The previous section detailed the raw observations on Windows and Services culture I saw after weeks of hearing about the situation from as many people as I could. I could not just put that out there without specifics of what I thought could improve. I had to put some structure on what I learned and to offer optimism and aspirations.
Back to 085. The Memo (Part 1)
Reflecting on this moment of both optimism and fear, today I look at the candor I expressed with a bit of amazement. I wrote with detail and assertiveness yet seemed to forget that I was writing about one of the most successful businesses ever created. I was writing about hundreds of billions of dollars of market capitalization. I was writing about many friends. At the same time, there was so much that needed to be improved or more specifically to be repaired. I think what really motivated me were all those 1:1s I did and hearing all the different people expressing their pain and troubles, knowing things could be better. This was not a team that was dug in ready to resist change. It was a team waiting for change. It just needed to be the right kind of change.
That reality made this much easier. I felt if I could document what was going wrong and the broad population agreed then I was on a path to addressing challenges. If I could articulate reasonable aspirational goals, then what remained was to build a product plan on that rebuilt foundation of trust in management.
I was quite worried that both the problems described and the aspirations I would document would seem cliché. With BillG in particular, over the years he had shown little patience for the broad topic of management. His world view was always that the business would be best served by taking on the most difficult technical problems and developers would be anxious to tackle such challenges. That recipe propelled Microsoft for twenty years of Windows but was failing us now. SteveB was never one for patience and while he would be receptive to these management challenges, he was far more anxious about a plan and the timeline for the next product to address the concerns that were mounting about Vista—the company hung in the balance. KevinJo had just orchestrated a massive restructuring of the global sales force before taking over most of product development. He was deeply in sync with the idea of identifying organizational problems then directly addressing those.
The memo, Observations, Aspirations, and Directions for Windows and Windows Live, proposed three mainareas to address: decision-making, agile execution, and discipline excellence. Each was presented in a section with both observations and aspirations.
These points will sound like random musings from any generic book on management, both at the time I wrote them and reflecting on them today. The lesson learned, using the phrase from the previous section, is to demonstrate that these are more than clichés by citing specific examples that resonate with the employees who are being asked to operate differently and specifics on exactly how we will achieve aspirations.
Decision-Making
Across all of Microsoft, “decision-making” had been a constant and nagging issue. We discussed it after every MS Poll (the yearly survey of employee attitude and feedback), and each year I was left puzzled. It had never been an issue for our team (in the MS Poll and other feedback channels). I didn’t understand what was so difficult about decisions. We made decisions all the time in Office, so many it wasn’t even clear to me what decisions were so difficult.
Then I arrived in the Windows hallway.
There, it was an endless discussion of who “owned” a decision or who was “accountable” and, worse, people were asking me what “model” I used to make decisions. This was a reference to classic models of business function (or more aptly dysfunction) that use tools known as a responsibility assignment matrix (RAM, one such tool) for decision-making. One labels participants as: Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, and Informed (or RACI). Another such tool, OARP, stands for Owner, Approval, Responsible, Participant. These tools consistently proved frustrating and there was little evidence that decisions were made with less effort or more importantly, more staying power or higher quality.
The use of these tools arose as a defense mechanism againstexecutives and managers who were prone to swoop and poop, a metaphor I learned as I assimilated into the team. As with birds, many managers seemed to show up at inopportune times, issue a quick opinion or edict, and not stick around for the mess they left behind. How much of this was actually a mess or simply a reaction to executive authority or inability to influence decision-making would take time to untangle. The expectation for me as a new Windows executive was that I had a tendency to employ this technique, no matter my own personal history or approach.
What I knew already to be the case turned out to be a big part of the problem, and that was a culture of escalation. In all software projects at scale, it is always the case that one team depends on another team—to provide code, consume code, integrate things together, and more. And this extends to sales and marketing connections. In Windows, escalation seemed to be the way most situations between teams were handled. It was a culture in which nothing was decided until people got in front of a VP, resulting in a culture where most of the middle management layer was biding time. And did I mention there were 7 or 10 management layers in Windows?
Weening the team off the culture of escalation proved to be one of the bigger cultural transformations I needed to make. It was also the root of challenges over many years of work between Windows and Office. In a culture of escalation, decisions made by people on the front lines, so to speak, rarely stick. In fact, escalation was done expressly to reverse lower-level decisions. If a Windows partner or collaborator doesn’t like the situation then an escalation ensues, and rarely did things stay the same. Office loathed escalation. Decisions were pushed down and stayed down. When people tried to escalate, they were told to work it out. The result was that when Windows tried to escalate decisions in working with Office they rarely got overturned, which proved enormously frustrating to Windows. And when Office tried to make plans, they would often find them upended at executive escalation meetings with Windows.
In Office, escalations happened so infrequently I cannot even recall any specific instances. In fact, we in Office had a saying that “escalation is failure.”
The primary downside of escalation is the way it shifts accountability. The winning side in an escalation feels an accountability not to the decision, but to winning the process of escalation. The losing side (and yes, they feel like they lost) does not feel bought into the decision and if it does go wrong, they too will join in the chorus of pushing blame up the chain. This is exact opposite of what you want to happen in times of making difficult decisions. The second-order effect is the obvious problem that as decisions are pushed up the chain there is less detail on execution related issues available, and usually that is where the trouble starts. These downsides were especially acute in mid-2000s Microsoft which was so much about improving accountability.
Given the crisis situation I was facing it would have been trivial to declare some sort of emergency and take control like a field general in a losing battle situation. Not only would this have been straightforward and arguably predictable, but it would also have fed right into the dysfunction that was already present. Sucking up all the difficulty would have been another management cliché, but one I could avoid.
Changing the culture surrounding escalation was going to be tricky. I decided to focus on consensus as a core tool for deci…