Listen

Description

We were going through the procedures for dealing with student records and things like that. And just immediately as if it was a totally normal thing to say, my supervisor said you might want to do a pronoun check in if you're ever concerned. And then the example she gave is: For example, if you have a girl who comes in with a short haircut, you might want to ask her, “Hey, are your pronouns still she/her?” And I'm just sitting there like. What on earth ? How do you not see that as the most sexist, regressive, conservative thing you could ever say? But a lot of these people who think of themselves as very progressive and very against gender stereotypes don't have an issue with it. And I must admit, I'm a little baffled by that. I don't know how that would not strike you as obviously bad that the category of girl is now reserved almost entirely for children who practice femininity.

Hello listeners, and welcome to Broadview. I’m Lisa Selin Davis and my guest today is a teacher in a public school in a blue state with a front row seat to how gender issues are playing out, and a unique insight based on his own experiences, including once identifying as transgender himself. I’d asked him to speak with me because I’d heard him say something recently that astounded me. He noted that there is more allowable wiggle room for feminine boys today, perhaps in reaction to cultural discussions of toxic masculinity, but that any girl expressing a hint of traditional masculinity will think of herself as nonbinary or trans. We talked about what it’s really like for teachers, who are asked to embody the role of counselor, spiritual leader and friend in a world where schools are performing many functions besides education, and how parents who don’t share the belief systems taught in schools should navigate this difficult time. For reasons you can likely guess—fear of losing his job and/or his connection with students—he’s remaining anonymous. Here’s my interview with a blue state teacher.

Lisa: So welcome to my anonymous guest. We're going to talk today about what it's like to be a teacher during this time when there so much contentiousness around sex and gender issues. So can you just talk to me first about how long you've been teaching, and when you started to notice a change in terms of either how sex and gender were talked about and represented in the curricula and or when the students started changing.

Teacher: Yeah. So thanks so much for having me here. So I have not been in public schools for very long. I've been teaching in public school since 2020. So I'm just starting my second kind of full year of teaching in public schools. But before that I was teaching in some private schools, and then before that I was working as a tutor through a local college, a community college, and then before that I had my own small tutoring business. So I've been in education now for quite some time. Gosh, coming up on eight or nine years. But, only in a public school for the last couple of years. So I would say that I really actually came into the public schools kind of maybe at the height or right after the height of I think a lot of the whole movement was really peaking. Right. So I think that in terms of I don't know if I have the greatest kind of control group of saying hey, it used to be this way. All I can compare it to is my own times in high school 15 years ago or gosh, that's wrong like eight years ago, I guess now. Gosh. But so I would say that I actually kind of my whole career of going through training and doing student teaching and then working in all these different places has kind of I really felt like I went through that process as the emphasis on gender and sex was really growing in these areas. So it's not so much that I saw a big shift where things used to be one way and then there were another more. It felt like I was kind of being carried along by that wave. I came in sort of as I think it was really starting to become bigger, and then I kind of watched it grow. But I think even by the time I first got into the industry, I think it was already an issue that people cared about, not as big as it is now, but I think it was kind of just just reaching its kind of first peak of of importance and emphasis and kind of political touchiness. So and then it feels like it's only gotten maybe maybe a little wilder there, even from there.

Teacher: But in terms of my students, that is something where I think I have seen, if I look over the last four or so years, I do think I've seen every year that's become a bigger and bigger thing among students. I don't have any hard facts or figures about kind of the exact number in each year. But I would say that just in terms of generally overhearing it in conversation, hearing students who are seeing students who are really passionate about it, and then, of course, seeing students who identify as trans themselves. I've definitely seen an increase of that since, say like 2019, 20 or so over the last couple of years. But and of course, it's wildly different from how it was when I was first going through high school myself.

Lisa: What was it like when you were in high school and what was that experience like for you?

Teacher: [00:03:38] Yeah, so it was a weird situation because I came of age kind of at what you might call like the height of the first kind of big gay, not the first, of course, but the in that 2007, eight, nine, ten maybe where I think it was kind of the first wave where gay rights activism was becoming a really big thing among the more just like general not super political, not super activist people, but just general liberals or whatever. Right. So I kind of came of age in my high school years where that was really important to me. It was kind of the being into gay rights and supporting gay marriage and things like that was kind of a big thing for the more like liberal students my age. Right., having come out of the previous big thing, which was like the war in Iraq and hating George Bush and all that stuff. But as that kind of became less and less of a of a big social thing, I think a lot of us young kind of more politically aware, kind of lefty or whatever students of which there weren't as many of course, back then, but there still were plenty. And I think we kind of moved into a lot of us did a lot of gay rights stuff and gay rights activism and things like that. And so when I was young at that age I started I actually was something of an early adopter of a lot of the gender stuff., it's interesting that I hadn't really thought about this period in my life a lot. So when I heard set up this interview or whatever, I actually took a little bit of time to go back to some old like email email accounts I had from back then. Or I found an old account ad on like a video game website and just as like, what was I really talking about? What was I thinking? And so it really struck me how back then stuff was not quite as it definitely wasn't as accessible and it wasn't as normalized. So nowadays I have a lot of students who even if they're not even super deep into this stuff, they would know what nonbinary versus transgender versus genderqueer versus X, Y and Z would be. That's those terms have kind of entered the mainstream. But when I was that age we're talking 2007, eight, nine, maybe it was obviously out there, but it was less common knowledge among even like my more liberal friends. And I stumbled upon it mainly through online stuff. Just see, I was really into a lot of lefty causes. I was into a lot of kind of more radical politics at that age, like a lot of like 17 year olds or whatever. And so I I kind of got into that around that time, and then I just was really interested in it, . [00:06:24][165.6]

Teacher: [00:06:24] So I was saying, like I said, I looked through some of those old accounts and I saw that I at times I was identifying as transgender, at times I was identifying as non non-binary…



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.broadview.news/subscribe