The market spent the first three days of last week just shifting about in a bumpy, lethargic, generally downward-trending trading pattern, simply waiting it out for the main event in the form of the Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation number release due on Thursday morning. There was certainly no sign that the buyers from the week before were looking to capitalize on their brief success and take any kind of control.
Even when the starter course arrived on Wednesday in the form of a slightly hotter-than-expected measure of wholesale inflation, the Producer Price Index (PPI), there was little reaction in advance of CPI, the main course. PPI climbed 0.4% in September after a 0.2% decline in August. Compared to a year earlier, the index was up 8.5%, down from 8.7% the previous month as energy prices eased. The Core number, which excludes food, energy and trade services, rose 0.4% month-on-month, but this was largely in line with expectations.
The reaction to the CPI release when it did come out the next day before the market opened was quite extraordinary. And ultimately baffling. Month-to month inflation from August to September rose by 0.4%, twice as quickly as the expected 0.2% pace. Compared to a year ago, prices were up 8.2%. Last month, that figure was 8.3%. Core inflation, which strips out food and energy costs, rose 0.6% in a month in September, unchanged from the August increase. This Core measure is now up 6.6% from a year ago and that’s the highest since Joan Jett shared with us all that she loved rock ‘n roll back in 1982.
The Fed is desperately trying to get inflation under control, but you wouldn’t know it from looking at those numbers. While energy prices are falling hard, inflation in services, shelter and transportation is still running seriously hot and even the notoriously free-spending American consumer is going to be facing some very hard choices as we head into the winter and holiday season.
Sometimes the stock and bond markets just do exactly what you expect them to. This was the case when the opening bell rang on the stock exchange an hour after the release of the CPI data. Interest rates skyrocketed, with the 10 year Treasury soaring above 4.07% at one point, territory not seen since 2008. Stocks swiftly crumbled to new 2022 lows again and well beyond. Within a couple of minutes of the open, the S&P 500 had dived over 2.5% and the NASDAQ was down by more than 3%. Things looked downright apocalyptic.
And then the strangest thing happened. As if by magic, everything suddenly turned around for no apparent reason. By 11:15am, all the day’s losses had been extinguished and things just carried on higher and higher, with both indexes ending the day well over 2% up from Wednesday’s close having round-tripped 5% intra-day. The last time the stock market bounced back that far from an intra-day decline of that size was in August 2011.
Finding a sensible reason for the abrupt turnaround, however, proved surprisingly tricky. All I could find were some rather unconvincing explanations like:
* “Things have been miserable for while and we were due for a bounce”. If the indexes had finished lower on Thursday, they would have logged their longest losing streak since February 2020.
* “Rent inflation may not be as bad as the CPI report showed”. Rents are factored into CPI on a lagging basis, meaning that the trend for shelter inflation might not actually be as awful as it appeared in the CPI report, since rent costs appear, anecdotally at least, to be moderating in real time.
* “Inflation remained high, but no one was expecting it to be low”. If inflation causes the Fed to tighten monetary policy too much, it would eventually correct course by loosening monetary policy again. That would, in theory, be good news for stocks (this one I found to be particularly absurd).
* “A technical bounce on the charts”. The initial price falls first thing in the morning hit some ancient trend-line drawn on some chart going back years and the market has a long memory.
Those all seem like poking around to find pennies in a fresh pile of cow dung to me, retro-fitting some tiny silver lining to a very large cloud. I could not find a single compelling reason given for the exceptional price spike and, believe me, I looked.
And so, while the champagne corks were popping on the New York Stock Exchange and giddy talk abounded that we had finally found “The Bottom”, a good number of us were just scratching our heads asking “WTF did we just see? And why?”
It took just 24 hours for this latest false start to be exposed as sham built on nothing. By the end of yet another ugly Friday, both the S&P 500 and the NASDAQ had had yet another losing week.
Beyond the CPI number, other factors also weighed on stocks last week. A number of Chinese cities moved to reimpose COVID lockdowns, but the main external culprit was across the pond.
Renewed turmoil in the UK government bond and currency market reached a crescendo on Friday after the Bank of England (BOE) refused to extend its program of stabilization through market intervention and British finance minister Kwarteng was summoned home early from Washington DC where he was meeting with his counterparts from around the world, only to be fired by a text from Prime Minister Liz Truss as soon as his plane landed, triggering a full blown political crisis to add to the financial chaos.
The global financial markets, the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK), most of Britain’s leading economists, the bulk of Truss’ own rebelling party and the vast majority of the UK electorate had all already expressed varying degrees of despair and/or anger at the bizarro-world plan of apparently unfunded massive tax cuts announced by Kwarteng that now apparently threatens the financial stability of the fifth largest economy in the world and a blood sacrifice was required. The smart money has Truss gone by Christmas.
OTHER NEWS
Ugly .. The IMF cut its global economic growth forecast for next year, warning that “the worst is yet to come.” It reduced its 2023 outlook from a gain of 2.9% in July to 2.7% now, with a 25% probability it could fall below 2.0%. That’s the weakest estimate since 2001, except during the global financial crisis and the outbreak of COVID. The World Bank endorsed these miserable prognoses.
Having said that, the ARTICLE OF THE WEEK below emphasizes how rubbish people and organizations are at making predictions.
Nice bump, but .. About 66 million Social Security recipients will see their benefits rise 8.7% starting in January, the highest inflation-linked cost-of-living adjustment since 1981, but the soaring cost of food, rent and other essentials means it won’t stretch that far for most of them.
The average $1,656 retirement benefit will increase by $144.10. The standard Medicare Part B monthly premium will decrease by $5.20 for 2023, which will further boost the checks of recipients who get their premiums automatically deducted from their Social Security checks.
However, more of retirees’ income could be subject to federal income taxes. The IRS will soon announce the 2023 standard deduction and the inflation-adjusted dollar thresholds for each income tax bracket, which could eat into many retirees’ take-home.
UNDER THE HOOD:
The Percent of Stocks 30% or More Below One Year Highs is an important measure of the most beaten-down stocks. It not only shifted higher when the June-August bear market rally died, but it has since returned to levels worse than it recorded at the June 16th low. In other words, such low prices did not spark committed buying in this supposedly “on sale” area of the market. This is suggestive of a lack of desire to even nibble on stocks, let alone enthusiastically backing up any trucks.
The same conclusion can be drawn from the fact that 80% of all stocks are now below their 10-week moving averages, a historically extremely low level which usually triggers swift dip-buying, but…