Why do some alumni give for a lifetime while others never do? It isn’t pride, loyalty, or how many emails they open. It’s identity.
In this Faculty-in-Residence Symposium, Ryan Catherwood hosts a live roundtable with Dr. Jay Dillon — Chief Alumni Officer & Strategist at UC Berkeley and creator of the Alumni Identity™ framework — joined by guest hosts Simone Jackson (USC Alumni Association) and Eryn Giegel (Roanoke College). Together they put a decade of Jay’s research to the test: what alumni identity actually is, how to measure it, and what it means for how advancement teams spend their limited time and resources.
As Jay puts it: “Pride is about the school. Loyalty is about the relationship. Identity is about the self — and it’s the self that predicts what people do.”
In this episode:
Why “alumni don’t engage with institutions — they engage with themselves”
The reason email opens and clicks mislead us — and why “the cheaper it is for an alum to do something, the less it tells you about who they are”
Belonging as a choice, and the three dimensions behind the Alumni Identity Score (salient, social, role)
The engagement gap: the high-identity alumni “living in joyful anonymity,” primed to give, that our dashboards can’t see
Why identity is mostly formed while students are still on campus — and how to activate it without eroding it
Where the research heads next: the identity-first model, escalation, and an “ideal donor score”
Try the 60-second quiz the panel took live: alumniidentity.com/score
Learn more and become a member at speakingengagement.org