Episode: Performance Was Never the Question
Itzel Moncada (Colibrí Strategies and Colibrí Institute) joins to dig into emerging-manager performance, the LP view of risk, the data gaps in private markets, open benchmarks, cross-border fund strategies, and what venture ecosystems outside the US should, and shouldn't copy.
Guest bio
Itzel Moncada is the Co-Founder and Managing Partner of Colibrí Strategies, a venture capital advisory firm focused on providing institutional allocators and venture managers with research-driven guidance on risk, structure, and governance. With a background in capital markets and a passion for supporting emerging managers, Itzel's work bridges capital, culture, and community to create enduring pathways of opportunity.
Timestamps
· 00:00 — Welcome and introduction to Itzel Moncada
· 00:34 — The question about capital allocation that led Itzel into research
· 02:07 — 2024: co-investors running out of money at the same time, and founders taking the hit
· 03:25 — Testing assumptions: Colibrí Institute's first white paper on emerging-manager performance
· 05:19 — LP feedback: risk, career risk, and "performance was never the question"
· 06:22 — White paper two: emerging managers and risk efficiency
· 07:01 — Why venture data is so hard to get
· 09:08 — Open access: why Colibrí made its data public
· 09:30 — Defining "emerging": Funds I–III, maturity, and GP demographics
· 11:06 — Constraints, scrappiness, and track record
· 12:50 — How LPs source and screen emerging managers
· 15:51 — Portfolio construction and the myth of "safe" large funds
· 17:16 — Building a firm, not a fund (Kauffman Fellows' Zero to Four)
· 19:26 — What emerging managers should copy from established firms
· 20:34 — Is there an information curtain? Benchmarks that skew towards large funds
· 22:05 — How a $25M fund should compare itself to peers
· 23:13 — The 2026 paradoxes: concentration, new funds, smaller checks
· 24:26 — Cross-border: what US research should and shouldn't carry over
· 28:16 — Local strengths: Mexico, Argentina, and building on existing talent
· 31:07 — Why international GPs get screened out: legal structure and fund size
· 32:28 — Dormancy, longer fundraising cycles, and the anchor problem
· 35:11 — AI, fund infrastructure, and why there's hope
· 36:38 — Tacos, tapas, and the Emerging Forward food map
· 37:34 — Wrap-up
Links mentioned
· Colibrí Institute Benchmark — https://www.colibri.institute/benchmark
· Colibrí Institute Database — https://www.colibri.institute/database
· Kauffman Fellows, Zero to Four — https://www.kauffmanfellows.org/zero-to-four
· Itzel Moncada on LinkedIn — https://www.linkedin.com/in/itzelmoncada
· Itzel's Substack newsletter — https://itzelmoncadavc.substack.com/
· Itzel's Substack note — https://substack.com/@itzelmoncadavc/note/c-333714479
· Emerging Forward on Spotify — https://open.spotify.com/show/6d7XPiIx4mekiPrgT03w5v
· Emerging Forward on Apple Podcasts — https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/emerging-forward-podcast/id1893666713
· Emerging Forward Substack — https://emergingforward.substack.com