So what did Margaret know?
Let me ask you this - how many companies have you worked in where there is an expensive Enterprise Resource Planning system or a Customer Relationship Management System, and there was often one person who knew how to assemble the ‘right’ information for the management meetings?
I have consulted for organizations that bought Salesforce, Oracle, and SAP, and then built an invisible second infrastructure out of Excel files, email chains, and one person who could pull it all together by Tuesday morning.
That person was sometimes a manager, sometimes an admin, sometimes whoever happened to be organized and patient enough to do the work nobody assigned. I will call her Margaret, because every company I have ever worked in had someone like that.
Margaret pulled data from four systems that did not talk to each other, reconciled the numbers, and built a summary on the schedule that reflected how decisions were actually made. The VPs who received her Monday email had no idea how the file worked. They just knew that when Margaret was on vacation, the week felt wrong.
Nobody called this anything. It was just how the week got done. But it had the shape of a quiet trade. Margaret’s salary on one side, the value of what she held in her head on the other, and a company sitting comfortably in the gap between them.
These gaps are everywhere
A law firm billing 10 hours for 2 hours of thinking and 8 hours of research is running a business built on the historical cost of finding the right precedent. A consulting team spending six weeks on a deliverable the client could assemble in a day is running on a gap in information distribution. The three-person agency charging $4,000 a month for social media management, the client does not know now comes from a freelancer with AI tools at a fifth of the price, running on a gap in access. These gaps are not bugs. They are what most of the economy is built on, from seven-figure ERP contracts to a dentist’s office on a Tuesday morning.
The question is: what happens when those gaps start closing faster than anyone can adjust to?
What I watched happen before
I have watched this before, in slower motion.
In 1979, VisiCalc shipped on the Apple II, and within five years, the spreadsheet had rewritten how accounting work actually happened. The gap it closed was arithmetic: the manual adding, reconciling, and cross-checking that had been a trained clerical skill for generations. The profession did not vanish. It got pushed upmarket. Routine ledger work shrank. Analytical work, the interpretation of what the numbers meant, expanded to fill the room that automation opened up.
The people who survived were not the ones who added fastest. They were the ones who understood what the numbers meant: the ones who knew which line item to question, which variance signaled a real problem and which was a rounding artifact, which summary the VP actually needed, and which one just looked complete. The tool replaced the arithmetic. It could not replace the judgment that made the arithmetic useful. The survivors crossed over. The people whose whole value was in arithmetic did not.
Here is the irony the piece has been building toward: the spreadsheet that Margaret uses is itself the product of an earlier gap closure.
The tool that holds her shadow infrastructure together is the scar tissue from the last time this happened, and the Margarets who survived that wave were the ones who learned to treat the new tool as a platform for judgment rather than a replacement for skill.
The travel agency business tells a similar story on a later clock. The profession ran almost entirely on information advantage: agents knew fares, routing options, and seat availability that customers simply could not access on their own. That gap sustained an entire industry. When Expedia, Orbitz, and direct airline booking made the database available to anyone with a browser, the commodity end of the business collapsed. Book-a-flight-to-Denver work went away. What survived was the high end: complex international itineraries, corporate travel management, luxury bookings where the client was not buying information but buying judgment, a relationship, and someone to call when the flight was canceled.
The gap closed. It did not close flat. It relocated upmarket, into the hands of firms large enough to absorb the freed-up capacity, and only the people who moved with it or were already inside those firms found a place to stand.
Both transitions played out over roughly a decade. The people caught in the middle of each one, too experienced in the old model to retrain cheaply, too young to retire, had a rough several years. Some crossed over. Most did not.
Here is what is different now: that decade is compressing to something between weeks and a couple of years, depending on which gap you are standing in.
The speed of closure
AI is automation on the next level. The old automation added columns of numbers and guessed which movie you might want next. The new automation makes the small judgment calls you used to make without thinking: which invoice has an error, which email can wait, which part of your Tuesday you forgot was even work. It reaches out and finishes something so repetitive you stopped noticing you were doing it.
The real traction is not in the enterprise transformations everyone writes about. It is showing up in a family-owned HVAC shop where the dispatcher used to spend Friday afternoons reconciling next week’s schedule against technician availability and customer callbacks, and now leaves at four instead of six thirty. It is showing up in a three-person real estate law office, where the paralegal used to type client intake forms from voicemails on Monday morning, and now opens her laptop to find forms already drafted.
These are not transformations. They are small gap closures, and a dozen of them add up to someone’s evening back. Once you start seeing these closures, you see them everywhere.
At the other end of the scale is Polymarket. It is a prediction market, a site where people put money on what they think will happen. In late 2025, one developer reportedly built a bot with Claude in about forty minutes, deployed it on Polymarket, and turned $313 into nearly half a million dollars in a month. The bot was not “smarter” in any mystical sense. It did not foresee the future. It moved faster than human traders to close tiny pricing gaps.
That example sounds like a triumph of democratized access. It is not. On the same platform, 92.4% of wallets lost money. That is not an unfortunate side effect. It is a reminder that these systems are built so that most participants do not win. The developer’s bot did not abolish the house edge. It found a way to operate inside it more efficiently than ordinary humans could. His AI system could spot small pricing errors and place bets faster than human traders could, and that speed was the source of its advantage.
That is the broader pattern. Access to AI tools is becoming nearly universal. The ability to turn that access into a consistent advantage is not. The gap that matters is no longer between people who have the tools and people who do not. It is between people who can convert automation into leverage and people who merely stand inside systems already optimized against them.
This decade’s real divide may not be access, but extraction.
The spreadsheet gap, and what lies beneath it
Come back to Margaret, because what she represents is bigger than the spreadsheet itself.
Every mid-size company I have worked in runs a shadow infrastructure. Every time mention this in private or in a presentation, I hear a nervous laugh. We call that a shadow’s laugh; people know this, but often don’t talk about it.
The official systems, the ones on the IT budget, capture transactions and generate reports. The shadow infrastructure, built in Excel and held together by institutional memory, captures everything the official systems miss: the context, the exc…