Listen

Description

For Context: Ethnography Interlude

Episode # 05

🎙️ Episode Overview

Ethnography and Theology — Holding the Tension Together. In this special episode of For Context, hosts Gino Curcuruto and Luke Stehr dive into the unique intersection of ethnography and theology. They explore why social science is a critical tool for the modern pastor and how their personal research projects—ranging from church planting in Philadelphia to CrossFit gyms in Texas—revealed the hidden “backpacks” people carry into their faith. Listen in!

Episode Highlights

* Defining the Method: Luke breaks down the difference between quantitative sociology (surveys and big data) and ethnography, a qualitative approach involving participant observation, field notes, and semi-structured interviews.

* The “Backpack” Analogy: Drawing from Clemens Sedmak’s Doing Local Theology, the hosts discuss how every person arrives at faith with a “backpack” full of cultural assumptions, family traditions, and past experiences that shape their theology.

* Gino’s Research: Investigating why people stay at his church plant, The Table Philadelphia. He discovered that the “pace” of the community and a deep sense of belonging were more impactful than the theological framework alone.

* Luke’s Research: A study titled “Muscles, Faith, and Friends.” Luke immersed himself in a CrossFit-based men’s Bible study to observe how shared physical struggle facilitates emotional vulnerability and shapes masculine theological identities.

* The Prophetic Voice: Why a theology must be firmly rooted in a local context to be genuinely prophetic. To speak truth into a culture, you must first understand its language and “embodied participation.”

Resources Mentioned

Doing Local Theology- Clemens Sedmak

Writing Ethnographic Field Notes -Robert M. Emerson, Rachel I. Fretz, and Linda L. Shaw

The Glass Church - Mark Mulder & Gerardo Marti

Ecclesiology and Ethnography Network:

https://www.ecclesiologyandethnography.net/

For Context is sponsored by Northern Seminary. To learn more about the Contextual Theology program (or any of the number MA, M.Div, and D.Min offerings), visit seminary.edu.

📚 Resources

* Gino Curcuruto: Following Jesus Into the Ordinary

* Luke Stehr: Faith In Situ

🤝 Join the For Context Community

If you enjoyed this deep dive, consider becoming a paid subscriber to help us keep providing the context behind the news.

* Subscribe to the Newsletter: forcontextpod.substack.com

Leave a Review: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

(00:00:10):

I’m Gino Curcuruto.

(00:00:12):

I’m Luke Stehr.

(00:00:14):

And you’re listening to For Context.

(00:00:16):

A podcast about Northern Seminary’s doctorate of ministry in contextual theology.

(00:00:24):

Okay,

(00:00:24):

well,

(00:00:25):

we are doing kind of a shorter,

(00:00:27):

different episode today,

(00:00:30):

where it’s just Gino and I talking specifically about...

(00:00:35):

He’s here.

(00:00:37):

But today we’re just talking about ethnography and why it’s such an integral part

(00:00:41):

of Northern’s contextual theology program and why you would even do ethnography as

(00:00:47):

part of a doctorate where you’re focusing on theology.

(00:00:51):

Because it’s not,

(00:00:52):

I think we’re discovering that this program sits in a pretty unique space where we

(00:00:58):

are trying to hold some things together that don’t often get held together.

(00:01:03):

Yeah.

(00:01:04):

So, yeah.

(00:01:06):

Yeah,

(00:01:06):

I think the one of the questions that maybe people might have is like,

(00:01:11):

what is ethnography and then why ethnography?

(00:01:15):

I want to just say from the beginning that while I do have like a top three

(00:01:19):

favorite sociologists and ethnographers,

(00:01:23):

I think that I didn’t have a handle on that.

(00:01:26):

You don’t have to be that nerdy to do this program, by the way.

(00:01:29):

before I was unaware of the controversy between like the all theologians and social

(00:01:37):

science like I just wasn’t you know I didn’t I didn’t grow up in the church didn’t

(00:01:41):

grow up in those conversations of like now we’re gonna we’re gonna lose our

(00:01:45):

theology if we just move to what sociologists say or we’re gonna lose our

(00:01:50):

verifiableness if we don’t think like social scientists in the church and so I

(00:01:56):

don’t know Luke I don’t want to put you on the spot but like

(00:01:59):

Your experience with that,

(00:02:00):

your understanding,

(00:02:00):

or maybe even some responses to how these things are important together.

(00:02:06):

Yeah, I think there’s a growing familiarity with sociology in the church because I think...

(00:02:14):

But it’s more along the lens of a quantitative sociological approach.

(00:02:17):

And by that, I mean it’s analyzing survey data, watching kind of statistical trends.

(00:02:24):

It’s the administration of surveys and trying to get kind of the biggest.

(00:02:28):

Mm-hmm.

(00:02:46):

And I actually interviewed for that program.

(00:02:48):

I didn’t make it in, so that’s not really me bragging.

(00:02:51):

But I interviewed for that program years and years and years ago.

(00:02:54):

But it’s a quantitative program.

(00:02:57):

And so the focus of the program is in this administration of and making sense of

(00:03:05):

basically huge data sets.

(00:03:07):

So it’s a statistical analysis to try and make sense of what’s happening kind of at

(00:03:11):

a macro level across the board.

(00:03:14):

Yeah.

(00:03:15):

I’m a little salty because my proposed research topic,

(00:03:19):

and we’ve talked about this,

(00:03:21):

was the religious dimensions of the anti-vax movement.

(00:03:23):

And I proposed this in 2018, 2018.

(00:03:30):

And man.

(00:03:31):

You would have had like a National Institute of Health grant.

(00:03:34):

I would have, man.

(00:03:37):

So, Kevin Doherty, you could have had me.

(00:03:42):

Look at you.

(00:03:43):

Yeah.

(00:03:44):

So, yeah, I called out.

(00:03:47):

I have nothing but respect for that program.

(00:03:49):

But it’s a very different approach to sociology than ethnography,

(00:03:52):

which leans into the qualitative dimension of the social science.

(00:03:56):

And so, ethnography is not demography.

(00:03:58):

Demography being like the study of demographics.

(00:04:01):

It can make use of demography to help kind of formulate the background assumptions.

(00:04:05):

But it...

(00:04:06):

In some ways,

(00:04:08):

bleeds more into like a cultural anthropology lens in my mind and that you’re a

(00:04:13):

participant observer is kind of one of the hallmarks of ethnography.

(00:04:17):

So you situate yourself within a context.

(00:04:20):

Yeah.

(00:04:21):

At varying levels of participation,

(00:04:23):

and we can talk about that and how we conducted our ethnographies later.

(00:04:28):

But you situate yourself as a participant in a context where you let people know

(00:04:34):

that you’re observing them because you want to be ethical.

(00:04:37):

But then you take field notes.

(00:04:39):

So you kind of are trying to make some shorthand notes about what you’re observing,

(00:04:44):

what you’re seeing.

(00:04:45):

There’s a surprising amount of methodology behind how you do field notes.

(00:04:49):

Well, we read a book for Mark Mulder’s class called Writing Ethnographic Field Notes.

(00:04:55):

And it was a doozy of a book about how you take field notes.

(00:04:59):

And then you conduct semi-structured interviews.

(00:05:01):

So as you’re observing people...

(00:05:04):

As a participant, not some detached, objective person watching behind a one-way mirror.

(00:05:10):

You’re in it.

(00:05:12):

You also conduct interviews with people to get a sense of their experiences.

(00:05:15):

And then on the back end,

(00:05:17):

after you’ve done that observation and interviewing,

(00:05:19):

you want to basically use a coding process to pull together that data in a way that

(00:05:25):

starts to make sense of it.

(00:05:27):

So how do you start analyzing the themes that people...

(00:05:30):

Talked about the things that you noticed in the environment, the interactions.

(00:05:35):

Yeah.

(00:05:36):

That’s a very long-winded way to describe what ethnography is.

(00:05:40):

I think that’s a really h…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit forcontextpod.substack.com