What happens when the pastor is the one who needs grace?
We talk a lot in the church about forgiveness. We preach grace. We proclaim second chances. We tell stories of redemption and resurrection. But what happens when someone really messes up? And what happens when that someone is the pastor?
On this episode of From the Heart of the City, I’m joined by the Rev. Lillian Daniel for a remarkably candid conversation about her new book, Defrocked: Good News from a Bad Pastor for a Better Church.
Lillian doesn’t tell a story in which she was simply misunderstood or falsely accused. She writes openly about crossing a pastoral boundary, the consequences that followed, being removed from ministry, and finding herself on the other side of the church’s disciplinary process.
But Defrocked is about much more than what happened. It’s about what comes next. What does genuine accountability look like without becoming dehumanizing? Can we take seriously the harm people cause while still believing they are more than the worst thing they’ve ever done? What does repentance actually require? Is restoration possible? What does genuine accountability look like? Most importantly: Do we actually believe the things we say about grace when grace becomes difficult?
One of the images that runs through Lillian’s book is the ditch in Jesus’ parable of the Good Samaritan. Sometimes we’re in the ditch because someone pushed us there. Sometimes life put us there. And sometimes we’re there because we jumped in with our own two feet. The question is whether anyone will stop to help.
Our conversation moves from Lillian’s own experience of failure and accountability to larger questions about clergy discipline, institutional processes, forgiveness, restoration, vocation, and the kind of church we might become if we stopped pretending that some people are beyond grace. There is something deeply hopeful in that.
Ultimately Defrocked isn’t simply a book about a ‘bad pastor.’ It’s a book about whether we can become a better church.
🎙️ From the Heart of the CityFaith. Justice. Community. Radical Hospitality.