Listen

Description

Three Men walk into a bar…

Or in this case, a debate on religious morality.

Utah’s Governor, the U.S. Defense Secretary, and the Pope, all stepped up to a microphone in the past week, and told the rest of us what counts as faithful, what counts as Christian, and what counts as moral.

And while they weren’t talking to each other exactly, when you put their statements on the counter side by side, it leaves you wondering who gets to define fidelity, and morality, and what does it all mean anyway?

A ‘Moral and Religious People’

That’s what John Adams once wrote about the Constitution of the United States. Saying it was crafted for “a moral and religious people.“ And it’s that quote that Governor Spencer Cox invoked to declare June “Fidelity Month”, which Cox defines as “dedication to faith, family and country.”

Cox has been workshopping this declaration for about five years now. He made history in 2021 as the first Utah Governor to declare a pride month in Utah. By 2023 we got a Pride Month that managed to completely omit any mention of LGBTQ people, which then morphed into a vague month of “bridge building” in 2024. After total silence last year, we have officially arrived at Fidelity Month for 2026.

So what’s the deal with ‘Fidelity’ month? Well, it’s not based on scripture, or the state constitution. Instead it leans on survey data from a 2023 WSJ poll, showing that a majority of Americans “no longer esteem values like faith, family, patriotism, or community involvement”, and uses that as the reason that Utah must recommit to them. (Though that poll’s dramatic findings have since been questioned. When Gallup kept its survey methods consistent, it didn’t find the same collapse.)

If your commitment to a value depends on where the numbers landed this quarter, that isn’t conviction is it? It’s more like market research. The whole point of a value is that it holds when the polling doesn’t! The irony writes itself. Even the audiophiles wouldn’t file that under high fidelity. (Bonus points if you get the John Cusack reference.)

Who Counts? John Adams didn’t say, but Pete Hegseth has IDEAS

Defense Secretary Secretary of War, Pete Hegseth, who routinely hosts prayer services at the Pentagon, rails against the “Godless left” in the name of Western Christian values, and talks about America as a Christian nation in its DNA. Last week decided to reclassify Latter-day Saints as a non-Christian sect in the military’s religion system.

Sen. Mike Lee called it “repugnant” and phoned Trump directly. Oh, to be a fly on the wall for that conversation. Hegseth then reversed this decision within days. Way to offend one of your major voting blocks, guys…

It’s tempting to leave that as the punchline, but that would ignore what is a pretty large piece of state history. And it matters especially here in Utah.

Latter-day Saints know exactly what it feels like to have someone else’s majority decide they don’t qualify. It’s baked into their founding story. They were people driven out of Missouri and Illinois by their neighbors, and a faith whose Christianity other Christians have been disputing ever since. The Pentagon’s dropdown menu is just the bureaucratic version of a very old argument.

You’d think a warning against letting the majority decide “who counts” would land harder here than almost anywhere else.

The Whims of the Majority

The third man to enter the conversation this week was Pope Leo XIV. You know, the actual head of the world’s largest Christian institution. He was in Madrid this week, telling Spain’s parliament that a just society is built on “the inviolable dignity of the human person” and that you don’t get to hand that dignity over to “the whims of the majority.”

Which is pretty funny considering Cox and Hegseth are the people waving faith and family around this June, and doing the exact thing the Pope warned against. Cox picked June’s values off a poll. The Pentagon decided who counted as Christian, then un-decided three days later when Trump got an angry phone call. That’s not conviction standing firm against the crowd. Nor fidelity to any values. That’s just plain old pivoting to throw red meat to the base when they boo you off the primary stage.

Now, Pope Leo hasn’t changed any doctrine around LGBTQIA+ folks. Asked this spring about blessing same-sex couples, he said the church’s unity “should not revolve around sexual matters,” and that justice and equality matter more. So he’s not exactly a beacon of Pride, but he also hasn’t spent his June erasing anybody’s hard fought rights in an effort to be more liked by people who don’t actually like him.

Fidelity is Pride, Pride is Fidelity

If fidelity is truly defined as faithfulness and loyalty, then Pride month is its purest expression. Pride is a fierce loyalty to our collective humanity - however that humanity looks.

And, to downtown Salt Lake this last weekend, it looks like a man holding a “Free Dad Hugs” sign. It looks like a teenager seeing, maybe for the first time, a crowd of strangers cheering for their exact self. It looks like the kind of joy that doesn’t perform, it just spills out, contagious, onto the street, past the barriers and the counter-protesters and straight into something that feels like belonging.

While the governor, the secretary, and the Pope spend June pontificating from behind their microphones, a whole community of faithful humans showed up on the pavement this weekend to actually live them. That is acceptance in its purest form, and you do not need a dropdown menu or a quarterly survey to recognize it.

Thanks for pulling up a stool. Want to grab a glass and join the conversation? Here’s how:

* Love it: Hit that heart button to show you like this post.

* Join the Conversation: We’d love to hear your thoughts on today’s piece.

* Restack: Share this out to your personal feed to help us expand our reach.

* Share the warmth: If this resonated, feel free to forward it to a friend.



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit aroundthecounter.substack.com