In 1768, the town of Newmarket, New Hampshire, elected a twenty-two year old man as town constable. It was a modest office in a small community. It was also a historic one. Wentworth Cheswell was the first person of African descent to win elected office in American history — the beginning of a civic career that would span five decades, include service as a soldier at Saratoga, and culminate in his appointment as the first African American judge in United States history. His story went largely untold for too long. In its absence, a myth arrived — more dramatic than the truth, and considerably less true.