With trading volumes contracting rapidly, the stock market - at least as represented by the major indexes - was acting early last week like it had already checked out for summer and it’s not even May yet. It was proving to be something of a snooze-fest with a generally negative tilt as far as the headline indexes were concerned. But under the surface, things were playing out rather differently.
Earnings and guidance are generally holding up better than expected, mostly beating estimates at a good clip - notably Microsoft (MSFT), Alphabet/Google (GOOGL), Meta/Facebook (META) and Intel (INTC) last week. Indeed, 83% of non-financial companies have beaten earnings estimates so far this season (only 57% of financials).
This high beat-rate is, of course, a lot easier when the bar of these estimates has been consistently lowered by companies in considerably despondent forward guidance over the last couple of quarters banging on and on about how difficult 2023 was going to be. After all, the stock market is all about expectations versus reality.
Of some concern, however, is the fact that those firms whose earnings are failing to beat estimates seem to mainly be those that have their fingers on the pulse of the demand side of the economy, such as UPS, Caterpillar (CAT) and Packaging Corp of America (PKG) - and a number of these stocks got punished last week after announcing disappointing earnings and/or very cautious commentary/guidance.
So while macro-economic data is still broadly leaning towards a soft landing scenario (inflation to be conquered without a highly damaging recession), the micro-economic data around which types of companies are hurting more than others may be pointing in the other direction.
Early in the week, First Republic Bank (FRC) reported that customer deposits fell 40% or $72 billion in the first quarter during a ham-fisted earnings call. The already-incinerated stock got cut in half again in a matter of hours and then tumbled a further 30% the next day. On Friday, the stock price got cut in half yet again in the after-hours. While the market has now basically given up on First Republic as a viable stand-alone entity (rumors abound about a JP Morgan or PNC Bank absorption), the real damage will come if there are signs of further contagion into the likes of Zion Bank (ZION), Comerica (CMA), Bank of Hawaii (BOH) and Western Alliance (WAL).
It’s a sharp reminder that the banking sector is not yet out of the woods and indeed may well experience more pain ahead as a result of also being so entangled in the increasingly troubled world of commercial real estate that is suffering from enormously higher interest rates and vastly lower occupancy rates. A revival of banking stress simply isn’t priced into this market and its return will prove troublesome if it happens.
Stocks finished the week a touch higher after a mostly tranquil Monday, a difficult Tuesday and Wednesday but a powerful resurgence on Thursday and Friday as markets basked in the sunlight shone by earnings and guidance from some of the mega-cap tech names (FAAMG stocks, see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK BELOW). For the month of April, the S&P 500 added 1.5%, while the NASDAQ squeezed out just a small gain.
Congressional lawmakers’ continued reckless posturing around the debt ceiling appeared last week to have finally just about made it onto the radar of markets, although hardly in a meaningful way yet. For the moment at least, it still has the feel of a parent rolling their eyes after just noticing for the first time that their two toddlers are bickering over a toy. But the longer this nonsense goes on without resolution and the specter of 2011 starts emerging, the more nervous markets are going to get and the more a disastrous and completely unnecessary own goal becomes a possibility.
The Federal Reserve’s favorite inflation measure, the Core Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) Price index ticked down only slightly, showing 4.6% inflation year-on-year, down from 4.7% a month ago, denting the assumption that inflation is coming down hard and pretty much cementing the fact that the Fed will raise interest rates by another 0.25% this coming Wednesday (still hovering above an 80% probability, see FEDWATCH INTEREST RATE PREDICTION TOOL below).
At first glance, the second estimate (of three) of Q1 2023 US Gross Domestic Product (GDP) numbers looked grim; rising at an annualized rate of just 1.1% versus the median expectation of 1.9% and far below the 2.6% growth in Q4 2022.
The underlying details look more encouraging, however. The biggest drag by far came from a huge swing in business inventories but that category is highly volatile and subject to big quarter-to-quarter moves.
The data also confirmed that business activity is stalling out as borrowing costs rise. Spending on new buildings, equipment and more rose by just 0.7% in Q1 2023 as compared to 6.0% and 4.0% the two previous quarters.
The housing recession was the first to show itself as being affected by the Fed’s interest rate hike campaign that started exactly a year ago. But the worst may now be over, with the sector becoming less and less of a drag on growth. As recently as Q3 2022, residential investment was plunging at a 27% annualized pace. In Q1 2023, it declined at barely a 4% rate.
The interpretation of the GDP numbers actually pushed back on the idea of a hard landing and it was that which cleared the way for the strong earnings from many of the big dogs to catapult stocks meaningfully higher over the last couple of trading days, along with the market’s persistent faith in the Fed’s “hike/pause/pivot/cut” narrative, part one of which comes into play this week with the latest Fed interest rate decision announcement.
The way this narrative sees things panning out is that a 0.25% hike on Wednesday afternoon will be the last as the central bank heads into a period of pause before pivoting to rate cuts before the end of the year. Certainly very possible but, as I have been saying, this world-view is so accepted and widespread (the futures market says that the probability of rates being higher at the end of the year than they are now is quite literally only at 3%, even though the Fed is insisting that they will not cut in 2023) that there is a lot of potential for disappointment if things don’t quite go as planned and that disappointment could translate into lower prices.
OTHER NEWS ..
80%-off sale ..The Wall Street Journal reported last week that a 22-story glass-and-stone office skyscraper on California Street in San Francisco, once home to some of the world’s most valuable commercial real estate, is expected to draw bids of about $60 million, compared with an estimated value of over $300 million in 2019. The office market is being hit nationwide, but San Francisco’s blow was especially hard, for reasons including high costs, heavy reliance on a tech industry quick to embrace hybrid work, and quality-of-life issues such as crime and homelessness.
Bye, bye BBBY .. The effort to save Bed Bath & Beyond (BBBY) has finally failed and the stock is plunging into the abyss. The struggling retailer announced it had filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection after being unable to raise enough funds to keep it afloat and will liquidate.
The company explained that it would continue to keep its remaining 360 stores stores open for the time being, but would begin to “effectuate the closure of its retail locations.” Bed Bath & Beyond also noted that while it has already started its liquidation process, it intends to use the Chapter 11 proceedings to “conduct a limited sale and marketing process for some or all of its assets”.
The stock had been a favorite of so-called “meme-stock” novice amateurs who kept on buying it as part of a self-styled war against institutional short-sellers. It looks like the retail day-traders are ending up on the wrong side of things yet again.
Less smoke .. We're all smoking far less but the most dr…