Listen

Description

Before you go any further in reading this, we want to be VERY clear about something. Utah is not a blue state. It is not going to be a blue state in 2026, 2028, or likely even 2030.

But shifts ARE happening here that are important, and the national media is almost catching on.

They noticed Utah didn’t swing hard for Trump in 2024, that LDS voters had the largest leftward shift of any religious group, and they’re noticing the Prop 4 battle (but, unfortunately, still lumping us in with California and Texas and painting it as a partisan play when it’s really not).

What they keep missing is the why. And the answer is, it’s because of Utah women.

We’ve been watching the data, and BYU professor Jake Rugh has confirmed what we’re all seeing at our neighborhood playgroups: Utah men are THREE TIMES MORE LIKELY to stick with the MAGA brand than the women who recoiled from Trump in 2016 and are never, ever getting back together with MAGA. And the numbers against Trump in Utah are only growing.

So the data shows you the pattern, but it doesn’t fully explain what’s happening behind the scenes. Mercifully, you don’t have to be LDS to understand what’s happening here. Whatever values Utah women hold, whatever their faith or background, the MAGA brand of politics is not one we are shopping for.

Let’s add a little historical context, because Utah has always had a complicated relationship with women’s power. We were the first state to recognize it and we’ve been coasting on that 1870 headline ever since as proof we’re pro-women.

WalletHub has had something different to say about that for the past 8 years, placing Utah in 50th position for Women’s Rights again in 2026.

The reality is, Utah has always had this unresolved tension between the myth of women’s power here and the reality of it. So that makes what’s happening right now so ‘remarkable’, to quote Professor Rugh, is that women on both sides of the aisle are deciding the gap between the myth and the reality doesn’t fly anymore.

Polling from 2025 puts Trump’s net approval among Utah women at 14 points underwater. This gender gap has shown up consistently across every cycle since 2016, and it’s only growing.

The Salt Lake Tribune reported that a February 2026 poll found that 58% of Utah LDS voters say they’d vote for Trump today. That’s already 10 points lower than those who actually colored in the bubble for him in 2024. That’s a lot of quietly conflicted voters. Think about your ward or your neighborhood. If 10% of the people who were Team Trump in 2024 are now saying ‘I’m out,’ that’s not just a statistic. That’s the sister who usually handles the funeral potatoes deciding she’s done being told to follow the rules by men who keep breaking them.

If the data shows us that Utah women are looking for a different kind of leadership, the current primary showdown between Congressman Blake Moore and state Rep. Karianne Lisonbee is where that rubber finally hits the road. We’re seeing a bit of a Republican neighborhood feud following the Prop 4 victory. Lisonbee is trying to blame Moore for the courts stepping in, but that’s like blaming your neighbor for the HOA fine you got after you ignored the rules for eight years. The courts didn’t step in because of Moore; they stepped in because the Legislature thought they could override Utah voters and get away with it.

Moore says he still believes in an independent advisory commission and that the legislature has constitutional authority over maps. He’s been consistent to the point of stubbornness, which in any other era of Republican politics might even be considered a virtue.

There’s a certain irony in how this fight has played out. The legislature made it incredibly difficult to get an initiative on the ballot through the signature process. And then remarkably easy to remove signatures from one.

They designed those rules when they assumed they’d always be on offense. It never occurred to them they’d need those rules to cut the other way.

And here’s the part Lisonbee really can’t say out loud: the constituents she’s trying to appeal to in this primary, conservative women in Utah, are the same women showing up in the data, cycle after cycle, moving away from exactly what she represents.

She’s not just running against Blake Moore. She’s running against the 10% of LDS voters who are quietly checking a different box because they’re tired of the drama. Utah women didn’t change their values. The Republican Party changed what it was asking them to accept.

We’re still the same women who show up with the casseroles and organize the PTA, and it turns out, Utah women have a pretty long memory, a low tolerance for being underestimated, and, as the legislature just found out the hard way, a sophisticated understanding of how the rules work.

The national media might be looking for a ‘blue wave,’ but they’re looking for the wrong color. What’s happening here is more like a family meeting where the women have finally decided to stop sitting at the kids’ table. We know exactly how the rules work. And we aren’t going anywhere.

Thanks for pulling up a stool. Want to grab a glass and join the conversation? Here’s how:

* Love it: Hit that heart button to show you like this post.

* Join the Conversation: We’d love to hear your thoughts on today’s piece.

* Restack: Share this out to your personal feed to help us expand our reach.

* Share the warmth: If this resonated, feel free to forward it to a friend.



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit aroundthecounter.substack.com