The month of September duly lived up to its stock-killing reputation and there was a strong sense of good riddance from investors as markets closed on Friday. On the bright side, Octobers following losing Septembers have a history of being rather good for stock prices and November to December is historically a strong season.
Last week began with a predictable but mild snap-back rally on Monday after the carnage that had followed the outcome of the most recent Fed meeting the week before. But the relief was short-lived. By Tuesday, markets across the board were back in freefall after consumer confidence and expectation readings cratered and data showed new home sales plunging almost 9% in a month.
The mood was also not helped by announcements that Amazon is getting sued by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and by 17 states for so-called monopolistic practices and that Target is closing nine stores in four states, including one in Manhattan, due primarily to massive levels of organized retail theft (or “an increase in shrink” as corporate-speak calls it) and attacks on store staff.
The market took a breather on Wednesday and ended the day little changed - which was actually quite an impressive performance in the face of a big jump in oil prices that day to the highest level in over a year, a still-ripping US Dollar and the highest 10-year Treasury interest rates since Shaggy strongly protested that it wasn’t him in late 2000, dragging mortgage rates even higher (see AVERAGE 30-YEAR FIXED RATE MORTGAGE below).
And, of course, the sense then was that we had all moved one day closer to the world’s most pointless and unnecessary government shutdown caused by the “Burn It All Down” mob in Congress making a fool of the clueless and impotent Speaker Of The House. In the end, it seems that the can is simply being kicked down the road by a 45-day reprieve in last minute stop-gap measure which means we’ll likely go through all this utterly embarrassing s**t again before Thanksgiving.
Investors came back in with some cautious dip-buying on Thursday, sensing perhaps that things had maybe fallen a bit too far a bit too fast and both surging oil prices and the rocketing US Dollar pulled back a bit. But the buying felt like it lacked any passionate enthusiasm as stock prices seemed to tick up only grudgingly.
Friday saw a resumption of the slide after a brief morning spike resulting from some hopeful inflation data (see below) ran out of steam and hopes of avoiding a government shutdown seemed to evaporate. Wall Street traders trudged home in a horrendous Manhattan rainstorm, which seemed to sum up another gloomy week that ended a pretty miserable month and a difficult quarter (watch out for my Quarterly Market Review in the next few days).
There is a slight whiff of stagflation in the air (the toxic simultaneous combo of high inflation and unemployment and slowing growth, see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below) and that is a bad smell for stock markets. Any further data releases that point in that direction are not going to be well received by investors as they may pose an existential threat to the validity of the “Three Pillars” (1. No Landing / Soft Landing, 2. Disinflation, 3. Fed Done/Almost Done with Rate Hikes) upon which this year’s rally has been built. Indeed, these pillars are single-handedly the only rationale for stock prices being any higher in 2023 than they were in 2022 and if they begin to crumble then so could the entire stock market.
The final revision of Q2 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) showed last week that the rate of economic growth in the U.S. was unchanged from the second estimate, holding steady at an annualized rate of 2.1%. We also learned on Friday that the Fed’s favorite inflation measure, the Core Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) Price Index increased just 0.1% in August, lower than expected, indicating an annual core inflation rate of 3.9%, in line with expectations.
For a further meaningful decline to occur in stocks, we will have to see: 1) a clear slowing of growth and/or 2) a real rebound in inflation. To be clear, the data is not yet showing either of these right now and that’s a good thing.
Looking forward however, if the data does show either or even both problems occurring, do not be at all surprised by a swift 10-15% fall in stock prices (likely worse than that for tech names and YUC stocks) as the Three Pillars deteriorate. If the data shows that neither problem is happening, the S&P 500 could easily rally back a couple of hundred points higher from here. And, if the data remains mixed, contradictory or inconclusive, then expect conditions to continue to be choppy around current levels until such time as things break one way or the other.
So, what does a “Good” Outcome look like?
* More “good” inflation reports, meaning that the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Core PCE Price Index are flat or decline further
* Goldilocks growth including no decline in retail sales and no spike in consumer credit
* Mild and gradual softening of the labor market - monthly job creation in the mid-to-low 100k area, job openings back below 8m.
* An end to expected Fed interest rate hikes and at least two rate cuts in 2024.
* A solid Q3 earnings season, which begins on October 13th, particularly from the so-called Magnificent Seven, that’s Apple (AAPL), Alphabet (GOOGL), Nvidia (NVDA), Amazon (AMZN), Microsoft (MSFT), Meta Platforms (META) and Tesla (TSLA)
* Any government shutdowns only last for a few days at most.
What does a “Bad” Outcome look like?
* Inflation rebounds - CPI and Core PCE Price Index rise
* We get a growth scare e.g., retail sales fall, consumer credit deteriorates
* The labor market does not soften, meaning unemployment does not rise back up to around 4% and/or job openings remain stubbornly high.
* Markets come to expect another interest rate hike (probability viewed as being over 50%) and either zero or only one rate cut in 2024.
* Disappointing earnings for Q3 in general, but for the Magnificent Seven in particular
* Any government shutdowns last for two weeks or more
OTHER NEWS ..
Less For More .. Buying a home or car right now is proving unaffordable for many American households because of the toxic mix of massively higher borrowing costs and much higher prices. Consumers in the market for loans to buy homes and cars are discovering that, because of the Federal Reserve’s relentless 18 month campaign of interest rate increases, their money gets them a lot less than it did a few years ago. Meanwhile, those with credit cards and other loans that carry rates pegged to broader interest benchmarks like the 2-year or 10-year Treasury rates are finding that their balances have gotten much more expensive to maintain.
A Wall Street Journal report estimates that the typical American household would now need to use 42 weeks of income to buy a new car, up from 33 weeks just three years ago. And, as reported in last week’s issue of Angles, the National Association of Realtors now calculates that the typical American family can no longer afford to buy a median-priced home.
Another One Bites The Dust .. The Wall Street Journal reported that Hong Kong’s criminal investigation into crypto platform JPEX has led to the arrest of at least 11 people last week with allegations that it defrauded investors of $192 million. Police swooped in just days after the securities regulator warned investors that JPEX lacked a regulatory permit and that users had been blocked from withdrawing their funds. and platform providers were ordered to block its website and app locally. Hong Kong’s response comes after it introduced a strict new regulatory regime for cryptocurrencies four months ago.
The WSJ report quoted Lily Fang, professor of finance and dean of research at INSEAD business school near Paris, as saying “This unfortunately shows that allowing retail trading in this space, which is known to be fraud-prone, when investor education is sorely lacking, is a mistake.”
Not …