to get dirt under your fingernails — and there are a lot of kids craving that now.
Seth: A long time ago I was a high school science teacher at a boarding school right out of college. One thing that stuck with me: we had a shop teacher — husband of one of the English teachers — who ran five sections of wood shop, and the kids were thrilled to be using real tools and making things. It really highlighted the disconnect between how theoretical our learning usually is — we just talk about ideas — and the fact that when you go to work, a lot of that theory isn’t very useful, or you simply haven’t learned other things: hard skills, or soft skills about working with people.
You mentioned drawing. I sometimes describe it this way: you use words to understand ideas and people, you use numbers to understand the physical nature of the world, but if you want to understand space, you need to draw. Words, numbers, and pictures are the three systems we use to understand the world — and if you can’t manipulate shapes on paper, you don’t really understand space. You can’t think about it.
Aaron: That’s totally right — and if you can’t, you’re stuck. We see a lot of frustration around this, especially in bike planning, because so many of the advocates come from policy backgrounds. They don’t know how to draw a street section. So you’ll see a lot of sincere, dedicated activity — but then it hits the point where funding and commitment exist, and the plan has to be handed off to a traditional street engineer, and the whole thing falls apart. I’d argue that’s because the advocate couldn’t draw it out and carry it further themselves. Without those skills, you’re reliant on people who don’t care about your issue as much as you do, or who are fundamentally opposed to it — usually because of some dogmatic, siloed rule that conflicts with your vision.
So people get handcuffed, professionally impotent, because they can’t draw. I see it every day in incremental development — there’s no way to do urban development without drawing. I think every developer should draw. Not every developer I know does. But the ability to look at a lot and sketch out whether something could work — a napkin sketch — every developer should be able to do that.
Seth: It’s a huge part of my own practice. Our architects actually make fun of me because I do a lot of it in PowerPoint — at the end of the day I just need to know how big the rectangle is, and then I can draw other rectangles.
Aaron: Right — it’s rectangles all the way down. I teach a site-plan class for Duke students, many of them upper-level civil engineering majors, and it always amazes me: in two hours I can teach them to draw a single-family home on a 50-by-150 lot. If there’s time, they’ll add a garage, an ADU, and some parking. Mostly it’s hand drawing, tracing paper, coloring, scales — tools like a scale rule they’ve never touched before. But site planning is teachable in an hour and a half. It’s really not that hard. It’s a bunch of rectangles.
Seth: Right — just rectangles and measuring. I came up doing trace, and it was always funny showing up to a meeting with the architect holding my own trace — they’d get a little worried. But it’s given me a lot of power, because I can show what I want instead of describing it loosely — “the bathroom needs to be like this.” It also lets me do a lot of early conceptual design without paying anyone.
Aaron: Exactly right. And the more incremental you are, the less you can afford to walk into an architect’s office and spend one, two, five thousand dollars just to learn that you can’t do what you wanted to do. You need to be able to filter out nine of every ten projects yourself before you go to another profe…