Download The Public SQ App and Join Me Here
“When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty.”― Thomas Jefferson
In 1919 World War I was in the rearview mirror of the country and there was a determination throughout the country to embrace the time of peace and to get on with the flow of life.
What better way to do this than with sport that we have often referred to here in the U.S. as the country’s “National Pastime.” During this time some of the most iconic figures in the sport of baseball would end up coming on the scene to transform the culture and to serve as the era of some of the most legendary names the sport has ever known.
However, in the country’s attempt to enjoy the National Pastime in 1919 there would end up being a dark cloud that loomed over the popular sport and that cloud would shed light on the shortcomings of human nature while also teaching us about the scams and corruption that can come about through the desire for money.
Even though the American citizen was ready for a change in the pace of life with having just gotten through a global war, the 1919 World Series was about to create some news headlines that would shock the world and forever change the view and direction of the National Pastime along with the mood of the country.
The Official Substack Of Brandon Richey is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
The 1919 World Series Scandal
In 1915 Charles Comiskey set out to buy the best players to build up his Chicago White Sox team. One of those players is the iconic American legend Joseph Jackson, or who you may more commonly recognize as the great Shoeless Joe Jackson.
Shoeless Joe Jackson was the best hitter of the time and allegedly earned the nickname Shoeless when having played a game in his socks due to his shoes having been too tight during one of his early games in Greenville, South Carolina.
In 1919 nobody would bet against the Chicago White Sox. During this time baseball was more than a sport, but rather a way of life.
However, when it came to the business of baseball Comiskey was one that ran that aspect of the game in his own way and his way wasn’t always a way that was popular among his players. Comiskey was a tight fisted businessman that was notorious for making his players promises regarding their agreements related to their compensation and would frequently not follow through. Sounds familiar with many of our modern day politicians, right?
Even worse, Comiskey was known for directly intervening in some circumstances by not allowing a player to play, particularly if a player was on the verge of earning promised wages based on hitting high benchmarks previously agreed to that would be related to that player’s game performance. In short, Comiskey would do anything to save a buck. (Source: History Channel)
To offer some additional understanding and to further illustrate Comiskey’s cheap nature in 1917 Comiskey had promised his players a bonus if they won him the pennant. They did so and he held up to his end of the deal by rewarding them with a case of cheap champagne and the sports writer Ring Lardner reportedly said that the champagne tasted like piss.
Now given this knowledge of Comiskey it wouldn’t take long for his players to understand this and it would ultimately lead to his team’s demise.
Just prior to the World Series first baseman Chick Gandil and fellow teammate Eddie Cicotte met up with a well known gambler and bookie at the time by the name of Joseph “Sport” Sullivan. Yes, believe it or not gambling was a huge part of the culture of sports at the time just as baseball was a huge part of the culture at large.
Now right here I wanted to interject to point out a very interesting thing that I discovered regarding a conflicting narrative that occurred with this meeting depending on which historical series of events you choose to believe involving what took place with this meeting. I’m about to point to a complete contradiction between two different sources regarding the events that took place among Eddie Cicotte, Chick Gandil, and Joseph Sullivan.
On one hand, if you read the account of this meeting according to Wikipedia the framing of this meeting was that Joseph “Sport” Sullivan was the one that approached the players Gandil and Cicotte to make them an offer of $10,000 per player if they could get about eight players in on a plan to throw the series against Cincinnati. According to Gandil this was a shock to him as he had always seen Sullivan as a gambler, but never took him to be a fixer.
However, according to the History Channel’s account of this Gandil was the one that sought out Sullivan and offered up the idea where he and several of his disgruntled teammates would organize a plan to throw the game if Sullivan could come up with enough money to make it worth the effort.
It was then said that Sullivan would end up offering $80,000 if the players would hold up their end of the deal. Although the Wikipedia version along with many serious baseball fans would want to reject the idea that the players actually initiated the scandal, the reality was that many games were fixed during that time regarding the history of the sport…and other sports as well.
So here you have two conflicting accounts on what happened during that meeting that would kickoff one of the most corrupt sports scandals in the history of all sports. So I wanted to take a moment to point this out as this is common when reading about certain historical events.
However, just like with anything in life we want to be Zenith and one way to do that is understanding the Zeitgeist and circumstances of that time in which we are examining. So on that note, given the fact that gambling was prevalent throughout the sports culture, given the fact that Comiskey was a cheap tight fisted businessman, and understanding that the potential payout of $10,000 per player was a solid amount of money that exceeded many annual salaries of the players to me it is much more logical that the players were the ones who were probably more proactive in organizing the scandal.
This doesn’t even factor in the knowledge that Gandil also had a shady history involving instances of theft and was also known as a brawler. Regardless, gambling at that time was just as much a part of baseball as popcorn and the 90 feet that exists between the bases.
Additionally the owners would turn a blind eye to the gambling as it was something that was difficult to prove not to mention the fact that addressing it would attract a negative press.
The possibility that certain White Sox players might throw the series prompted another gambler and ex-ballplayer named Sleepy Bill Burns to approach Gandil and Cicotte offering them and additional $100,000 to fix the series and now there were two sets of gamblers involved with the White Sox players with a total of $180,000 to sweeten the pot. (Source: History Channel)
Both sets of gamblers went to the one guy that could financially back such a deal in Arnold Rothstein. It was said that Rothstein, a notorious gambler and crime boss, would bet on anything except for the weather and that’s only because that was the one thing he couldn’t fix.
However, once the word had gotten out to the gambling world that the Sox would throw the games the gamblers came out in full force to lay down their bets on Cincinnati to win. As a result all of this started spinning out of control and the $100,000 promised by Burns never arrived and $80,000 fronted by Rothstein dwindled down to only $10,000.
The $10,000 that remained went straight to the pitcher Cicotte as the pitcher was the only one needed in order to secure the fix.
The White Sox dropped the first two games of the series, but the third game wasn’t in the bag. The third game was back in Chicago and Dickie Kerr was up for the next game as the starting pitcher.
However, I need to point out h…