“Democrats suck at messaging.”
You hear it over and over. And plenty of smart people have written plenty of smart pieces about how Democrats could lean into the memes more, fight dirtier, and find the next John Fetterman before the next John Fetterman finds himself (because yikes).
The national party often seems terrified of upsetting anyone already sitting at the table, which makes it pretty hard to invite new neighbors in. And that’s all fair - to a degree.
But “Democrats are bad at messaging” is starting to sound tired and lazy. It’s the explanation everyone reaches for because it’s comfortable and easy. It doesn’t require you to ask whether the thing being communicated was ever going to work in the first place. It just requires a better writer, a sharper meme, a younger candidate, and surely, definitely…maybe…this time it’ll land.
But then you look at the whole BRAT girl summer, Harris campaign meme (theme?) and you’ve got to realize that’s not it. Brat girl summer was the fun, viral pop vibes everyone was asking for, but a message built for gay men on Fire Island in Brat-themed crop tops isn’t going to work for the entire country.
The thing Democrats are trying to say is not the same thing everywhere, on purpose, and that’s not automatically a flaw. It’s what it means to be a part of a coalition. And that’s really what it means to be a ‘big tent party’.
Like with every coalition, there’s a baseline that holds the party together. For Democrats it’s the simple belief that you don’t get to tell another person who they can love. You don’t get to tell a woman what she does with her own body. You don’t get to decide who counts as a full person and who doesn’t. That’s it. That’s the floor. If you can’t agree to those basic principles, you’re not a democrat.
But what that floor is defending against changes by zip code, and that’s why one message everywhere, doesn’t resonate.
In Brooklyn, the threat reads as corporate landlords, immigration raids, an economy rigged for people who already have everything.
In Utah or Idaho or Colorado, the same underlying value: leave people alone tolive their own lives, shows up in defending a woman’s medical decision from her own legislature, or a kid’s right to exist without his state weighing in on who he is.
It’s the same floor, but a completely different opponent. A party that insists on saying it the same way in both places isn’t being principled. It’s being illegible in at least one of them, possibly both, and that’s exactly why you heard people asking what Democrats even stand for in 2024. When you try to be everything for everyone all at once - you are beige. Or greige. Both of which serve no one.
That brings us to today, where the national conversation right now is all about the media’s favorite alliterative criticism, that Dems are in disarray once again, as progressives battle it out with moderates.
Take a look at what happened this month. In deep blue New York, three DSA-backed candidates swept their House primaries this June. Brad Lander crushed a sitting congressman, about 66 to 34. Claire Valdez took an open seat outright. Darializa Avila Chevalier squeezed out the sitting chair of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus by less than four points. MS NOW called the night a political earthquake, echoing what Politico called a sledgehammer to the Democratic establishment.
Look at Utah, the same week, in the one Democratic-leaning district the state’s ever had, Ben McAdams won his primary outright, a clean majority over three progressive challengers combined, running as someone who “insisted that he’s only moderate in tone,” not moderate in substance.
Completely different room, completely different volume, completely different result, same values. They’re all running to codify Roe. They’re all running against how ICE is being used right now, even if they don’t all agree on what should replace it. And hand a gun owner like McAdams and a democratic socialist like Valdez the same bill requiring background checks on every sale? They’ll both sign it.
What all of this is doing is taking a result that makes total sense in its own room and asking it to mean something in every other room of the house. The national conversation loves to tell you that a big tent means everyone has to sing the exact same song at the exact same volume. We encourage you to think of a big tent party like a chaotic family reunion. The cousins from New York are going to bring a completely different vibe than the aunts from Sandy, and that is exactly how it’s supposed to be.
The real lesson here, because the mainstream media has it all wrong, is that New York didn’t repudiate Utah and Utah didn’t repudiate New York. Lander and McAdams aren’t on opposite ends of one fight. They’re two coalitions inside the same big tent, each one doing exactly what a big tent is supposed to do.
Thanks for pulling up a stool. Want to grab a glass and join the conversation? Here’s how:
* Love it: Hit that heart button to show you like this post.
* Join the Conversation: We’d love to hear your thoughts on today’s piece.
* Restack: Share this out to your personal feed to help us expand our reach.
* Share the warmth: If this resonated, feel free to forward it to a friend.